• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • A Herd of Independent Minds
Uncategorized

A Herd of Independent Minds

By jennifer
September 16, 2005

Owen Harries writes in today's Financial Review,

"On political matters, intellectuals tend to share two characteristics: they are slaves to fashion; and on the big questions, they tend to get things hopelessly wrong."

Harries proceeds to give a few thousand words of relevant examples beginning with,

"If you had been a man of affairs living in 1910 or thereabouts, it is likely that you woiuld have been well aware of the increasing tense international atmosphere, as Germany not content with having the most powerful army in the world, sought to challenge Britian as a leading naval power. But if you had been an intellectual living in the same period, chances are you would have subscribed to the view, propagated by Norman Angell in The Great Illusion, that war was a dying institution... "

The Club of Rome predictions in the 1970s - that unless we limit population and industrial growth the world would self-destruct by the end of century - are included in Harries list.

Harries asks, "Why do intellectuals get things so wrong, so often? The question is worth asking because they are still with us, still vocal, still taken seriously by many as the interpreters of the course of human history. A large part of the answer, surely, lies in the intellectuals' search for - demand for - coherence in human affairs, for pattern, for meaning and consistency. Once this was found in the form of religion; for the past hundred years or more, most intellectuals have found it in the form of ideology."

Does this provide some insight into how and why some of our most revered environmentalist academics get it so wrong - from Paul Ehrlich to Ian Lowe?

........................

The piece by Owen Harries titled 'The parochialism of the present' is to appear "simultaneously in the inaugural issue of The American Interest" at www.the-american-interest.com. But I can't find it there.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. I am happy to be considered an intellectual along with Lowe, Flannery and Quiggin. Just cranky they misrepresent my work - in my view because it does not support the ideological position they defend.

  2. Well Rog - while you right wing dudes are wallowing in a soup of self congratulatory rhetorical drivel some of us are keeping up with the literature.

    I just happened upon this while having my chamomile tea and rocket-leaf whole grain sandwich.....

    Read it and weep boyo ...

    Science, Vol 309, Issue 5742, 1844-1846 , 16 September 2005

    [DOI: 10.1126/science.1116448]

    Changes in Tropical Cyclone Number, Duration, and Intensity in a Warming Environment

    P. J. Webster,1 G. J. Holland,2 J. A. Curry,1 H.-R. Chang1
    We examined the number of tropical cyclones and cyclone days as well as tropical cyclone intensity over the past 35 years, in an environment of increasing sea surface temperature. A large increase was seen in the number and proportion of hurricanes reaching categories 4 and 5. The largest increase occurred in the North Pacific, Indian, and Southwest Pacific Oceans, and the smallest percentage increase occurred in the North Atlantic Ocean. These increases have taken place while the number of cyclones and cyclone days has decreased in all basins except the North Atlantic during the past decade.

    1 School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, USA.
    2 National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, CO, USA.

    We deliberately limited this study to the satellite era because of the known biases before this period (28), which means that a comprehensive analysis of longer-period oscillations and trends has not been attempted. There is evidence of a minimum of intense cyclones occurring in the 1970s (11), which could indicate that our observed trend toward more intense cyclones is a reflection of a long-period oscillation. However, the sustained increase over a period of 30 years in the proportion of category 4 and 5 hurricanes indicates that the related oscillation would have to be on a period substantially longer than that observed in previous studies.

    We conclude that global data indicate a 30-year trend toward more frequent and intense hurricanes, corroborated by the results of the recent regional assessment (29). This trend is not inconsistent with recent climate model simulations that a doubling of CO2 may increase the frequency of the most intense cyclones (18, 30), although attribution of the 30-year trends to global warming would require a longer global data record and, especially, a deeper understanding of the role of hurricanes in the general circulation of the atmosphere and ocean, even in the present climate state.

    Ian Lowe may have the last laugh after all...

    We love you Ian - "they know not what they do - forgive them their sins..."

    Don't you just hate those left-wing intellectual smart alecks doing research ?

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *