According to Opposition environment spokesman Anthony Albanese the latest issue of science journal 'Science' provides,
"A scientific basis for what the Government was told in its climate change risk and vulnerability report just two months ago".
And when the 7.30 Report interviewed me they indicated that the science was already settled. So how does this report value add? Is it really definitive? Is the opposition a couple of months behind the government in accepting "the reality of climate change".
Albanese is reported as stating, "Australia is at risk because of the higher incidence - in this case - the scientists have reported a doubling of category four and five cyclones and hurricanes."
The same news reports states,
"The research, from the University of Georgia and the National Centre for Atmospheric Research in Colorado, shows that high-strength cyclones have nearly doubled in 35 years in all five of earth's ocean basins.
"Global data indicate a 30-year trend toward more frequent and intense hurricanes," the researchers said.
However, scientists say they lack enough data to be definitive, because the period studied in the report is too short.
They also say other factors, such as El Nino current or humidity play a role in the intensity of tropical storms."
Now why didn't they include the data from the 1940s - the last time the US had lots of intense hurricanes?
Who has read the paper in the new issue of Science?
John
I note you have glossed over all the other points and gone back to the cherry picking on the CRU data.
I have to tell you that you statistical argument on trends would not pass Introduction to Statistics 101. You cannot say anything in these short term runs. As I said it may be that 2005 is warmer - if it is - "on your argument" you'll be in trouble. Myself I would look at a longer time period.
You make a big argument about things "not being that simple" and then you "assume" that CO2 will increase linearly every year and that every year MUST be a record. Not that's illogical. If you think at the current level of forcing and with the various other issues like El Nino occurring and you think you will see that - well I'm speechless.
And I agree with you about 1998 and El Nino - but there have been past El Ninos too - why weren't they the warmest ? 1982/83 was a whooper. Do some research on the effects of global temepratures by El Ninos - it may help explain things.
If you're right - it will be Nobel prize winning stuff - but before you rush off to Science or Nature to claim the ground - then take your stats argument to any maths teacher or uni stats dept and see if they think it would be publishable. I'm telling you they will politely show you the door.
On stats - climate guys obsess over it - look up the mathematics of validation and cross validation.
The reason you should that the next few years come in cold is that if the temps go up your argument here is irrelevant, spurious, unscientific and wrong. You are the one saying it's a cooling trend. If you are not I don't understand what you're saying.
And if you won't go back before 1940 (strangely lops off a nasty tail eh) - well we must not talk about any Little Ice Age data - because anecdotal evidence is heresay and there were no accurate temperature recordings - your logic not mine ! You can't have it both ways John. It's interesting that those researchers who have patiently put the pre-1940 record together have wasted their time. And if they are wrong - well don't trust the CRU as you have done as they are citing pre-1940 figures. Gee if that's the level of their science (on your logic not mine) don't trust them.
I'm afraid the observational data does support the hypothesis - and a wide range, based on physics, trends, data and models - not just a few cherry picked numbers. The Swiss guys have calculated the flux.
Models - so flawed to be useless - list out your long reasons why. Many many journal articles on validation must be in error.
On Australia losing energy - well it all depends - big droughts may provide a reinforcing feedback mechanism - the opposite of what you're saying.
And on heat flowing to the poles - I thought you were saying Antartica was getting cooler. ?? Haven't thought about effects on circumpolar vortex have you?
Don't worry about satellites to be launched/just launched - the ones already up there say that the troposphere has warmed. Were'nt you saying the opposite only a few months ago?
On the IPCC tweaking their models. Well no - it's a bit more complicated than a simple regression. They don't fit data like that. If you model the separate forcings wyou don't explain the variation. If you add them you do. And they do explore more than a point in time (from your words)- a whole line of points in fact.
And you are right on models - they have a long way to go. And it seems that when corrected, the warming may be even greater - not less than predicted
You are a cherry picker I'm afraid. You pluck little bits of flotsam and jetsam from very small runs of data and then try make a whole construct around it. Not even serious skeptics do that.
You have not provided one single mechanism for what you are seeing. You just keep saying - "well duh - it has happened before so "
Phill,
Isn't the soap-box getting a bit uncomfortable now?
You say "1998, 2002, 2003 and 2004 were the hottest years on record" - but be HONEST here and and say IN ORDER OF DECREASING TEMPERATURES.
Sure 8 years is not a long period but the declining temperatures in this period may well be indicative that the period of warming has ceased and temperatures are now FLAT.
Phil, I do what Ender said one should do; I look at the data not the varierty of spin/opinions. I use
http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/data/temperature/ as the prime source of global and hemispheric data.
When I said warmest in about 60 years of warming I did so with a very good reason. If you bothered to look at the CRU data you'll find that they indicate the percentage of the world covered by accurate observations. In 1945 that coverage was 50% - in other words we lacked reliable data for 50% of the world. Any average global temperatures would be very speculative.
Do you know about the "Little Ice Age" of about 1857? Global coverage was about 17 or 18% and I'll bet that was Europe, the USA, Canada and almost nowhere else. I wonder if the Little Ice Age was anything more than a phenomenon of the Northern Hemisphere and maybe only the US, Atlantic and Europe?
Thanks for mentioning 1999, 2000 and 2001. These show how easy it is for temperatures to fall despite the levels of CO2 (if you believe that sort of thing).
The big difference between Australian and Global temperatures is that heat energy can easily disappear from Australia but in a global picture it can keep circulating. Hence the well-documented disperson of warm equatorial waters to the polar regions takes several years and causes warming along the way. Get another El Nino while this is happening and there's a good chance that we'll now have two regions of warmth.
Also, what happens when warmer waters reach the polar regions? The heat goes wherever the winds and ocean current take it. Sometimes this means icebergs break off and sometimes it means warmer winds blowing across another region and moving the heat around.
(I think I've said it before but maybe not - it's like pouring milk into hot black coffee and analysing each swirl of warm and cooler currents.)
Actually we do know what caused 1998 to be the warmest year regards global averages. The Southern Hemisphere warmed more than usual and becaus ethis coincided with NH warming, the average was higher than usual. The reason for the warming? An analysis of the monthly anomalies makes it pretty damn certian that it was caused by a very strong El Nino. Of course all this might be a coincidence but the chances are not high...
I assume the graph that you claim the IPCC models reproduce is the trends graphs. I wonder how many times those models has to be tweaked - as in the parameterizations be adjusted - in order to approximate the trend graphs. I suspect that the best you could say is that the graphs were able to match a particular situation at a particular point in time. According to detailed analysis (by others) and my own efforts, I can tell you that the models are still a long, long way from accurate predictions.
Don't believe me? Well, a satellite was just launched - or is about to be - to take a good look at clouds because it is well known that the algorithms for handling cloud in climate models are very poor.
Finally, why should I hope 2005-07 comes in cold of that temps start to go back to 1940 levels? You're the one making big claims about continued warming being caused by increasing carbon dioxide.
I'm saying that
(a) the OBSERVATIONAL DATA does not support your glib assertions
(b) the models that you hold in high regard are so flawed as to be useless
(c) that warming is irregular while carbon dioxide increases pretty uniformly and so if CO2 is having any effect at all it is very small (which casts further doubt upon the models)
You claims simply do NOT stack up! If you were honest, you would acknowledge that fact and investigate why.
cheers
John
Phil tried to post this comment yesterday AM - but was again excluded with message 'inappropriate comment'. It seems there is a problem with posts that include too many or at least 4 fullstops ... at least that is one theory. So try and limit the full stops... to three.
Best Jen.
********************
I don't think you would survive statistics 101 I'm afraid. Short trends and
outliers are introductory materials.
OK Last year was cooler than 2003, which was cooler than 2002. And 1998 was
warmer than all three.
But barring some small short-term variation, global temperatures are rising
inexorably. 1998, 2002, 2003 and 2004 were the hottest years on record. Nine
of the 10 hottest years have been in the past decade. 19 out of the 20 warmest
years have been since 1980. And the same sources are mooting that 2005 may be
hotter than all of them ?!
If it is you'll have to back peddle won't you - but you wouldn't as you'd
say "but but but - it's only one number.." 1998 is a considerable El Nino - of
course it will be a spike. You have to filter out El Nino/La Nina effects in
these data..
Have a look at
http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/
info/warming/
Here is the spatial view…
http://lwf.ncdc
.noaa.gov/oa/climate/research/trends.html
“Warmest in our 60 years of recording" you say - you thought we
didn't notice did you... are you saying we have no measurements before 1944 -
are you sure...
John you could have taken a bet between 1940 and 1950 that the world was
cooling and for a short time you'd be right. And then you'd be massively wrong
on the long run as the greenhouse forcing (or add your explanation here) took
over.
And why leave out 1999, 2000, 2001 - you would have been overjoyed at the
time - then it warmed up again. Short term trends are not that helpful…and
statistically insignificant. No body ever said every year will be a record –
where has the IPCC said that ?
And every one-off record that gets broken can’t be attributed to climate
change either (and the corollary also holds true – you can’t rule it out
either). You simply don’t have enough information with a single datum or few
data to say anything.
The above graph has been well reproduced by IPCC models which factor in
volcanic, solar and green house forcings. There are interacting effects - but
the overall trend is
up up up... and the only hypothesis we have is CO2 borne out by some good
physics - direct measurement - see above in thread - solar and volcanoes don't
help
explain anything. And if you remove global dimming damper from increased cloud
reflectivity and soot - well maybe the trend will be even bigger than we have
now ...
You'd better hope that 2005-07 comes in cold ... and that temps overall start
heading back to 1940s levels real quick.
Phil.
Ender,
You say ...
----
"Functioning scientists are the ones who do this:
"verified through observation, formulation of testable statements to explain those observations, and controlled experiments or additional observations to find out whether these ideas are right or wrong."
Your 'scientists' simply pick apart line by line the working scientists work to find any tiny mistake which is then trumpted as 'proof' that AGW is wrong.
How about they get on with the observing part in the real atmosphere with instruments.
----
Noble aims but unfortunately too often characterised in the pro-warming lobby by the assumption that (a) an observation has one cause only and (b) the existence of a correlation, no matter how weak, means that one element is driving the other.
Be assured that I am not exaggerating a 'tiny mistake' when I look at the CRUs compilation of observations of the atmosphere recorded with instruments.
As far as I can see right now the case for AGW is non-existent because the period of warming is NOT continuing.
What you must find even more galling is the lack of warming despite the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide (according to the observations of the atmosphere recorded with instruments).
Let's review your statements in the light of this reason lack of warming..
"verified through observation" - no AGW verified here mate, not when temperatures aren't rising
"formulation of testable statements to explain those observations" - Sorry you fail again. AGW believers explain warming as a consequence of an increase of carbon dioxide. We've got the CO2 increase but not the warming so the AGW statements fail the test. (And so do a whole bunch of climate models!)
"and controlled experiments..." - tough one. Shall we turn the sun up a notch to see what the extra radiation does? YOU turn it up and I'll watch what happens...
"... or additional observations to find out whether these ideas are right or wrong." - Right now the AGW ideas are looking very WRONG!
Real Science - as you define it - shows that your claims are bunkum !
Have a nice day,
John
I'm still waiting Phill ...
1998 - 0.58 (warmest in our measly 60 years of recordings)
2002 - 0.475 (hottest since 1998)
2003 - 0.475 strange - no increase!
2004 - 0.455 even cooler !
DO YOU CALL THIS WARMING OR COOLING ?
John
rog - Real Science is this:
"Evolution is a valid scientific theory for the origin of species that has been repeatedly tested and verified through observation, formulation of testable statements to explain those observations, and controlled experiments or additional observations to find out whether these ideas are right or wrong. A scientific theory is not speculation or a guess — scientific theories are unifying concepts that explain the physical universe.
This quote is from http://www.aas.org/governance/council/resolutions.html#teach
and as you can see pertains to Evolution however if you take out the evolution part and substitute Global Warming then these people say it much better than I can.
Functioning scientists are the ones who do this:
"verified through observation, formulation of testable statements to explain those observations, and controlled experiments or additional observations to find out whether these ideas are right or wrong."
Your 'scientists' simply pick apart line by line the working scientists work to find any tiny mistake which is then trumpted as 'proof' that AGW is wrong.
How about they get on with the observing part in the real atmosphere with instruments.