• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Cost of 'Green' Electricity
Uncategorized

Cost of 'Green' Electricity

By jennifer
January 16, 2006

My colleague Alan Moran, had an article published in Melbourne's Herald Sun on the weekend. I was interested in his comment about the relative cost of different electricity sources in a Victorian context. He wrote:

"Extracting carbon dioxide from brown coal, even in the embryonic pilot schemes now on the drawing board, would double the cost of electricity generation. Not only would this have a direct on the consumer but it would, at a stroke, undermine the State's commercial competitiveness.

If we were serious about reducing carbon emissions we would be embracing nuclear power.

At least we know this is only double the cost of coal power.

But even such a modicum of commonsense wilts in the hands of ministers who are prisoners of the green left.

Mr Thwaites released a paper shortly before Christmas calling for a doubling of the electricity derived from wind power.

We know wind power is expensive and unreliable but in making the proposal, he did not even try to estimate its cost to the ordinary consumer or to the State."

Good Causes

Comments

  1. For an extensive wind farm impact analysis see this Heemskirk development proposal in Tasmania. It depended in 2003 somewhat on the Bass Link and relies on existing hydro development. This is probably our green energy at its best but what a sensitive environment.

    http://www.dpiwe.tas.gov.au/inter/nsf/Attachments/SSKA-
    5J3397/$FILE/Heemskirk_proj_summ.pdf

    Note the sand flies around there will surely warm you on a bad day.

  2. L A Times...California Think?

    Try cost of compliance with batty scenarios.

    Its no secret Cal is going down the financial gurgler, no forward planning for energy, plenty of wacky schemes with no tangible result except high bills that has meant business is leaving Cal in truckloads.

  3. considering landscapes and population distribution, wind and solar energy in Aust might deserve comparison with california and tex as more so than with northern europe. It was announced late 2005 that xcel Energy Colorado wind power was now cheaper than natural gas and coal power sources (and Oklahoma and Tex as wind power was becoming competitve with gas and coal). I suspect it was due to local factors such as hurricanes increasing gas prices. however, the lower prices were announced as a permanent offer starting january 2006.

    almost useless abstract only now unless yo pay:) http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/911646041.html?dids=911646041:911646041&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Oct+15%2C+2005&author=Nicholas+Riccardi&pub=Los+Angeles+Times&edition=&startpage=A.18&desc=Windfall%3F+No%2C+but+Savings+Ahead

Write a Comment