In the following blog post Adele Major, Web Editor, Greenpeace Australia Pacific, explains why Greenpeace does not believe sustainable whaling is possible and provides links to more video evidence:
Last I read you are an "environmental blogger" so logically I would assume you are interested in the actual environmental impact of whaling, rather than entire threads devoted to your interpretation of an inconclusive piece of footage on a pro-whaling website.
Is sustainable whaling possible?
I am not a marine mammal expert, and don't claim to be, although I have read a lot about this issue. However the information below was prepared by John Frizell, whale campaigner and Greenpeace's representative at the IWC, who is an expert on issues related to whaling.
"Everywhere whaling has been practised, including around the coast of Japan, it has lead to depletion of whale populations. That's why Japan started Antarctic whaling in the 1930s, their own coastal waters were already showing marked drops in catch after 30 years of whaling using imported technology.
The statistics say it all. The blue whales of the Antarctic are at less than 1 percent of their original abundance, despite 40 years of complete protection. Some populations of whales are recovering but some are not.
Only one population, the East Pacific grey whale, is thought to have recovered to its original abundance, but the closely related West Pacific grey whale population is the most endangered in the world. It hovers on the edge of extinction with just over 100 remaining.
For this reason we believe commercial whaling should not be attempted again. In the case of the Southern Ocean, the IWC has made it a whale sanctuary where no whaling is permitted. So Japan's 'research' program is gathering data to set commercial catch limits on a population for which commercial whaling has been forbidden.
Recent DNA evidence shows that the impact of commercial whaling may be even worse than previously thought. Most estimates of historic whale population size have been extrapolated from old whaling figures, but this method is often very inaccurate, argues marine biologist Steve Palumbi of Stanford University's Hopkins Marine Station in California, USA.
In 2003 Palumbi and his colleagues used DNA samples to estimate that humpback whales could have numbered 1.5 million prior to the onset of commercial whaling in the 1800s. That number dwarfs the figure of 100,000 previously accepted by the IWC based on 19th century whaling records. Humpback whales currently number only 20,000.
In the case of the Southern Ocean, Japanese delegates to the International Whaling Commission (IWC) constantly refer to a 1990 estimate of the Antarctic minke population of 760,000. But that figure was withdrawn by the IWC in 2000 because recent surveys found far fewer minkes than the older ones. The new estimates are half the old in every area that has been resurveyed. The IWC's scientists do not understand the reasons for this and so far have not been able to agree a new estimate. A substantial decline in Antarctic minke population has NOT been ruled out.
Additonally, whaling is no longer the only threat to whales. The oceans, or rather, human impacts on the oceans, have changed dramatically over the half-century since whales have been protected. Known environmental threats to whales include global warming, pollution, overfishing, ozone depletion, noise such as sonar weaponry, and ship strikes. Industrial fishing threatens the food supply of whales and also puts whales at risk of entanglement in fishing gear.
Expectations for the recovery of whale populations have been based on the assumption that, except for commercial whaling, their place in the oceans is as secure as it was a hundred years ago. Sadly, this assumption is no longer valid. This is why we believe that whaling in all forms must be stopped."
This year, fin whales will be added to the hunt. Fin whales are the second biggest creature on earth after the blue whale, and are listed as 'endangered'. There is no justification for hunting an endangered species. Very little is known about southern fins and most civilised cultures recognise the need to preserve biodiversity and conserve species that are endangered and protected (such as in Australian waters which they migrate through).
By the way, in the interests of a balanced approach for your readers, I would suggest you also link to our footage, available in longer form here and with a voiceover here. And since it seems you are also an expert on maritime navigation regulations and are calling for the resignation of Captain Sorensen based entirely on this piece of video, you can read his own account of his actions, click here.
As I have mentioned previously, Greenpeace is committed to a long history of non-violent protest and ramming is not a tactic we use.
End of text from Adele Major.
Ahem, why is everybody talking about whales? This whole "whale" thing is not about whales but fish. I've been reading the Japan Fisheries Website and aside from the fact that some of the links are broken, I feel as though I'm being lectured at by my high school headmistress, eg - intro "We, the Whaling Section of Japan, are dealing with a variety subjects, probably, more than you expect"
I didn't know what to expect after that but here's an example from the Q & A section:
Q Will research catches further deplete endangered species?
A "Certainly not, most species of whale are not endangered. In fact, based on scientific data endorsed by the International Whaling Commission’s Scientific Committee, we can say that many species are abundant..."
here's another Q & A.
Q What has been learned from Japan’s research programs?
A "Much has been learned about the feeding habits of whales through analysis of stomach contents. The research has found for example that whales are consuming 3 to 5 times the amount of marine living resources as are caught for human consumption. In the waters around Japan we have a situation of declining catches in certain fisheries while at the same time the sampling from our research program reveals that minke whales are eating at least 10 species of fish including Japanese anchovy, Pacific saury, walleye Pollock and other commercially important species..."
In fact this "stomach analysis" occurs also on the ICR website see http://www.icrwhale.org/eng-index.htm wherein there are photographs of the stomach contents of slaughtered whales.
It is clear that there will not be any solution to this issue until we accept the real agenda of whale-killing nations. That is, fish, not whales. In fact, although I have never tasted whale, I can't imagine it would taste too good -rather tough and tasteless like those overgrown turkeys that appear in the shops around Christmastime (which I wouldn't eat either). According to other posts on other websites, only older Japanese eat whale, and young Japanese don't have a taste for it.
What is the answer then? As awful as it sounds, the non-whaling nations will have to give fishing rights to the Japanese (and other whaling countries) equivalent of the amount of fish consumed by all these whales they kill. Only then will they feel not so hardly done by. In the process, non-whaling nations will have to eat less fish. This doesn't bother me, I'm a vegetarian. I can't stomach any of this brutality.
Will this happen? Going by history, not much happens without force.
Yours
Marine - Melbourne.
Plagiarism, piracy - there is no end to the perfidy of the modern enviro-warrior.
And re-popularised by Woody Allen's "Annie Hall" 1977.
Groucho & Woody both lefties so I'm sure you would not approve.
Plagiarisng Marx Bros Phil? - Groucho would not be amused.
Just like Forestry is your meal ticket.
On meal tickets.. ..
Just all medical research is false if done by doctors.
All geological research is false if done by geologists.
All forestry research is false if done by foresters.
Come on - that's b/s and outrageous. The usual tactic by you right wing guys is to withhold research funding so nobody is informed. Typical !
"self rationalisation of the criminal mind" - what a piece of hilarity - can hardly stand up for laughing - spare us the rhetorical b/s or save it for your Honours in Sophistry.
And yes like Rog with his 4 x 2 peace stick - we have the right wingers now resorting to personal violence as a solution. Ian wants the Yakuza who he probably has on standing offer contract for dealing with demonstrators anyway (sigh). Better still - why not harpoon them ? Even better let's nuke the southern ocean and get all the whales and demonstrators in one hit.
So like Rog - be condemned for your inaction and preference for extinction. So much for foresters as conservationists.
P.S. That was the royal "we" - are not amused.
P.P.S. Not a member of any NGO, including Greenpeace, and have no vested interest in the matter. It's personal. I would not want to belong to any club that would have me a as member.
Phil, I note that you have used the plural "we" in reference to the actions of Greenfarce. Do you have an undeclared interest here or is this just a by-product of high dudgeon?
The IWC is a self selected, unrepresentative body with a very high proportion of small maritime states that are beholden to Aust/UK et al. It has always had the stench of an ALP branch list at preselection time.
Any country can opt out of IWC at any time and can opt out of any provision. Any country can refuse to recognise a territorial claim made by another nation over ocean that is outside the territorial and fishing limits and beyond the continental shelf.
So your little list of broken provisions is no different to the numerous broken provisions of The Intergovernmental Agreement on the Environment by Australian states in their treatment of farmers. According to the Minister, there are no compliance provisions because the agreement is not binding. Ditto all the bumph from the IWC.
An international covenant does not become binding law in a country that has merely ratified it. It must also have specific enabling legislation, properly enacted in its own legislature, to create a legal obligation on the citizens of that country. No such legislation appears to have been passed in either Australia or Japan.
This is not the case for acts of piracy, reckless endangerment and negligence. So this line about unlawful acts to prevent other unlawful acts is nothing but the self rationalisation of the criminal mind.
And, Laura, of course the 200 scientists at IWC want more research, it is their meal ticket.
The alternative to lawful protest is bring on the Yakuza. Lets see some Bushido boogie on the high seas.