I was going to title this blog post 'Martin Ferguson for Prime Minister' - but I don't really know that much about Martin Ferguson.
He gave a great speech in defence of Tasmanian foresters some weeks ago, click here.
Yesterday The Australian newspaper published him asking that we move beyond politics and embrace the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate.
The speech and the article are revolutionary because Ferguson is a senior member of the Labor Party and he is taking a stand against traditional green politics yet over recent years the Labor Party has not only consulted with, but encouraged environmental activists, including Don Henry from the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF), to write Party policy (see the Latham Diaries).
Ferguson is redefining what it means to be an environmentalist and reshaping environmental politics in Australia. In yesterday's The Australian he wrote:
"Unprecedented world economic growth is creating unprecedented global energy demand, rising energy prices and faster depletion of non-renewable energy resources. These are genuine threats to our future economic wellbeing. Maybe worse, the unequal distribution of energy resources across the world is a real threat to future geopolitical stability.
International initiatives such as the Kyoto Protocol and the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate have the potential to ease both these tensions. But although greenhouse gas reduction targets may be necessary, any frank review must conclude that the world's greenhouse emissions are not going down in the short term: they are simply being shifted from one country to another.
After all, the world's biggest greenhouse gas emitters are not bound by Kyoto. The US, as the world's biggest emitter, has refused to ratify the agreement. China and India, the second and fourth biggest emitters, are not required to reduce their emissions. And while we are often reminded by the Greens that Australia has the highest per capita greenhouse gas emissions, let's not forget there are good reasons for that.
Australia's relatively high energy intensity has to be considered in the context of the country's size and its relatively low population density, its climate, its heavy reliance on coal for power generation, and the presence of energy-intensive industries such as aluminium which form the backbone of the nation's wealth-generation capacity.
That is why it is a significant achievement of the Asia-Pacific Partnership's first meeting that the aluminium industry in the member countries reached an agreement on working together to reduce emissions. This is essential to overcome the problem of simply shifting emissions from one country to another and at the same time shifting Australian manufacturing jobs and prosperity offshore, to countries with lower environmental standards.
It is extraordinary that the Greens could place the economic security and jobs of their constituents at risk and at the same time advocate a worse greenhouse outcome by displacing Australian industry to countries with lower standards.
It's time to abandon the political correctness espoused by the green movement. Let's be real: without getting business on board we cannot achieve anything.
Read the full article by clicking here.
The Australian newspaper continues the theme with its editorial today. The the last paragraph includes:
The reactionary response to the Asia-Pacific Partnership meeting this week demonstrates that support for Kyoto cloaks the green movement's real desire - to see capitalism stop succeeding. Extreme greens cannot bear to accept that our best chance of reducing greenhouse gas emissions will occur when free enterprise has incentives to implement solutions. While power providers and big electricity users will howl, we need a national carbon trading scheme, with permits bought and sold in the free market, as a means of meeting greenhouse reduction targets set by Canberra. And we need tax concessions for industries that develop new technologies to clean up power supplies. In the long term geo-sequestration, which buries carbon dioxide pumped from power plants, may be a solution. And research into technologies to clean the coal burned in electricity generators is already under way, including development of a power plant in Florida designed to deliver much lower emissions. When the incentives exist business will use technology to find a way. For a century London was plagued by pollution that killed people. No longer. People now fish in the great lakes of North America which were once sludgy industrial swamps. And the idea that cars could emit much less pollution would have seemed impossible to environmental doomsayers 30 years ago. They would not have even conceived that commercial cars could run on batteries, with hydrogen power on the horizon. Whatever the extreme greens say, we can address global warming without adopting a medieval mindset that sees electricity as inimical to the environment. This week's meeting was a practical step forward by six nations whose legitimate energy requires continued use of coal - perhaps with more nuclear energy to follow. It worried environmental activists - because it showed up their messages of doom for what they are - hot air.
What a difference a week can make!
One last post (cros my heart and hope to die) to substantiate the CO2 fertilisation and water saving effects that to some extent counteract global temperature increases:
Crop losses to water shortage may exceed those from all other causes combined. If agriculture is to feed the world’s burgeoning population, yields of water-limited crops must be improved substantially. Efforts to accomplish this have concentrated on increasing the fraction of available water that crops transpire and increasing plant water use efficiency(biomass produced per unit of transpiration. These and other components of crop water economy will be affected by anticipated global changes, changes that include correlated increases in both atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration and mean temperature.
Yield of water-limited crops is determined by crop water use and plant water use efficiency, each of which will be affected by the anticipated rise in atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration and concomitant increase in temperature. At the leaf level, a given proportional increase in CO2 concentration generally elicits a similar relative increase in transpiration efficiency (ratio of net photosynthesis to transpiration). The increase in transpiration efficiency may result both from an increase in photosynthetic rate and a decrease in stomatal - conductance.
Feedbacks involved in scaling from leaf to crop constrain the increase in net carbon gain and reduce the anti-transpiration effect of CO2 enrichment. As a result, the increase in crop water use efficiency at high CO2 typically is less than 75% of that measured at the leaf level. By accelerating crop development and reducing harvest index, higher temperatures often erode yield benefits of improved water use efficiency at high CO2. The fraction of available water that is used by crops could increase with CO2 concentration because of greater root growth and faster canopy closure, but these effects have received scant study. Field experiments indicate that CO2 enrichment will increase crop water use efficiency mainly by increasing photosyn-thesis and growth. Yield should be most responsive to CO2 when temperatures approximate the optimum for crop growth. Elevating CO2 can ameliorate negative effects of above-optimal temperatures, but temperatures near the upper limit for crops will depress yields irrespective of CO2 concentration.
Implications of Atmospheric and Climatic Change for Crop Yield and Water Use Efficiency
H. Wayne Polley*
Published in Crop Sci. 42:131–140 (2002).
Oh Rog - really - I'm heartbroken - I stayed up all night writing it too.
Anyway - so you tell me why Louis is wrong then.
Incidentally some dogs will lie anywhere. Louis had been bagging string theory - now he's quoting a string theorist when it suits him. Oh the sweet smell of hypocrisy. You need to keep check on your character.
I read it Phil and I disagree with your view that your comments are substantial.
Hey Louis - I've told you why you're wrong on Mars in Warwick's blog but you haven't read it have you. Waiting for the penny and Louis's pants to drop .. .. I'll leave it for you as an exercise. In the mean time keep digging a bigger hole. I've got a bet running on how deep you go.
Good point, Davey. All very well to have one little beacon of common sense in the party but it will mean diddly squat if it comes without a complete ethics transfusion for all those "poisonous young men in suits" that, as Tom Burns put it, "wouldn't make a labor man's armpit".
Sorry Davey -deeply suspicious it's vote buying. But like to think you are right. However the the disconnect that the climate but is rubbish but we still need to do something is illogical.
Maybe some companies already get it and don't need pacts to get moving.
http://www.bpalternativenergy.com/liveassets/bp_internet/alternativenergy/index.html