• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Elephants to Sweden?
Uncategorized

Elephants to Sweden?

By jennifer
May 3, 2006

There has been an interesting exchange between Ann in Sweden, David in Tokyo, and others following my blog post of 23rd April titled 'Norway to Kill More Whales'.

The discussion has now moved from whales to elephants.

I lived in Kenya from 1989 through to late 1992 and visited Zimbabwe and South Africa. It was evident back then that there were too many elephants in southern Zimbabwe, while they were being shot out of Kenya.

I have previously mentioned the book by Raymond Bonner, 'At the Hand of Man: Peril and hope for Africa's Wildlife' (Alfred Knopf, New York 1993, pp 322) which is about the early history of conservation groups in Africa and how their staff in Africa supported trade in ivory. But the fundraisers and executives at their headquarters in Europe and the USA wanted bans ... lobbying for a ban on ivory generated membership and donations.

I've copied the following comment from David, because it does raise the very real issue of how 'Africa' can and should manage its elephants. Elephants can be so destructive and require so much space, and 'Africa' is being denied the opportunity to make money from ivory - which could give elephants a local value and in this way aid conservation of the species?

David wrote:

Ann,

Sorry, but your statements do confuse me. 🙂

Countries like Kenya are more than welcome to manage their elephants how they see fit.

However, they campaigned to have a ban on the ivory trade put in place because they had failed to manage their elephant populations, consequently suffering from poaching etc. The problem was, when the ban was imposed in 1989, it led to other nations being forced to abide by the ban even though their circumstances were different.

While Kenya had failed miserably to look after her elephants, nations in Southern Africa had been doing a fine job, and their elephants were in good shape. Here's the thing - there is a demand for elephant products. Rather than ban this trade, why not permit it, make money from it, and with those funds manage and regulate the industry for the good of conservation?

Read about Zimbabwe's CAMPFIRE approach to conservation here:

"While economic incentives are indispensable, the programme preaches and practises sustainable consumption as a vehicle for development. This is the language the Zimbabwean people and their ancestors have been practising since time immemorial."

Unfortunately, NGO groups from the Western world seem to care more about African elephants than they do about African people.

Remembering that all parties agree that conserving elephants is a priority, which do you give more importance Ann? African elephants or African people?

As for relocation, nations in Southern Africa should be under no obligation to relocate their (valuable) elephants to Kenya, a nation which has failed abismally to look after theirs (unless Kenya wishes to pay?).

Even in Kenya, the elephant levels are growing these days - but for how long will the ecosystem be able to sustain continued growth?

Then what? Ship elephants to Sweden perhaps? 🙂

Westerners seem to love them so much, let's see how they enjoy having them overrunning the local neighbourhood.

David

Thousands of elephants were culled in South Africa last year.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. i love that or god has blessed our eternity with so many wonderful type snd breeds of people and animals. i hope that one day very soon that i will be able to contribute to you in a working capacacity. right now i am not working and besides certain very special things are in my life i would love to be able to cast my ballot on the election sheet for our wonderful animals . who although they were put here first thier accounts and well beings have never have been in any ones hearts except a few fine people like yourself and a very few others. may god bless your march love and care for his children that he put here before us

  2. hello

    i send my resume

    i love sweden

    i know swedishi people help to another

    i love help to another people

    i will makeing christian

    please give me any jobs

    i will do this

    please give me one chance

    please

    RESUME

    RITESH B. MODI MOBILE NO : +91 99257 75014

    “RITURAJ”, EMAIL: nil2051@yahoo.co.in

    4-AKSHARNAGAR,

    GANDHIGRAM

    RAJKOT-360007

    GUJARAT, INDIA

    Ø OBJECTIVE:

    “To Excel in life with full dedication to the organization goal as an individual in a team where I can be a key member.”

    Ø PERSONAL INFORMATION:

    · Date of Birth : 6th MARCH 1980

    · Gender : Male

    · Marital Status : Married

    · Nationality : Indian

    · Language Know : Gujarati, Hindi & English,.

    Ø HOBBIES :

    · Traveling, Computer Surfing, music, interacting with new persons.

    Ø PRESENT ASSIGNMENT :

    · Presently I am working with “ADANI RETAIL LTD” as (P-Card Officer) Since feb.-2005, “ADANI RETAIL LTD” is having 51 outlets in Gujarat region. And First Indian Retail Chain Certified ISO 9001-2000. Adani is only having biggest hyper market (Shopping Center) in the heart of Rajkot Which is having over 20,000 Sqft Shopping Area and four floor and Three Super Markets.

    Ø Major Responsibilities Include:

    · Entries of the entire party product at our branch.

    · Stock transfer all Branch, Inward, Outward

    · Knowing the procedure of inward and outward as well as peace-to- peace Replacement to minimize loss.

    · Versify the Party wise statement with out records, solve the queries with regards the party wise application.

    · Generating product wise company barcode and looking for item wise stickering

    · Filling all the documents and party wise bill for p-card.

    · To solve the client quarries like founding purchase entries, billing, and item code, also solve the problems of customers etc.

    · P-card for Entries of the entire party product at our branch & Further Follow ups for Margins up.

    · Slicing for grocery bulk product.

    · Business Partner’s Entry & Business Partner short out their Problems.

    · Daily Stock Reconsilation

    · Help in HR

    Ø SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATION:

    · B.A. with psychology in Saurashtra University RAJKOT

    Ø COMPUTER LITERACY:

    · Window, MS-OFFICE & also well versed with INTERNET.

    I here by declare that all above furnished Information is authentic to the best of my Knowledge.

    Ø REFERENCE:

    Will be furnished upon request.

    RITESH B. MODI

  3. Brendan,

    My comments regarding an apparent increase in whale watching in Tonga is based on conversations I have had with business owners there, and my own personal observations over the past three years when I have been doing my research. I also assisted a tour company and found that although clients came from all over the world, the majority were made up of Australians and New Zealanders. So I have no 'official' source for my comment, which is rather unprofessional of me. I have contacted a tour operator who does whale watching in Tonga to see if she has any stats on recent visitation to Tonga for whale watching activities.

    I fail to see how whale watching and whaling with this population of animals can be compatible. The Tongan population is at about 700-1000 individuals. The JARPA Programme plans on taking 50 animals from an as yet unidentified feeding location. In Antarctic waters it is basically impossible to assign an individual to its winter feeding population, and so it is quite conceivable that the Tongan animals will be included in these takes.

    One has to ask why these animals are currently at such a low population level. It could be argued that as a species, human beings are opportunistic and have little consideration for the future. The low numbers of Tongan and Fijian whales is due to a failure to recover from legal and illegal whaling. Will we make the same mistake? I guess we will know after St Kitts next month.

    A travel show here last night told Australians we should be visiting Tonga. All well and good, but the infrastructure leaves a lot to be desired, although it is improving. Some people don't even know where Tonga is, but given adequate information and guidance are willing to try whale watching there, which of course offers something quite different with the swim-withs. A lot of it comes down to advertising and informing people.

  4. Could you cite the source for this increase in the number of whale watchers in Tonga?

    I ask, because the last time I was assured there was an increase, it was based more on wishful thinking than evidence. The link below should take you to a graph on visitor numbers at Vava'u, matched with an econometric model.

    http://my.opera.com/chthoniid/homes/files/vavau.gif

    It is clear than visitation rates experience a strong seasonal effect, and there was no time trend upward.

    This however, still overlooks the main problems with the IFAW compilations. The first is they report much higher estimates of benefit than 'economic studies', because they count industry 'costs' as benefits.

    Second, it has not been established that whaling and whale-watching are incompatible.

    Third, isolating the attraction of whale watching from other activities in Tonga is problematic. Tourists frequently do other activities while in Tonga, and if the whale-watching opportunity did not exist, they'd probably just do something else.

    This is the problem of being on the periphery of the global 'whale watching' industry. Tourists from Australia or NZ, might go whale watching if they take a holiday in Tonga. Someone wanting to just watch whales in Australia or NZ, go to domestic sites (e.g. Kaikoura in NZ). They don't go to Tonga.

  5. Whale watching is slowly increasing in Tonga, due to the fact they offer swim-withs. The development of Neiafu, in Vava'u, has been quite marked, due to the increase in tourists coming to swim with the whales.

    There have been no studies on the impact of swim-withs on this low population of whales, and the long-term effects on mothers and calves (which are havily targeted)and breeding animals is unknown. It is a double-edged sword, as there are some in the Tongan parliament who support the resumption of whaling in their waters. No one would go to Tonga purely for vessel-based whale watching, but the lure of swimming with whales is becoming quite popular now. Each year more and more licences are issued for these activities, and operators only have guidelines to follow regarding how they should behave around the whales(which many don't).

    Not all whale watching is done from advertised whale watching vessels, as some deep sea fishing and dive operators also will take people out, as will other individuals who can see a quick way to make a buck during the whale season.

  6. Given I co-authored a report on the IFAW (and similar) whale watching studies for the IWC, some comments may be appropriate.

    First, IFAW-type studies typically generate estimates of value of whale watching that are about an *order of magnitude* greater than published, peer-reviewed economic papers on whale-watching. The reason is simple. IFAW-style studies simply add up all expenditures to estimate benefits. Thus, a range of industry 'costs' end up being classed as a 'benefit'.

    According to IFAW, spending money on fuel for boats is a 'good thing'. One can only imagine the delight of the Japanese if they also classed the expenditures on their whaling fleet in the Antarctic as a benefit and not a cost.

    This is conflated by a general claim that whale watching is increasing. It is, but not in developing countries that are considering it as a development option (e.g. Tonga). Eco-tourism largely bypasses countries on the periphery of this industry.

    If someone in NZ or Australia want to watch whales, they go the Kaikoura or S Australia. They don't get on a plane to fly to Tonga to watch whales.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *