• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Dead But Won't Lie Down: Vincent Grey Comments on Tuvulu
Uncategorized

Dead But Won't Lie Down: Vincent Grey Comments on Tuvulu

By jennifer
June 15, 2006

"Everybody knows about Tuvulu, It is becoming inundated by the rising sea level because of global warming. The New Zealand Government has recognised the plight of the embattled inhabitants by offering special deals for immigration. So have the Australians. It forms a regular topic at meetings of the Pacific Forum and beyond, and there cannot possibly be any disagreement on the matter."

writes Vincent Grey today.

And he continues:

"A couple of years' ago I was interviewed by the Dunedin-based Natural History Unit as part of documentary for the National Geographic Channel. I had over an hour to give my views on greenhouse warming, which I expected would appear in an internationally distributed documentary. They sent me a copy of the final doco "to enjoy". I found that it was all about how Tuvulu is faced with imminent disaster, with a "moaning Minnie" lady persistently bemoaning the loss of her homeland from a comfortable flat in Brisbane. My contribution had been almost eliminated.

But Tuvulu reminds me of a comic song I used to sing of Gracie Fields called "He's dead but he won't lie down". Tuvulu persistently refuses to subside.

A tide gauge to measure sea level has been in existence at Tuvulu since 1977, run by the University of Hawaii It showed a negligible increase of only 0.07 mm per year over two decades It fell three millimeters between 1995 and 1999. The complete record can still be seen on John Daly's website, www.john-daly.com.

Obviously this could not be tolerated, so the gauge was closed in 1999 and a new, more modern tide gauge was set up by the Australian Bureau of Meteorology's National Tidal Center by Flinders University at Adelaide. But Tuvulu refuses to submit to political pressure.The sea level has actually fallen .since then

Tuvulu cannot be allowed to get away with it. So Greenpeace employed Dr John Hunter. a climatologist of the University of Tasmania, who obligingly "adjusted" the Tuvulu readings upwards to comply with changes in ENSO and those found for the island of Hawaii and, miraculously, he found a sea level rise of "around" 1.2 mm a year.which, also miraculously, agrees with the IPCC global figure.

Since all this seems biased, or politically influenced, Dr John Church of the CSIRO at Hobart, Tasmania, a Lead Author of the IPCC Chapter on "Sea Level", plus his colleague Dr Neil White, have sought to reverse actual measured trends by "combining records from tide gauges from all over the world with satellite altimeter data to assess regional variation". Unsurprisingly, and equally miraculously, they reach the same conclusion as Greenpeace and the IPCC. All this has to be imposed on poor little Tuvulu to "prove" global warming.and speed emigration.

The IPCC Chapter on Sea Level is one of the more dishonest. It practices two important deceptions. First, it completely fails to mention the fact that many tide gauges are situated close to cities where the land is subsiding because of erection of heavy buildings, or removal of ground water, oil and minerals. . It so happens that the island of Hawaii is one of the more heavily populated Pacific islands where the sea level is "rising" because the land is "falling" Another reason for upwards bias is Port Adelaide, Australia, where they decided to increase the water level in the harbour to allow for larger ships, They dredged and built a bar on the harbour. Unsurprisingly, the level rose on the tide-gauge. Corrections for these upwards biases in tide-gauge measurements have never been permitted to be discussed by the IPCC.

The other deception of the IPCC Sea Level Chapter is in statistics. The sea level averages are so inaccurate that they have to supply only one standard deviation as a measure of inaccuracy, instead of the otherwise universal use of two standard deviations. One standard deviation gives only a one in three chance that the measurement lies outside the limits. Two standard deviations puts it up to one in twenty. If you use the proper figures you find that the accuracy sometimes permits a less than one in twenty chance of a sea level fall. That must never be allowed

This whole melancholy story is told in an article in 'Science' 2006 Volume 312, pages 734 to 736, It seems that the Greenpeace organisation is now occupying the role of the late Trofim Lysenko in their ability to reverse the findings of scientific research.

Vincent Gray
Wellington, New Zealand

'It's not the things you don't know that fool you. It's the things you do know that aint so' Josh Billings"

Good Causes

Comments

  1. It's been fun reading all this. However, these comments are deeply unserious. Indications: 1) suggesting that land subsidence is caused by the weight of buildings, rather than by tectonic processes, known for the South Pacific and Indian Oceans since Darwin's time: 2) the 'suspicious' coincidence between the IPCC and Dr. Hunter's estimates of sea-level rise. In the real world, we expect best estimates to converge. We also expect scientists in a particular field to take the various factors that affect their observations into account, rather than trying to come up with a new single-factor theory that explains everything, almost always a sure mark of pseudo-science or meaningless contrarianism. Clouds and aerosols: what effect do they have in conjunction with everything else? Is the problem insoluble in theory, difficult, or can it be estimated between various parameters and these checked against observation over a period of years? Those are the questions a serious questioner would ask. Oddly enough, climatologists and atmospheric physicists would often know more about these things than geophysicists or economists.
    Got to go, I have a pain in my elbow I need to ask my mechanic about, and while I'm in the area, I was going to check with my grocer about a squeal in my brakes, while I ponder how soil drying will lower basalt or limestone bedrock.

    Is England also in a tectonic subsidence region? Their coastal railways are being flooded more and more frequently over the last 20 years.
    http://www.guardian.co.uk/climatechange/story/0,,1790046,00.html

  2. Excuse me Stewart and Fat Wombat, it is not the weight of the buildings that makes the ground sink but rather, the diversion of water by pavement that dries out the soil strata. And sink it certainly does.

  3. Stewart - Climate models are defeated by clouds and aerosols, to name just two of many flaws, but my list of just a few examples of the many disciplines involved in climate science was not in any particular order.

  4. I'm not sure of the source of the original comment from Dr. Gray. However the articled referred to is in fact in Nature, volume 440, pages 734-736 (6 April 2006) | doi:10.1038/440734a . Also I'm not sure why Tuvalu gets referred to as Tuvulu in the comment.
    The Nature article is more balanced than usual in Nature on climate issues. At one point they discuss the controversey:

    "Those sceptical about Tuvalu's plight, including amateur scientist Willis Eschenbach, seize on local explanations such as mining to assert that fears about sea-level rise are created by hysterical journalists and environmental groups looking for a cause célèbre. Eschenbach, who carried on a spirited debate with Hunter in the journal Energy and Environment, has concluded that sea-level rise in Tuvalu is an illusion. He has used that conclusion to support an argument that there is no clear evidence for climate change".

    I was also amused to find a blog comment by John Hunter in 2003 stating in part:

    "I have never stated that sea level is not falling at
    Tuvalu -- there is a significant likelihood that it is, as indicated by my
    quoted uncertainty interval. But just because it MAY be falling does not
    mean that we should act as if it IS falling".

    As far as I can see, the uncertainty is still high.

  5. John

    the Fanafuti gif is

    http://www.pol.ac.uk/psmsl/pubi/rlr.monthly.plots/732011.gif

    and the Tuvalu data is as follows, maybe BOM want more reliable data or maybe.....you fill in the gaps;

    732 TUVALU
    011 FUNAFUTI 08 32 S 179 13 E 62/C GLOSS 121

    DATA FOR : 1977-2001
    RLR FOR : 1977-2001
    INCOMPLETE: 1977 1979 1980 1981 1983

    012 FUNAFUTI B 08 30 S 179 12 E 62/24 GLOSS 121

    DATA FOR : 1993-2003
    INCOMPLETE: 1993 1994

  6. rog...

    Sea level monitoring at Tuvalu has been happening since 1977 according to the reference I provided above.

    It seems like you have two options...
    (a) the data I gave you is fictitious (and part of a conspiracy by ... let me guess... Exxon-Mobil?)
    or
    (b) the project to which you refer ("South Pacific Sea Level and Climate Monitoring Project") is a relatively new co-operative project and is not an accurate indication of the extent of earlier monitoring.

    Which is the more plausible ?

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *