• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • The Smartest Guys in the Room?
Uncategorized

The Smartest Guys in the Room?

By jennifer
August 11, 2006

Graham Young posted the following comment last night at an earlier blog post on climate change:

"Good to see we've moved on to the Hockey Stick. I find it interesting that while Enron's auditor, Arthur Andersen, is virtually no more, because of its lack of oversight in "refereeing" (to borrow a scientific term to cover an accounting situation) the accounts of the company; and Enron's highest executives were sent to jail, nothing much has happened to Mann et al, or their referees. Yet the Mann et al analysis has a lot in common with Enron.

While the original mathematical error was probably accidental, the perpetuation of it couldn't have been, once the McIntyre and MacKittrick analysis had been released. Enron was a company that once made real profits, but got into modelling the future and counting the results of its models as profits, which it then reported as real, despite the evidence. In the real world, rather than the real climate world, that is called fraud.

Worse, Mann et al set up their blog to, amongst other things, essentially defame their critics. Likewise, Kenneth Lay et al did their level best to defame and discredit their critics.

The climate community seem to just regard this issue as just a bit of a dust-up (including many of the contributors to this blog's comment box). In fact, it is far more serious than that, and the fact that reasonable people can have that attitude points to the serious crisis that there appears to be in some parts, at least, of the scientific community.

What has gone on here is criminal. Public monies have been directed in ways that they shouldn't have been on the basis of this graph. The attempt to cover-up the problems is fraud. It's about time that someone took legal action, assuming there is a law which makes this possible. If the law hasn't envisaged this particular issue and neglected it, then one should be enacted to take accounts of these facts.

Of course, the irony is that the graph couldn't have been correct in the first place as it didn't take account of the medieval warm period, which we know from observation to have been much warmer than now. So why did so many otherwise intelligent people go along for the ride?

And don't anyone tell me that the medieval warm period was a localised effect. If that was the case, where were the much colder counterbalancing areas in the reconstruction?"

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Yes Helen, it seems the level of personal responsibility in the public sector changes in inverse proportion to the level of authority they seek to exercise.

    What a marvellous life? Control everything, pay for nothing, claim all credit, accept no blame.

    The latest trick in avoiding consequences of misrepresentation to policy and legislative processes is to shift the key personnel a month or two before the decision is made. This allows everyone to make their views known to the relevant person but then allows the new person in the post to "forget" or "fail to grasp" the significance of any considerations that the Department might regard as inconvenient. So after "extensive consultation" the departmental preferred option gets up anyway.

    And they then wonder why no-one wants to enter into "strategic partnerships" with scum.

  2. Very good blog. Loved the five point test for fraud, Ian. Your experience in trying to bring accountability for misrepresenting facts is not alone. I can give an example from South Australia.

    Some years ago I lodged a complaint with the Commissioner for Public Employment against a Native Vegetation officer for underminig process by misrepresenting events (evidence provided) in briefings to inform decision makers, and for altering a document without noting the alteration or citing any authority to make that alteration.
    (It was some years before we became aware of the existence of those briefings or that the document had been altered.)

    After about a year, the Commissioner concluded that there had been some communications problems, and the officer concerned would be interviewed about improving future communications.

    Now the Enron boys had some, er, "communications problems", didn't they? But they were not public officers, so they could be brought to account.

  3. Yes, Ian. This wasn't even dignified by modelling. It was a guestimate backed up by the usual shock horror stories by the ABC and SMH.

    In the justification for the Native Veg Act the official position called "Setting the Scene" by the same John Benson, had a table listing the cleared areas of each bioregion but for some reason it didn't include a total for the state.

    When I compiled that total area of cleared land in the state (as you do) I found that this 28 million odd hectares was a full seven million hectares less than what the same author, in the same document, had claimed to have been cleared by the 1930's.

    The omission of this total obscured the fact that there had been an increase in native vegetation, net of all clearing, of seven million hectares since the 1930's. A matter of considerable relevance when investigating the need for vegetation legislation.

    When I referred this matter to the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption for investigation I discovered that ICAC regards the proper discharge of it's duties in such matters as thinking up any number of plausible explanations in Benson's defence, without actually conducting any sort of investigation.

    The body charged with investigating corruption, ie. "the partial OR dishonest exercise of public official functions", actively sought out excuses for not investigating the matter. They even used the fact that there was no record of explanation for the omission from Benson, as a reason for not asking him for one.

    And contrary to a mountain of case law to the contrary, ICAC claimed that the fact that Benson did not appear to benefit from any of his representations, meant that he was not subject to Sec 185A of the Crimes Act 1900.

    The fact that a thief may give all the proceeds to someone else has never been a defence but it was good enough for ICAC.

    Just another day in the brave new green utopia.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *