• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Ice Shelf Becomes Sea Ice: Perhaps Good News for Polar Bears?
Uncategorized

Ice Shelf Becomes Sea Ice: Perhaps Good News for Polar Bears?

By jennifer
December 30, 2006

Two days ago the mainstream media was lamenting that polar bears should be listed as threatened with extinction because of disappearing sea ice all a consequence of global warming.

Today the media is reporting that a giant ice shelf the size of 11,000 football fields has snapped free from Canada's Arctic and has formed an ice island. Furthermore, this ice island is likely to end up as sea ice in the very places scientists are complaining there is not enough of the stuff for the big bears...

"Within days, the floating ice shelf had drifted a few kilometres offshore. It travelled west for 50 kilometres until it finally froze into the sea ice in the early northern winter... Prevailing winds could then send the ice island southwards, deep into the Beaufort Sea."

Well isn't this good news for polar bears?

It could be, if there was any truth to the story that polar bears are threatened with extinction from a reduced area of sea ice.

But the whole "disappearing sea ice threatens polar bear's survival" story is in reality a farce.

While the area of sea ice has been declining over the last couple of decades, the number of polar bears has actually been increasing. That's right increasing!

So it is very wrong for the Australian Broadcasting Corporation to uncritically report that: "The World Wide Fund for Nature says the declining number of polar bears is a major warning on the impact of climate change."

There were only about 5,000 polar bears in 1970, numbers depressed by hunting. There are now about 25,000 polar bears. The increase a consequence of agreements to restrict hunting under quota systems.

The biggest threat to discrete populations of polar bears continues to be illegal hunting in places like the Chukchi sea and Greenland's failure to agree to the quota system.

If the extent of sea ice continues to decline in places like Hudson Bay and the Beaufort Sea, these populations of polar bears can move north to where there is more sea ice with ringed seals, or they might simply switch to hunting seals that prefer warmer weather.

As I have previously written, the two polar bears living happily at Sea World, on Queensland's Gold Coast, enjoying watermelons and museli bars, are evidence of the capacity of this big bear to adapt, including to warm weather.

------------------
The mass of ice fell away 16 months ago but scientists have ony just realised because it all happened at a remote locality off the coast of Ellesmere Island which is about 800 kilometres south of the North Pole.

The issue of environmentalists and scientists taking advantage of the popularity of polar bears and drawing rediculous conclusions from the available data all to progress their global warming agenda is reviewed in a piece I wrote for the IPA Review earlier this year entitled 'Polar Bear Politics: Underestimating the survival capacity of one popular bear'.

There is an old blog post from 25th October 2005 here (Polar Bears on Thin Ice) and another from 3rd May 2006 here ( 16,119 Species Threatened with Extinction?) and I also wrote something on 30th May 2006 here (Polar Bear Politcs: Misrepresenting the Nature of One Smart Bear).

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Increasing? Not quite.

    "We analyzed capture-recapture data collected from 1984-2004 by the Canadian Wildlife Service, and handling data for polar bears captured in and around the community of Churchill by the Manitoba Department of Conservation. We used Cormack-Jolly-Seber to estimate survival, population size, and population growth rate. We concluded that the total size of the WH polar bear population declined by approximately 22%, from 1194 (95% CI = 1020, 1368) in 1987 to 935 (95% CI = 794, 1076) in 2004. The correlation between earlier sea ice breakup and decreased survival provides quantitative evidence for a link between climatic warming and polar bear population dynamics. It may also help explain why Churchill, like other communities along the western coast of Hudson Bay, has experienced an increase in the number of bears that come into town prior to freeze-up each fall. The progressively earlier breakup of sea ice shortens the time that polar bears can hunt seals during the critical spring foraging season, thereby reducing their ability to accumulate the fat reserves they rely upon while stranded on land. The WH population is forced ashore earlier, in poorer nutritional condition, and remains food-deprived for a longer time. As polar bears exhaust their fat reserves toward the end of the ice-free period, they are more likely to encroach upon human settlements in search of alternative food sources to sustain themselves until freeze-up. Thus, the increase in polar bear-human interactions in western Hudson Bay probably* reflects an increase in nutritionally-stressed polar bears searching for food, not an increase in population size. Models developed and tested on the WHB project are currently being used for a new population estimation for polar bears of the Southern Beaufort Sea." (Amstrup USGS 2006)
    * This is unlikely to mean nothing of the sort is happening and the bears are just coming to town looking for lawn chairs and Coca Cola. Scientists never leap very far ahead to leaps of faith-based absolutism found in conservative polemics.

  2. I've detected increasing instances of wingnut deniers eating their weasel words and out of context quoting. Amstrup is the go to guy on this species. Or you could declare them not a real species like these morons have at GM's Corner? Denial is a sad thing. Truely sorry in every way.

  3. Washington Post states:" ...The bears have resorted to open-water swimming and even cannibalism in an effort to stay alive..."

    It must however be pointed out that our cute bears( polar bears, grizzlys and brown bears) have always had a tendency to cannibalism...

    The males have a habit of trying to kill the male cubs....and to eat or bury the cadaver...

    Don't know if the researchers now have detected an increased tendency to cannibalism???

  4. I think it's safe enough to (blog rule) assume good faith by the polar bear institutes & scientists appearing in the various extracts above.

  5. Ann: US legal obligations under the Endangered Species Act (sued by GP etc to add PBs to list). They're getting around the potential extension of that obligation to include a need to address climate change by declaring it extraneous to endangered species issue.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/28/science/28polar.html?ex=1324962000&en=50b37e5bde8ccc37&ei=5090&partner=rssuserland&emc=rss

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/26/AR2006122601034.html

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *