• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Polar Bear Facts: Part 1, Numbers Have Increased Dramatically Over Last 30 Years
Uncategorized

Polar Bear Facts: Part 1, Numbers Have Increased Dramatically Over Last 30 Years

By jennifer
January 4, 2007

I am no expert on polar bears. In fact I have never been to the Arctic. But I do have an interest in animal conservation, that scientific findings are reported honestly and accurately, and that the general public is not mislead on environmental issues.

Over the Christmas holidays Australians were repeatedly told through news broadcasts that polar bears are already a species in serious decline, in particular that they are seriously threated by global warming.

Earlier in 2006 I spent some time reading technical reports about the relationship between the decline in the extent of sea ice in the Arctic and polar bear ecology. I was surprised to discover as part of this research that polar bear numbers have actually increased over the last 30 years.

The more I read the more it became apparent that polar bear researchers were down playing this good news and promoting any finding that could be interpreted as a "decline" in any population of polar bears. It was also clear that global warming campaigners were keen to sieze on this information, extrapolate and exaggerate a bit more, and then parade it as evidence for a claimed overall decline in polar bear numbers.

Just last week I posted a piece at this blog stating that despite claims in the popular press and scientific literature to the contrary, polar bear numbers are actually increasing. I wrote that numbers have increased from about 5,000 to 25,000 over the last 30 years.

The piece has generated much discussion at this blog, and I have received many ‘hate emails’. I have been accused of all sorts of things, including showing a complete disregard for the hard work of experts in the field. But interestingly no-one has disputed my principle claim: that polar bear numbers have more than doubled over the last 30 years.

A key criticism appears to be that I have not acknowledged that polar bear numbers have been predicted by experts to decline dramatically in the future.

The reasoning from the most shrill of the self-proclaimed experts has been that because there is a likelihood the situation might deteriorate into the future, we can’t acknowledge the good news now.

I completely reject the notion that any scientist, researcher, campaigner, or self-proclaimed expert has a right to withhold good news on an environmental issue of intense public interest because of what may or may not happen in the future.

-------------------------
In the next installment/next blog post on this subject (Part 2) I will explain why I am skeptical of the claims that polar bear numbers will decline dramatically over the next 50-100 years.

I am happy to publish guest posts that put an alternative perspective, for example, that provide information supporting the contension that polar bears are a truly threatened species, email to jennifermarohasy@jennifermarohasy.com .

Good Causes

Comments

  1. "The population of Davis Strait polar bears is estimated to be at 2,100, says an interim report of a three-year study.

    Ten years ago, Inuit hunters, using traditional knowledge, estimated there were 1,400 Davis Strait polar bears and 1,650 by 2004.

    The population in the recently released report includes polar bears in south Baffin, Labrador, Nunavik and southern Greenland."

    http://www.cbc.ca/canada/north/story/2007/01/16/polar-bear.html

    "Nunavut must think big, not small, on polar bears"

    “Allowing ourselves to remain paralyzed by anger against certain environmental groups only keeps us stuck as victims.”

    SHEILA WATT-CLOUTIER
    http://www.nunatsiaq.com/opinionEditorial/opinions.html

  2. "For the record Libby, I did provide that link but it took longer than your motor mouth and you had already started gloating before I posted it. Same old same old."

    Rubbish (dumpster) Ian. Go look up "self-appointed expert" in the dictionary and you will find a picture of yourself.

  3. http://www.nunatsiaq.com/news/nunavut/70105_01.html

    "For example, the Polar Bear Specialist Group, made up of polar bear scientists and wildlife managers from around the circumpolar world, claim the Baffin Bay and western Hudson Bay populations are each in decline.

    As for Davis Strait, they say there’s not enough information about that population to make an informed estimate.

    So in January of 2005, when Nunavut increased annual polar bear hunting quotas from 398 to 507 bears, the decision provoked an immediate backlash from a majority of polar bear scientists.

    The minutes of the Polar Bear Specialist Group, who met in Seattle in 2005, say many scientists had “a definite high level of uneasiness” with GN population estimates based on traditional Inuit knowledge, as well as with Nunavut’s big increase in hunting quotas."

    Looks like selectively cooked data to support hunting revenue to me, and to the consensus of polar bear scientists worldwide. Self-interest is easy to spot.

  4. Mr Iceglass,
    Maybe you think I'm hard on you...but IMO, sorry, you are a bad ambassador for the Inuit people.

    I have been open minded and told you that I accept traditional Inuit hunting, but still you hurl out insults!

    In my very, very small and insignificant way, I have always supported Inuit culture... and BTW. there are other aspects of culture...you forget to mention handcraft and art.

    I use to buy Inuit art postcards. Here's an excerpt from my Inuit Bird book of postcards:

    "Cape Dorset- called Kinngait in the Inuit language, Inuktitut, for the areas high rolling hills- is a thriving community on southwestern Baffin Island, in the Canadian Arctic Territory of Nunavut. The community is renowned for the wonderful Inuit art ....bla, bla bla...

    One of my favorites is "Ukpaaraaq" ( Young Owl).

    But when I read such comments as yours I must say you make bad PR.

    And no more comments from me... maybe only if you post with your real name...

  5. For the record Libby, I did provide that link but it took longer than your motor mouth and you had already started gloating before I posted it. Same old same old.

    Good points Ice Class.

  6. "We can have whaling discussions on another thread..."

    No, go back to David's blog where you belong Ice Class. He is a NZ who wants to be Japanese, and you are a ??? who wants to be Inuit. You share the same obnoxious and repelling attitudes too.

  7. Just a contrarian wingnut: ice drip, like the rest. Flannery will have to answer for himself, and the so-called 25 year demise since the study for the listing claimed 50, but I go with the USFWS. Since it's headed by a sceptic of climate change, the listing data is beyond reproach both Legally and scientifically.

  8. Inuit are unlikely to call people "good folks" in online discussions regardless how oil-soaked they are. Surely you don't think I'm THAT naive? Greedy NGO is a false cause fallacy. Compared to oil money, they make chump change from donations for social change. This is as they say "Bollocks!"

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *