"The US supreme court yesterday issued a landmark ruling in favour of environmentalists and against George Bush's stance on global warming. The court judged that the federal Environmental Protection Agency had the power through a clean air law to restrict exhaust emissions, and told the agency to re-examine the issue.
"The ruling was in response to a lawsuit filed by 12 states and 13 environmental groups frustrated with the Bush administration's lack of action. Individual states, led by California, have been imposing regulations of their own. Car makers, public utilities, and others responsible for carbon dioxide emissions opposed the lawsuit.
"The court found that the scientific evidence shows that global warming is not some future threat, but is already having serious impacts in the United States. This will be a huge turning point in federal policy. The administration massively overreached in refusing to cut global warming pollution from cars when the Clean Air Act explicitly requires it to act...
Read the article 'US supreme court overrules Bush's refusal to restrict C02' by Ewen MacAskill in The Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,,2048760,00.html
Does the act discriminate between primary and feedback effects? If it's an effect, why does one have to distinguish between the mechanisms of it's cause?
Air pollution was never a singular American issue, it was also a global one, that every industrialised country had to deal with.
AGW is proven, they just have to ask their own peak scientific bodies.
It's one thing to say that particulates in the air are causing breathing problems and that mercury dumped in the water harms fish. Those are direct and proven causes and effects. Global warming is indirect and is not proven and is not a singular American issue. The EPA doesn't need to be involved in international problems and treaties. I can't believe that you can't see how the Court is stretching the interpretation and expanding the unintended authority of the EPA. Let the legislature handle that.
Is this a legal argument? Air and water don't need protection, they are inanimate molecules. The environment needs protection, and it includes us.
Does air and water need to be protected from being polluted by CO2?
Why do you keep your air and water clean? Because it protects your environment. Excess CO2 is damaging the environment.
SJT, the EPA was created to keep America's air and water clean. This goes beyone that, no matter what the truth about AGW. I don't have time to read the entire opinion and dissenting opinions, but I suspect that Justice Scalia made the most sense in his conclusions.
Woody
CO2 was not considered a pollutant back then because the effects of enhanced global warming were not known then. It's not a matter government socialist conspiracies and corruption, it's a simple matter of science discovering something.
It's really a matter of whether the IPCC is right or not, which is what the court has decided should happen, let the scientists sort it out.