"The Sustainable Development Network (SDN), a coalition of people-oriented conservation groups, today called upon delegates to the CITES meeting in The Hague to reconsider the ban on sale of tiger parts, which it says is undermining effective conservation by reducing the incentives to manage tigers sustainably and increasing the number of wild tigers that are poached. The SDN argues that trade in certified farmed tiger parts could meet existing and future demand, thereby reducing pressure on wild tigers.
"The conservation community has for many years been split over whether commerce in endangered species is desirable. While the evidence has increasingly suggested that commerce must be part of the solution, opponents of commerce have dominated the debate. As a result, restrictions on commerce have become the cornerstone of conservation policies, with the consequence that tigers and several other species have been driven to the verge of extinction in the wild.
"One fundamental problem is that by making trade in these wildlife products illegal, the trade has been driven underground. As Kirsten Conrad, a tiger conservation expert, notes, "Despite legal protection over most of its range, prohibition of international trade, anti-poaching efforts, and millions spent by NGOs and governments, demand for tiger parts shows no sign of abating."
"Recent estimates put the value of illegal trade in wildlife at over US $6 billion a year – which would make it the third most traded illicit product after drugs and arms. Indian policy analyst and developer of SDN’s Sustainable Tiger Initiative, Barun Mitra, puts it succinctly: “When trade is outlawed, only outlaws trade.”
"Some of the poorest people in the world live in close proximity to tigers and other valuable resources, yet they have little incentive to conserve and manage those resources sustainably, because they are not allowed to own or trade in them. As a result, only criminals and smugglers profit from poaching. This is bad for the people who share the tiger’s habitat and very bad for tigers.
"The contrast with crocodiles – another large carnivore – could not be more stark. Three million crocodiles are farmed each year in facilities as disparate levitra as Australia, South Africa and the United States – enabling the demand for crocodile parts to be met legally, while massively reducing the pressure on wild crocs. In 1971, all of the world’s 23 species of crocodile were classified as endangered; now, the eight farmed species are no longer threatened and populations of eight other species have recovered.
"As Mr Mitra, whose Liberty Institute was a founding member of the SDN, puts it “The only market failure in tiger conservation is the failure to let markets operate.”
"In the new proposal – the “Save the Tiger Initiative” – the SDN outlines ways of enabling people to own and sell tigers, which would provide incentives for a range of commercial activities, from eco-tourism to breeding tigers and trading in tiger parts. Under this proposal, the SDN believes that the tiger, which is such a charismatic and culturally rich species, can become economically viable and thereby survive in the wild.
"Kirsten Conrad explains why she supports the SDN Initiative: "While all this sounds cold-blooded—tigers are not tubs of margarine nor domestic livestock— conservationists do not have the luxury of ignoring the distasteful but possibly effective strategy of allowing trade in captive-bred tigers, at least not if they are truly intent on saving the tiger from extinction."
Barun Mitra concluded, “The tiger could easily earn its keep and buy its way out of extinction – if we allow it to do so,” adding that cooperation between China and India offers the best hope for this mighty but endangered beast.
"NOTE: The 14th Conference of the Parties to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora is currently taking place in The Hague (3-15 June 2007). Asian big cats are on the agenda under "Species trade and conservation issues" but some countries want the topic dropped.
"The Sustainable Development Network is a coalition of individuals and non-governmental organizations who believe in a people-oriented view of sustainable development.
www.sdnetwork.net
End of Media Release.
On the issue of forest guards...I've just written up my chapter on Sariska, which has been found to be poached out of tigers. What I was told by several individuals was that guards were "old men wielding sticks...who ran at the sight of well-armed poachers". They are frequently not paid, nor trained. Hardly an effective detereent against sophisticated poachers, and others can speak to the rifle-weilding guard protecting rhinos in Africa.
On the TRAFFIC report. That report implies that since very little tiger was found in retail and wholesale matrkets, demand is not there. Yet, nobody disputes that illegal trade is headed into China. The investigation failed to penetrate the trade network to find out exactly how these tigers (and possibly other wildlife) are being brought into China.
This is Kirsten Conrad. Two quick comments, as I've just come online after a week with no intenet.
First, I'm a vegetarian also for ethical reasons--who am I to take hte lifr of a sentinent being when I can meet my nutritional requirements, relatively easily, wlsewhere? But, I recongnise the right of individuals to make their own decisions and am reluctant to press my views on others.
Second, I believe the South China Tiger who died in South Africa was diagnosed with a weak heart, probably the result of inbreeding. While I am not aware that any analysis that has been done of mortality rates of the population of South China tigers in captivity, I do know that the population has lost robustness and does exhibit defects due to a narrow gene pool.
Fwiw, I've added a few more pictures from Tiger Farms to my blog.
Also, laundering of wildlife products can be deterred by having a limited distribution path, that is insulated from laundering. Southern African countries showed it could be done with ivory, even without being able to DNA type the ivory being exported. With tiger bone, we have the additional advantages of one market- tiger-bone from farms won't leave the country- and DNA profliling.
I think (based on discussions so far) that some limited trials, using the existing TCM network are being considered.
In terms of poaching, the root problem is the thousands of depserately poor who live (often illegally) on Asian reserves. Chinese demand alas, is often used as the scapegoat. Your basic subsistence-level farmer in a reserve, doesn't like tigers because they threaten his paltry livestock, or children. I'm not surprised. He's poisoning off tigers, not to supply the Chinese blackmarket, but to stop his son or daughter or goats getting killed.
Indian policy has been to decide who has legitimate rights to live on these reserves, and who is to be removed. This policy of forcing people off the reserves however, has a large human cost. The families that are removed, have a tendency to kill themselves shortly afterwards.
This tends to rapidly reduce the enthusiasm of officials to manage the reserves 'for nature' and 'for tigers'.
There seems little enthusiasm also, amongst the NGO community to recognise things are a lot more difficult in India than simply creating and policing reserves- and that most of the pressure (habitat loss, local poaching) is a result of human-tiger conflict and not the Chinese black-market. Just how many Indians do we want killing themselves to let the tigers survive?
China is also part of the range of the bengali tiger, and with the rural-urban migration, gives us a new option. There are rural areas now in China where tiger-human conflicts can be minimised. The tiger-farms give us the tool to tackle *one* of the poaching threats, and to be honest, the Chinese have tended to bundle the restoration/reintroduction plans with the captive-breeding programme. But that tends to be the Chinese take on conservation- step 1 is so often an ex situ breeding programme.
I don't have all the answers, but in this particular case, I get very fustrated by NGos who do (apparently) have all the answers- often without the benefit of being aware of the horrible mess we've got ourselves into with the tiger. Also, the current strategy- is costing us a lot of tigers (500 or so per year) and people, and nobody is coming out ahead.
Shutting the whole debate down, isn't helping.