• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
Uncategorized

Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

By jennifer
September 18, 2007

I have long held the view that the relationship between indigenous and non-indigenous Australia is self-defeating. Belonging to the same landscape; bound together in territorial respect for the aspirations, life and memory of our own constituents; surely it can be agreed that the dislocation of indigenous peoples from their living cultural landscape is as abhorrent as the eviction of non-indigenous Australians from Australia.

Nevertheless, Australia had little choice but to refuse to ratify the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples adopted by its General Assembly last week.

ABC News quotes Prime Minister Howard as saying, "We do not support the notion that you should have customary law taking priority over the general law of the country."

Upon closer consideration, however, elements of the declaration reveal far more insurmountable implications.

Article 28 (in particular):

1. Indigenous peoples have the right to redress, by means that can include restitution or, when this is not possible, of a just, fair and equitable compensation, for the lands, territories and resources which they have traditionally owned or otherwise occupied or used, and which have been confiscated, taken, occupied, used or damaged without their free, prior and informed consent.

2. Unless otherwise freely agreed upon by the peoples concerned, compensation shall take the form of lands, territories and resources equal in quality, size and legal status or of monetary compensation or other appropriate redress.

When the High Court ruled that native title and pastoral lease could co-exist, we saw the federal parliament amend the Native Title Act to provide greater certainty to pastoral interests and effectively rewrite history against indigenous interests.

For Australia, the implications of Article 28 alone, is insupportable. It is a very great shame that the Declaration was framed in such a manner, when so much of it stood for such gain.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Thanks for this post Neil. It's a step in thought and focus above the usual guff and your views on this important issue are always good to hear. I'd like to see more of this (don't be disuaded by the nature of some comments above).

    rog do you have better suggestions of working definitions for these terms, or do you think we shouldn't try to define or apply them?

  2. 'indigenous people have tried to retain some of their culture and adapt it to todays socio-political machinations,it has blatantly let them down with tribal elders abusing their position of trust to make contracts/deals with governing bodies with only their own goals in mind.' - Jayne

    That would appear to be a rather sweeping generalisation...

  3. I agree with what you say Neil but Australia's indigenous people have to take responsibility for themselves,instead of relying upon guilt-fueled payments demanded in their name by tribal elders who claim they make decisions for the good of the whole tribe.
    While indigenous people have tried to retain some of their culture and adapt it to todays socio-political machinations,it has blatantly let them down with tribal elders abusing their position of trust to make contracts/deals with governing bodies with only their own goals in mind.
    Evolution within indigenous societies must be allowed,otherwise we are left with people who are used and abused,for monetary gain,by the very ones they have chosen to represent them -the situation that is emerging now.

  4. Jayne,

    Australian society has members of indigenous extraction with varying degrees of cultural integrity. You are describing conduct of such a segment in the same terms that I described. We are not in disagreement.

    Pre-colonial-Australian indigenous society, upheld a sustainability longer than any other culture in the history of humankind. Much of the wisdom of this cultural capability is retained within remote homeland peoples throughout Australia.

    Australia's Westminster system of government has tremendous strengths but it also has its fatal flaws. In many respects democracy has become a cultural liability that allows population concentration to demand short-term advantage against the disregarded importance of long-term diasadvantage.

    The issue of Australia respecting the rights of its indigenous people seems to be inevitably constrained to one of absolute extremes; either indigenous people are utterly assimilated or fully restored to their former glory. Very little consideration goes into Australia assimilating into indigenous culture or banishing its population to the countries of origin.

    This is why the Declaration was so uninspired. Australia's potential to benefit from changing its relationship with its indigenous peoples to one of genuine respect, for the undeniable attributes of adaptation and perseverance, could inspire change, over the long term, towards a more honest and sustainable Australian society.

  5. Neil,
    The particular indigenous people I mentioned claimed money for preserving their tribal culture and native lands environment,of which they have done neither,with the express permission of the rest of the tribe.
    They have used non-indigenous peoples guilt(whipped up by inaccurate media reports) to trade for money they have not used for the purposes of their claims;this is not the fault of non-indigenous people but the self-willed actions of those claiming indigenous Tribal Elder rights.
    "Inclusive consultation" is mere lip service for the *Yorta Yorta people,who were granted limited land rights and consultation with the Vic Govt and Parks Vic.So long as they toe the Parks Vic party line of lock it up and leave it,it's all dandy and that was a decision they chose.
    As Rog stated about the Celts "they were dudded by their clan leaders" and the same thing has happened again in Victoria.
    Self-willed actions by Tribal Elders,some of whom I know for a fact have no interest in the environment or culture except for monetary gain,who were given Tribal Elder status by the members of their particular tribe,freely.
    Not the fault of any non-indigenous person.
    *Family members are not part of the Yorta Yorta tribe.

  6. Jayne,

    I know of several so-called scientists that rely exclusively on grants from governments. Consultancies seeem to thrive upon public monies and bureaucracy draws so heavily upon Australia's well-being that I'm truly astonished it is not irradiated for the malignancy that it has become. But these are failings of non-indigenous Australian society, just as those members of an indigenous extraction, draw upon an aspect of funding opportunity that Noel Pearson has argued so capably sustains bureaucracy through an obligate dependency.

    Why have we allowed such deterioration as a society? I know I have spent much time pondering this kind of question and it would seem to me that we are vulnerable to corruption because of an almost unlimited conceptual capability that is unconstrained by a common truth.

    Australian society rewards consultancies for the illusion of bridging the gap between political expedience and inclusive consultation. Australian society rewards bureaucrats for their ineptitudes and the greater number of officers under their authority. Australian society boasts 'spin-doctoring' as a capability of those entrusted with representative authority.

    Indigenous society, from my observations, is grounded in a common truth. Its custodial resposnibility, to protect the sanctity of the natural environment (which for them is synonymous with the spiritual environment of their ancestors and in whose eternal company they will be honoured on the basis of the fulfilment of their custodial responsoibility) is an enviable and significant element of a sustainability that has surpassed all other human cultures in the world.

    So much of this weblog is devoted to debate about sustainability. A great deal has been written about the over-emphasis of calamitous climate concern particularly where the research getting is so good.

    It is very telling that so little regard is had for Australia's indigenous culture in addressing the sustainability woes that seem to be of such importance to so many contributors.

  7. This thing could completely alter the landscape.

    Everyone of Roman descent in Northern Europe (using DNA testing) must go back to Italy.

    Everyone of Moorish descent on the Iberian Peninsula must be repatriated to Africa.

    Poland must be given back to Prussia.

    China should relinquish claims to all sorts of things.

    Hmmm... should Brazil be given back to the Vatican?

    Now that the United Nations has blessed all these issues, let's have some wars!

  8. Angela,

    We are an adaptable species. Humankind occupies an incredible diversity of habitats; from the arctic tundra to equatorial rainforests, from great cities to vast expanses of desert wilderness. When we speak of the Kalahari Bushmen, the Inuit, the Amazonian Indians or the Mountain Cattlemen, we are celebrating the triumphant interrelationship between people and their environment.

    Principle 22 of the RIO DECLARATION ON ENVIRONMENT AND DEVELOPMENT, states: Indigenous people and their communities and other local communities have a vital role in environmental management and development because of their knowledge and traditional practices. States should recognise and duly support their identity, culture and interests and enable their effective participation in the achievement of sustainable development.

    Australia is defined by its people and their relationship with their environment. It has been triumphant in its interdependence of unique communities, bound in territorial respect for the aspirations, life and memory of their constituents. Territorialism binds individuals and families together in their common possession. It is the building block of both communities and nationhood.

    However, Australian society is becoming increasingly anti-territorial. Through popularist environmentalism, it is disintegrating. Divisive, anti-community enviro-politics peddle the perverse notion that the relationship between Australians and their natural environment should be based on divorce rather than marriage. If it were considered in terms of promoting feelings of ill-will or hostility between different groups so as to threaten the peace, order and good government of the Commonwealth, then it would conform with the meaning of seditious intention under anti-terrorism legislation.

    Prime Minister Howard has previously described his offense to the idea that the extreme greens have a mortgage on concern and compassion for the forests or for the environment of this country. He has told of his long belief that it is never fair to ask a small section of the Australian people to carry the burden and the cost of implementing something that the overwhelming majority of the wider community wants. He affirmed his unshakable belief (and that of his government) that in achieving the goals of a better environment we shouldn’t throw on the scrapheap vulnerable, isolated, regional communities, their families and the people who owe their livelihoods to the activities of those communities.

    That his beliefs run contrary to the outcomes of popularist environmentalism is an undisputed fact.

    Why? Because so many of the eighty-five-or-so per cent of Australians that live in cities and major towns allow it.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *