"The proposed pulp mill at Bell Bay in Tasmania should go ahead if it meets environmental guidelines” said Don Burke, chairman of the Australian Environment Foundation [AEF].
Mr Burke was commenting after discussion at the AEF annual conference in Melbourne on the proposed pulp mill.
“This is best practice pulp production. We believe that it is essential to support best practice industries. Encouraging improvements in environmental behaviour of companies is the best way forward.
To refuse the mill a permit and continue to export wood chips to mills overseas that are not up to the standard of the Bell Bay mill is to show a breathtaking disregard for the environment” said Mr Burke.
“We have looked at Gunn’s operations in Tasmania, we have looked at the data and we have listened to the needs of the Tasmanian people. Based on the available science AEF supports this project as an example of best practice sustainable forestry.
Decisions on the environment must be based on science and evidence – not emotion – if we are to achieve the best possible result for the environment and the people that are part of that” concluded Mr Burke.
The AEF conference was addressed by Gunns Ltd Resource Manager, Calton Frame prior to discussion on the proposed mill.
-----------------------
The Australian Environment Foundation (AEF) is a not-for-profit, membership-based environment organisation having no political affiliation. The AEF is a different kind of environment group, caring for both Australia & Australians. Many of our members are practical environmentalists – people who actively use and also care for the environment. We accept that environmental protection and sustainable resource use are generally compatible. For more information about the AEF visit www.aefweb.info .
Conclusion: the AEF's claim to be a different kind of environment group is unsubstantiated spin. It pushes a barrow full of vested interests. It only focuses on issues that arise in the media that affect a well-funded lobby group or the profit-making abilities of well organised, asset flush industry groups. Cite any action of the AEF that proves me wrong!!
Cinders: IFC investment guidelines can be read in various ways
Top Sessons by Sector – Timber, Pulp & Paper
5. “Technology: State-of-the-art technology may not be appropriate to the country’s resource base or workforce. Vague performance guarantees in equipment supply contracts can be dangerous. Base sensitivity analyses over a period that accounts for technological change”.
http://www.ifc.org/ifcext/oeg.nsf/AttachmentsByTitle/Timber%2C+Pulp+and+Paper/$FILE/Timber%2C+Pulp+and+Paper.pdf
When suggesting Lib Lab pollies look at subsidising a big chair factory or two as the natural alternative to pulping all the pulpwood available in Tasmania I ‘m sure we could all avoid lots of other little problems down the track like the lack of experienced welders and electricians.
TWS could then have a field day counting stressed look chairs as our chips went to Asia.
Community concerns about any project not just pulp mills are important, and need to be addressed.
In the case of concerns expressed about location, marine and air pollution as well as human health, and the impact on commercial fishing, vineyards and tourism all have been addressed and information available at the web site of the developer, by the State Government, Department of Justice and the RPDC, the Federal Government on its EPBC page and many of the myths relating to these concerns been summarised on the http://www.tca.org.au.
Yet from reading the media release of the Australian Environment Foundation, the AEF has also done its separate due diligence on the project, by visiting the site, talking to people and getting up to speed on what represents best practice environmental management.
For those wanting a crash course on pulp mills the World Bank’s environmental health and safety (EHS) guidelines are recommended at http://www.ifc.org/ifcext/policyreview.nsf/Content/EHSGuidelinesUpdate_Comments
In contrast if you check the Wilderness society annual reports you find that in 2004 only 160k was spent on scientific research despite an a budget of $9 million, in 2005 the dollars went up to $295k but so did the budget increase by $2 million to $11 million. No wonder they don’t know the difference between bleaching pulp with elemental chlorine and the modern and safe method of ECF.
A next event for AEF Chairman Don Burke will be a book launch in the Macquarie Marshes on Wednesday 26th September.
Land rehabilitation by an AEF member will be on show... this is an opportunity to see the sort of thing AEF members support and participate in.
There will be buses leaving from Warren which is not far from Dubbo.
Contrary, its reasonable to ask the AEF to explain its claim that "The AEF is a different kind of environment group, caring for both Australia & Australians".
Recall that Jennifer kept claiming that there was a need for good evidence-based environment policy, leading to her role in this capacity at the AEF and leading to the establishment of the AEF (using the office facilities of the IPA which is a covertly funded lobby group). Hence if evidence-based policy is a point of distinction of the AEF as we were originally led to believe, and as is supported by Walter's claim that 'employing available scientific knowledge' is one of the differences, then it's reasonable to ask about this.
Hence these are valid questions to ask, especially on this blog. Having established that, let's look at HOW the AEF differs from other groups. Walter made a bunch of motherhood statements on what makes the AEF a different kind of environment group.
1. trying to bring a more holistic perspective to environmental issues, incl. the needs of human ecology
-- loads of env groups claim the same. eg some enviro groups support a pulp mill in Tassie for local benefit (just not this closed book Gunns version)
2. employing available scientific knowledge to evaluate and mitigate human impacts rather than simply seeking to use it as evidence to support opposition
-- Can you give an eg? eg: how does the AEF's support of the pulp mill 'evaluate and mitigate human impacts'? It seems the AEG just wants to oppose community concerns.
What 'scientific knowledge'have you based that pulp mill policy on? On what scientific or industry standard does the AEF base it's claim that this is a best practice operation? Gunns makes this claim but it's had its share of expert oppositiob. Still on 'scientific knowledge' as something that differentiates AEF, what of the AMA's view of the impact on human health from the inversion & air pollution in the valley? On what basis do you ignore that scientific input? Some other environmental groups have proposed an alternative vision for a pulp mill in Tassie that they feel mitigates human AND environmental impacts - what is the AEF's response on that scientific basis for that policy?
3. high level professional experience in relevant industries and academic diciplines.
-- Ahhh, meaning its closed membership is cut from the same cloth? You forget go to mention the high alliance of political purpose. If this is a valid point of distinctin then it suggests that other citizen activist groups shouldn't have the right to be heard unless they have the same make-up as the AEF. The AEF says it cares for Australians, so that does that extend to right of say from non-scientists and non-industry heads too?
To uphold this supposed distinction then you need to demonstrate that the majority of other environmental groups have inadequate input by Industry and Scientists. The options remaining are Arts, Government and Religion. Do the bulk of environmental groups only employ poofs, politicians and popes?
4. new, small, and have little funding
-- describes plenty of groups
The AEF is still new, ok, it can't point to achievements but it's had long enough now to set its goals. What practical, real achievements does the AEF plan to achieve over the next 12/24/36 months (whatever your planning horizon is)? OR don't you have any plans for specific practical outcomes because you simply want to issue public utterances to drive your political agenda as issues arise in current affairs?
pinxi and Munn - and Rossco, who requests a defence of a falsehood
do your own digging.
Pinxi,
What credible weight does any environmental organisation have? Do any of them have transparent peer reviewed policies? Do any employ standards of evidence or verification? Among the activist groups seeking to influence policy can any provide a list of "practical environmental" achievements? Do any deliver significant real results?
The questions you raise are not really relevant to the nature and purpose of these kinds of organisations. They amount to a straw man.
What makes the AEF so DIFFERENT is that they are an environmental group trying to bring a more holistic perspective to environmental issues. In doing so they are considering the needs of human ecology, not just that of nature devoid of human involvement. This entails employing available scientific knowledge to evaluate and mitigate human impacts rather than simply seeking to use it as evidence to support opposition. A further distinction of the AEF is that its members are overwhelmingly comprised of persons with high level professional experience in relevant industries and academic diciplines. This is certainly a distinct difference from the mainstream environmental organisations wherein both members and staff seldom have any relevant qualifications beyond a desire to "save the environment" and a surfeit of self righteousness.
How successful the AEF will be remains to be seen. They are still new, small, and have little funding but they are raising matters that deserve consideration. Without such voices of opposition environmental concerns have tended to become a mindless rush from one poorly perceived "problem" to the next with no regard for actual consequences and no direction beyond some ill-founded notions of eco-correctness.
If you disagree, state your case. Robust debate leads to better understanding. Sniping is only a bid for attention by those with nothing to say.
I second this request:
Can somebody please give me a list of the "practical environmental" achievements of the AEF?
Posted by: melaleuca at September 11, 2007 12:08 AM
What significant real results does AEF deliver? What is it doing that's so DIFFERENT from the achievements of other hardworking groups (who perhaps lobby less publicly but just get down to hard work on the ground)? Show us it's not just more spin.
Gee what a surprise!!!! But what credible weight does AEC carry? Mmmmm crapola and milk for breaky.
Are AEC policies transparent & peer reviewed? If not, what is their standard of evidence and how is it verified?