Over the last 6 months, readers of The West Australian newspaper have been subjected to a barrage of hysteria over global warming. Very bad news stories of one kind or another are published almost every day, all with the common theme that civilisation as we know it is about to be destroyed.
Some of these stories are simply laughable, like the article asserting that a rise in temperature of 1-2 degrees will result in the extinction of the karri forest. Another reported that rising sea levels (caused by global warming) will, amongst other calamities, lead to a killer increase in salinity in the Swan River. Many readers were surprised by this, since the Swan River is a tidal estuary in its lower reaches, and is fed by the salt-laden Avon River in its upper reaches.
Day after day The West Australian delivers stories unequivocally foretelling the melting of ice caps and glaciers, death of forests, disease outbreaks, the collapse of agriculture, social disruption, loss of coastal communities and beaches, catastrophic storms, floods, droughts and bushfires. All of this is based on an unquestioning acceptance of the theory that human-induced CO2 emissions are causing the world to heat up, and an unquestioning belief in the link between projected warming and ghastly consequences.
I am curious about this lack of editorial scepticism. When it comes to reporting politics or community issues, journalists generally pride themselves on pricking sacred balloons, cutting down tall poppies, exposing spin and highlighting hidden agendas, in short doing what journalists do. The West Australian is quite good in this area, even if their judgement is not always infallible. They have not been afraid to attack government Ministers or powerful Union bosses or to probe politically-incorrect issues, such as alcoholism and education in Indigenous communities. But on global warming their stance is one of uncritical acceptance of Worst Case Scenarios. The whole package of political game-playing and agenda-driven alarmism is taken at face value and delivered on to readers as if the newspaper was a propaganda pamphlet, rather than a mature organ of the Australian media.
It is not just The West Australian. ABC current affairs journalists to a man and woman are also promoters of Global Warming Apocalypse. A good example was the recent segment on The 7.30 Report which suggested that a slight projected increase in temperature would result in a regime of completely unstoppable bushfires. This proposition was put to the gullible journalist by a climatologist and an environmental activist, neither of whom had any experience in bushfire science or management. No one with this knowledge or experience was interviewed.
And just before the Global Warming True Believers launch their barbs at me, I assure them that I accept the idea of climate change - the climate is always changing. I am also concerned about air pollution from industry and vehicles. However, I regard as unproven the theory of ‘accelerated global warming” as a result of human CO2 emissions. And I consider the worst-case scenarios uncritically presented as fact by journalists to be unhelpful to a community struggling to make sense of a complex issue.
There are risks associated with constant promotion of Worst Case Scenarios. The first is that people will start to shrug their shoulders, feeling that the whole situation is beyond hope: the planet is doomed, so we might as well live for the minute. This leads to the second risk: doomsday projections becoming self-fulfilling prophecies.
The one-sided reporting of the global warming debate is perhaps explained by the fact that journalists are frightened of presenting both sides of the global warming story. They do not want to alienate those powerful sections of the community who will attack them if they do, i.e. environmentalists, academics and business interests profiting from global warming alarm. Alternatively we are just seeing another example of the professional immaturity of the Australian media. I have observed that they have always regarded dramatic disasters and fearsome calamities as more newsworthy than everyday life or good citizenship. Thus trees being chainsawed to the accompaniment of wailing protesters is a far “better” story than a forest quietly regrowing under the stewardship of dedicated foresters. I can see no solution to this.
Roger Underwood
Perth, Western Australia
PS: I sent a copy of this article to the Editor of The West asking for any comments before I posted it on this blog. He did not reply. However, a week later a short article appeared with the first positive comment about global warming I have ever seen in this newspaper. The journalist reported the view of a marine scientist that global warming would lead to extensive new coral reefs forming all along the Western Australian coast, perhaps as far south as Perth. That will be nice.
--------------------------
In September 14, 2006, I posted a piece entitled 'Déjà Vu on the ABC' by Roger Underwood which went on to win a place in the On Line Opinion best blogs competition for that year. This article is also about inaccurate and misleading media reporting of an environmental issue. Read more here: https://climatelab.com.au/blog/archives/001633.html.
"You still have not provided the reference for these statements."
Yes I did in one of my posts above. I'll repeat for you:
Anyway, you wanted a reference? Check this out for CO2/Temperature correlation over geologic time intervals - NOT!
http://www.geocities.com/mcmgk/Geologic.html?1200636004328
This graphic has appeared in a number of presentations and papers. I've placed on my own web page for easy reference. The data sources are listed on the graphic.
As Nathan kindly pointed out, "And that graphic about the CO2 levels is from the Paleomap project"
It's bad enough you alarmists pretend that CO2 can have a major climate impact at current levels, never mind when they are 10X as high and are at the extreme of the saturation range. Talk about not understanding the basic physics of how GHG warming works.
Mark - "At 430 m years bp (I used 500 m as a rough date), the world was in an icehouse while CO2 was at 15x preindustrial levels.
- From 150 m years bp to 50 m years CO2 levels dropped from over 2000 ppm to current levels while the temperature went up and then stayed
flat.
- From 30m years ago, temperatures dropped significantly while CO2 was essentially flat."
You still have not provided the reference for these statements. Here is one
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/249/4975/1382
"Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide Levels Over Phanerozoic Time
Robert A. Berner 1
1 Department of Geology and Geophysics, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06511
A new model has been constructed for calculating the level of atmospheric CO2 during the past 570 million years. A series of successive steady states for CO2 is used in order to calculate CO2 level from a feedback function for the weathering of silicate minerals. Processes considered are: sedimentary burial of organic matter and carbonates; continental weathering of silicates, carbonates, and organic matter; and volcanic and metamorphic degassing of CO2. Sediment burial rates are calculated with the use of an isotope mass-balance model and carbon isotopic data on ancient seawater. Weathering rates are calculated from estimates of past changes in continental land area, mean elevation, and river runoff combined with estimates of the effects of the evolution of vascular land plants. Past degassing rates are estimated from changes in the rate of generation of sea floor and the shift of carbonate deposition from platforms to the deep sea. The model results indicate that CO2 levels were high during the Mesozoic and early Paleozoic and low during the Permo-Carboniferous and late Cenozoic. These results correspond to independently deduced Phanerozoic paleoclimates and support the notion that the atmospheric CO2 greenhouse mechanism is a major control on climate over very long time scales."
Interestingly enough this is one of the studies that CO2Science list as one that is against AGW which I do not see in the abstract.
Wes, I can assure you I don't mistake this blog as scientific method - far from it. However where the science of AGW is grossly misrepresented, as it so often is on this site, I think it should be pulled up. No harm in that, you wouldn't want to stifle debate would you?
You pose some useful questions about re-ordering economic systems and welath redistribution impacts of climate change. But thats all they are, questions - most of us are getting on with it and trying to solve some of these issues and its not helped by ideologically driven blog campaigns to undermine legitimate knowledge
Anthony is upset because I compared the sentiments of AGW True Believers, like him, with religious faith.
It is as likely that the AGW question will be settle in the comment section of a blog as the question of the existence of a divine deity. Anthony, and others, obviously mistake comment threads as scientific method. Likewise, no converts to either side are likely occur here as results of the, ahem, arguments posted.
I stand by my comments: This boisterous debate should be taking place in the mainstream media. The fact that it isn't doesn't prove that Al Gore and the IPCC is right, only that AGW is the politically correct flavor of the season.
And that our mass media, especially the taxpayer funded ABC, is failing at its primary function--to inform the public with an unbiased and rational view of current events.
Anthony and others seem to believe that since they perceive a so-called consensus, the matter is settled. That's the tautology of faith, propaganda and coercion, not rational Enlightenment values that form the basis for our civilization and scientific method.
I don't need to point out to a mob of climateheads that a single bloke with a proper working theory (ala Galileo) trumps the entire Church, do I? Of course, such a clever bloke, if he exists, will have about as much luck with ABC as Galileo had with the Church!
Jennifer tried to point out that the AGW consensus/panic is a manufactured mythology of the mainstream media. Perhaps the media has an unspoken, even unconscious, agenda?
What the debate on this thread should have been about is what is going on (and is not going on) in the mainstream media. Has climate change morphed into a political weapon? What happens when science is politicized? Why is there only one side of the story presented in the media? Does our response to climate change entail a reordering of economic systems? If so, does this mean a kind of wealth redistribution? Is the media waging a scare campaign in order to influence public opinion and policy? How does the media hyperbole on AGW tie in with its other favorite canards?
Those are just a few of huge pachyderms in room that Jennifer's insight should have made topical to this thread. Instead, its been hijacked by a visually challenged mob that only wants a tit for tat factoid food fight.
I wonder why?
Nathan,
I'm not disputing a greenhouse effect. I'm disputing that continued use of fossil fuels by mankind will cause further major warming. And as to the graph, let's be more precise:
- At 430 m years bp (I used 500 m as a rough date), the world was in an icehouse while CO2 was at 15x preindustrial levels.
- From 150 m years bp to 50 m years CO2 levels dropped from over 2000 ppm to current levels while the temperature went up and then stayed
flat.
- From 30m years ago, temperatures dropped significantly while CO2 was essentially flat.
The lack of correlation indicates that CO2 cannot be the major climate driver over the geoogic timescales shown. Can't you alarmists get it through your head that the physics of greenhouse grasses show that the warming relationship is logarithmic - at current levels there is not much additional warmng to be had particlarly if Lindzen is correct in his assessment (and I believe he is).
http://www.junkscience.com/Greenhouse/co2greenhouse-X2.png
And as to the faint sun thing, please show me the specific reference that deal with timescales. The faint sun was a factor billions of years ago but is not relevant to the discussion of the past 3 billon years. And why even bring up red giants and increased luminosity - that's billions of years out and has o relevance to the current discussion!
And yes I am in disagreement with the Royal Society. That paper you referenced provides only a passing discussion of temperature with no proof of anything.
Nathan,
I'm not disputing a greenhouse effect. I'm disputing that continued use of fossil fuels by mankind will cause further major warming. And as to the graph, let's be more precise:
- At 430 m years bp (I used 500 m as a rough date), the world was in an icehouse while CO2 was at 15x preindustrial levels.
- From 150 m years bp to 50 m years CO2 levels dropped from over 2000 ppm to current levels while the temperature went up and then stayed
flat.
- From 30m years ago, temperatures dropped significantly while CO2 was essentially flat.
The lack of correlation indicates that CO2 cannot be the major climate driver over the geoogic timescales shown. Can't you alarmists get it through your head that the physics of greenhouse grasses show that the warming relationship is logarithmic - at current levels there is not much additional warmng to be had particlarly if Lindzen is correct in his assessment (and I believe he is).
http://www.junkscience.com/Greenhouse/co2greenhouse-X2.png
And as to the faint sun thing, please show me the specific reference that deal with timescales. The faint sun was a factor billions of years ago but is not relevant to the discussion of the past 3 billon years. And why even bring up red giants and increased luminosity - that's billions of years out and has o relevance to the current discussion!
And yes I am in disagreement with the Royal Society. That paper you referenced provides only a passing discussion of temperature with no proof of anything.
Mark, the funniest thing is that the source of the climate drivers graphic you used:
http://www.searchanddiscovery.net/documents/gerhard/index.htm
Actually supports my argument.
Do you read the sources of your data as they are generally quite informative.
And that graphic about the CO2 levels is from the Paleomap project, which again supports the hypothesis that there is a greenhouse effect and it has been in operation for hundreds of millions of years.
How much did you read that website Mark?
http://www.geocomplexity.com/Global_climate.htm
It actually seems to support my argument.
It also disputes your claim that 500 million years ago was the coldest ever. Apparently it was in a 'greenhouse' state and was quite warm.
The graph you showed about solar luminosity just stated that solar luminosity is a 'first order' factor. On par with "Greenhouse atmosphere" and "solar system geometry".
Solar luminosity will continue to increase until after the sun enters it's Red Giant stage (when it will be bigger than the orbit of the Earth).
You can't claim weather is a way of 'disproving' Global Warming.
Mark, so you didn't read any of the papers I suggested?
I guess you disagreement is with the Royal Society:
"Correlation of CO2 levels with estimates of palaeoclimate suggests that the atmospheric greenhouse effect has been a major factor in controlling global climate over the past 600 million years."
And here's some papers about the early lower solar luminosity
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v277/n5698/abs/277640a0.html
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/198/4321/1035
What's the source of your data?
I know who I'll be trusting.
Sorry mates, had to scoot off earlier to play some ice hockey!
Anyway, you wanted a reference? Check this out for CO2/Temperature correlation over geologic time intervals - NOT!
http://www.geocities.com/mcmgk/Geologic.html?1200636004328
This graphic has appeared in a number of presentations and papers. I've placed on my own web page for easy reference. The data sources are listed on the graphic.
Oh and Nathan, what is this tripe about a weak sun during the period of the dinosaurs and therefore it had to be CO2 that kept things warm?? Thats rubbish! Yes, the sun had lower luminosity in its infancy but that was 3 to 4 billion years ago, not 200 million! See the graphic below.
http://www.geocities.com/mcmgk/Climate_Drivers.html?1200636759062
(original source http://www.geocomplexity.com/Global_climate.htm)
As Sid said: "Meanwhile in the real world the current northern winter, continues to be anything from mild, or even average, with continueous extreme cold reports regularly flowing in."
Here's the 30 day outlook for Canada. Some global warming!
http://www.weatheroffice.gc.ca/saisons/image_e.html?img=mfe1t_s&title=forecasts