"You can do a lot of damage with $10 billion. It can be used to build a lot of halls of fame and finance a lot of local community groups. In short, $10 billion can fund a lot of porkbarrelling in a lot of marginal seats.
Ten billion dollars is how much (on a conservative estimate) the federal government will make in 2010 from the sale of permits to emit greenhouse gases. Potentially double that amount could be collected - and if so federal government revenue would jump by 10 per cent. Anyone who believes that climate change is a gravy train only for lawyers, accountants and ‘‘environmental advisers’’ should think again. No politician has ever missed the chance to save the planet, especially if they can also garner a few billion dollars as a re-election war chest.
So far the government is not telling us what it will do with the embarrassment of riches it is about to receive.
In a speech last week to the Melbourne Institute, Labor’s climate change tsar, Ross Garnaut, said the additional revenue should be devoted to supporting ‘‘adjustment to a low-emissions economy’’. That sounds chillingly like code for a $10 billion ‘‘industry structural adjustment’’ program.
Garnaut said that whatever funding was provided to enable an adjustment to a low-emissions economy should be allocated ‘‘transparently’’. As someone experienced in the ways of government, Garnaut would appreciate that transparency is in the eye of the beholder. More transparency is better than less transparency, but of itself transparency doesn’t guarantee good policy outcomes. If the government funds the newest and trendiest low emissions technology, it can do so in an entirely transparent way; but that doesn’t change the fact that government is nonetheless picking winners.
One of the things Kevin Rudd could do with his windfall gains is cut taxes. The question is what taxes to cut. Priority should be given to reducing personal income tax as, ultimately, it is going to be individual consumers either directly or indirectly paying the costs of higher electricity prices. But cutting income taxes doesn’t compensate for the effect of raising industry costs on a country like Australia that’s dependent on cheap energy for its comparative advantage in international trading.
In his speech, Garnaut warned that ‘‘continuing disputation about parameters of the scheme, uncertainty, continuing politicisation of the ETS’s [emissions trading scheme’s] operations, would dissipate resources in unproductive activity, and seriously disrupt productivity growth’’.
An unkind person could translate this as ‘‘be quiet and leave it to the bureaucrats’’. The trouble is, bureaucrats don’t have a sparkling track record designing markets - ask anyone who’s had the misfortune of visiting a public hospital lately. Given the massive change that the introduction of an emissions trading scheme involves, it’s entirely appropriate that there be as much ‘‘disputation’’ as possible - particularly given that the scheme is going to begin within two years.
Climate change bureaucrats are going to be busy over the next few years as they invent an emissions trading scheme and scurry back and forth between Canberra and New York, because ultimately the scheme will be in the hands of the United Nations.
Labor has promised that Australia’s emissions trading scheme will be integrated into a global system. A few days ago the global head of carbon emissions for Merrill Lynch spelled out exactly what this means. ‘‘Every single carbon credit that comes in or out of Australia has to have a unique serial number, and that serial number is tracked by the United Nations.’’
The Department of Climate Change estimates that in the next few years this country’s greenhouse gas emissions will be about 600 million tonnes of carbon dioxide. Under the current European emissions scheme, one carbon credit is provided for every tonne of carbon dioxide. Even if only 10 per cent of Australia’s emissions are internationally traded, that still leaves 60 million carbon credits that must be given a serial number and reported to the UN.
There’s a certain irony that Kevin Rudd has pledged to cut red tape. His government is on the verge of imposing an emissions trading scheme with rules so complicated they will make the 8000 pages of tax laws look simple. Whatever complaints there are about the Australian Taxation Office, it is surely a paragon of efficiency compared with the UN.
Having the UN monitor and regulate Australia’s emissions trading almost sounds like an April’s fool’s joke - except that the first of April was three days ago."
John Roskam is the Executive Director of the Institute of Public Affairs and this article has been republished from the Australian Financial Review with permission from the author.
Spot on, Kent. Steve likes to paint all this as some sort of fantasy, as if all the good honest people he knows would never accept such a scenario. But he forgets that stalinism grew out of the same high minded soil that produced Tolstoy and the enhanced sensitivity of Dostoyevski. He forgets that the train to Auscwitz was driven by loving family men who regarded it as a safer job than driving an amunition train to the Russian front. He forgets that when supposedly civilised europeans are given a choice between one group of homicidal maniacs killing farmers and priests, and another group killing money lenders and lawyers, they WILL support one or the other.
And if he doesn't think it could happen again he should take trip to Bosnia, Zimbabwe, Gaza or Tibet.
"Hey doug, did you know the energy industries (via the Energy Supply Association of Australia) are actually calling for emissions trading, clear targets, and clear climate policy?"
Who cares? Whats that got to do with anything? Big business are pussies and totally unreliable partners when it comes to the promotion of liberty. They also have little affinity with free enterprise as restrictions help them over their smaller competitors.
Do you have any evidence for this racket or are you just going to stand around looking like someone itching to do malicious damage?
Ross Garnaut's role, carried in stories like this one http://business.smh.com.au/petrol-power-to-bear-emissions-burden/20080323-214f.html?sssdmh=dm16.307826 is a marketing one; to soften people up on behalf of the federal government. He floats, for example, then minimises the notion that electricity prices will double under Rudd's emissions trading policy.
He is employing a cynical marketing technique, referred to in some circles as "prepping the suckers." Garnaut is foreshadowing the government's ambit log of claims against the public on carbon trading. The ambit strategy runs like this; the marketer introduces his target audience to a concept that something dire and unacceptable is about to happen. Later on he delivers an outcome which is a little less extreme. That outcome is then reported as if it was good news because although negative, it is less painful than originally suggested. Having gotten away with that, when the dust settles, the dose can be repeated as often as needed without fear of much complaint. Each time the public can be told they are being protected from an even worse outcome. Totalitarian governments, like the old Soviets, were masters of this technique.
I won't reflect here upon the UN junkscience all this trading is predicated upon, but how long will ordinary working Australians continue to be duped into supporting a forced redistribution of their wealth and to allow sizeable chunks of Australia's economic sovereignty to be handed over to UN bureaucrats who simply see us as a cash cow?
Big trough. Big snouts.
Dear Steve,
I think your description in your third post could be argued to largely fit North Korea in 2008, other than the preferred colour choice of the resident totalitarians ?
So perhaps we have defined the shape of absolutist, totalitarian regimes at least - and not as works of fiction ?
Rgds