WASHINGTON - The Andes Mountains may have growth spurts, doubling their height in as little as 2 million to 4 million years, US researchers reported on Thursday.
Their findings suggest that current theories about plate tectonics -- the process that creates and moves continents, giving rise to mountain ranges -- may need updating...
Garzione proposes an alternative theory -- that delamination causes the root to heat up and ooze downward like a drop of thick syrup, abruptly breaking free and sinking into the hot mantle. The mountains above, suddenly free of the root, then spring up...
Read more here: http://www.planetark.com/dailynewsstory.cfm/newsid/48697/story.htm
Story from Planetark via Reuters. Reporting by Maggie Fox; Editing by Will Dunham and Xavier Briand
Austin,
So the mechanism is plate tectonics? But that has been comprehensively falsified for various reasons which I won't go into detail here but some of the papers can be read on http://WWW.NCGT.org
If PT is invalid, how then to explain this accelerated rise? (and the electrical supply to Halls Creek is off, as well as all the land telephone lines because some idiot dug up the Telstra Cable, again)
Anyone remember stress and strain?
Delamination releases mechanical energy due to friction within the moving pieces undergoing shear after a long buildup of strain. Think of it as tectonic rug burn.
Repeated delamination would heat the root up until it reached the heat of melting and then it could all go at once because its under much greater pressure than the surrounding rock.
Once it melted, it would no longer be anchored to the rocks above which would rise and the melted root would fall. The plate would move into the void.
Another very useful line of analysis is to look at the seismic tomographic data but one should be cautious - Some years back I recalled one analysis that concluded that the mantle was a tri-lobed structure and found the paper using Google. Now it's off the search engines, as far as I can tell.
All rather worrying really.
I just discovered the latest Microsoft file indexing service had not indexed my 500Gb storage drive where all my research data is stored ( thousands of papers and articles) so I have to wait until the indexing completes before I can add further comment on this topic.(Miocrosoft seems to be in two minds with indexing services - you think something is being cataloged but discover it isn't. Very frustrating - over 15 years of data collection and it cannot be searched at present).
Having said that, I should also point out that plate tectonics isn't a valid geological process either and plenty of papers on http://www.ncgt.org
So if subduction is not occurring, then the whole scenario described in the article is also wrong but I do accept the conclusion that the Andes rose up in a spurt - it's the mechanism of how that was achieved that is the issue.
Thanks for your comments, Louis. I will check up on isostasy and Airey, and look forward to your future comments on the matter. As the case for AGW seems to be collapsing, other perspectives from geology, tectonics, vulcanism etc. are well worth exploring. Career hungry academics might note this, and abandon ship before it becomes too obvious why they have done so. Imre Lakatos offered a few useful ideas on 'degenerate research programs'.
I agree with Louis on the density issue - as it stands, it makes no sense.
Would need to read the full paper to understand the metasediment dating that allows the assertion "doubling in height in 2-4 million years"
The NZ South Island Alps are certainly currently increasing in height, but nowhere near this rate. The tremors from the plate movements causing this are well recorded of course.