• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Bloggers Fail to Negate Broader Global Warming Argument: Cameron Stewart
Uncategorized

Bloggers Fail to Negate Broader Global Warming Argument: Cameron Stewart

By jennifer
August 9, 2008

Cameron Stewart writing in today's The Australian makes reference to the influence of internet bloggers in succeeding in highlighting that measuring climate change is an evolving science. But, goes on to suggest that "their success has been at the margins only" because we have apparently failed to "prove that these discrepancies negate the broader core arguments about the trends of global warming."

The article is entitled 'Key degrees of difference' and it begins:

"Has global warming stopped? The question alone is enough to provoke scorn from the mainstream scientific community and from the Government, which says the earth has never been hotter. But tell that to a new army of sceptics who have mushroomed on internet blog sites and elsewhere in recent months to challenge some of the most basic assumptions and claims of climate change science...

Read more here: http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24148862-11949,00.html

This is at least the second time in the last two weeks that internet bloggers have been identified by the mainstream Australian media as relevant to the debate on climate change. The earlier story was on ABC Lateline, you can watch the video clip: http://www.abc.net.au/news/video/2008/07/29/2318074.htm . I comment on the Lateline report in an associated blog post here:

Good Causes

Comments

  1. "Now why would anyone simply interested in money spend all that time doing very very hard physics and maths degrees.."

    Please point out anyone named on the front of the AR4 Synthesis Report with a "very hard physics or maths degree".
    In fact, point out anyone with a REAL science degree - period.

    "Why would scientists want to voluntarily be on IPCC working groups at endless meetings trying to distill the "science consensus" to be rewarded with rampant abuse from the population. It's more about service than reward."

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
    Service - right. Very funny - hilarious, even. Swanning off to Rio, Bali, Bangkok, etc.
    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
    These IPCC junkets are the usless articles' five minutes of fame.

  2. "That's the price you paid when Harvard business school cross-bred with science management in the 1990's."
    So, Luke, you're saying, in effect, that we're stuck with some bastard pup-child creation with supplementary neck bolts? And now it's chasing us down the street arms stretched wanting to get us?
    Metaphorically speaking of course.

  3. Sunset - could it also be that you're rampantly speculating.

    "Could it be because they know deep down that AGW hypothesis is pure B.S. but the money is real and nice to have along with a contrived good reputation built on UNVERIFIABLE research?"

    Now why would anyone simply interested in money spend all that time doing very very hard physics and maths degrees when business would make you much richer. Sorry most of the people who do science are doing to because they're interested. And anyone in Cooperative Research Centres would have noted that funding comes and goes.

    Most scientists would love to have a breakthrough on an issue that nobody else has seen.

    Why would scientists want to voluntarily be on IPCC working groups at endless meetings trying to distill the "science consensus" to be rewarded with rampant abuse from the population. It's more about service than reward.

    AGW is a very complex problem and the intertwining of politics and science doesn't help. Plus this is now expensive science which is expected to be run professionally in major programs with performance indicators and milestones. The notion that there is plenty of time for gentleman scientists to indulge their fancies chasing every rainbow just isn't there. That's the price you paid when Harvard business school cross-bred with science management in the 1990s. Programs, budgets, plans, and process.

  4. SJT:

    "He's right into smears as well, if you have been reading his posts. For some curious reason, however, nothing from the denier crowd is ever given the blowtorch to the belly, despite a rich field of pickings out there."

    You have yet to post examples of alleged smears.

    "I don't doubt that there are errors in the science, science is one long history of errors and mistakes being corrected and improved upon. Newton got it wrong, Einstein got it wrong. Yet science moves on, and, in the long run gets it right."

    Were those guys accused of smearing anyone?

    " AGW is a mature theory now, and the scientific basis behind it is now accepted by Pat Michaels and anyone else who is keen to keep their scientific credentials intact to some degree. Pat Michaels also says you can't call this a cooling of climate, because that's an abuse of science as well. Yet you will still read endless people here and on other climateaudit still questioning these basic facts. Why doesn't McIntyre get to work on them?"

    AGW HYPOTHESIS has been considered settled science by you guys.Without "debate".So why are all the AGW believer scientists still getting millions of $$ in research grants each year?

    Plus the world is supposed to be in grave peril.Why bother giving money away into research that have allegedly proven everything?

    Could it be because they know deep down that AGW hypothesis is pure B.S. but the money is real and nice to have along with a contrived good reputation built on UNVERIFIABLE research?

  5. "Then why don't you go to climateaudit and explain to steve why he is wrong? After all, if it is so obviously a "smear job" then you should be able to explain exactly why steve is wrong an W&A are right."

    He's right into smears as well, if you have been reading his posts. For some curious reason, however, nothing from the denier crowd is ever given the blowtorch to the belly, despite a rich field of pickings out there.

    I don't doubt that there are errors in the science, science is one long history of errors and mistakes being corrected and improved upon. Newton got it wrong, Einstein got it wrong. Yet science moves on, and, in the long run gets it right.

    AGW is a mature theory now, and the scientific basis behind it is now accepted by Pat Michaels and anyone else who is keen to keep their scientific credentials intact to some degree. Pat Michaels also says you can't call this a cooling of climate, because that's an abuse of science as well. Yet you will still read endless people here and on other climateaudit still questioning these basic facts. Why doesn't McIntyre get to work on them?

  6. Gordon; I think Steve McIntyre sums up the Mann debacle well in his own words;

    http://www.climateaudit.org/pdf/ohio.pdf

    The subsequent Ammann and Wahl disgrace is well up there as a prime example of the misrepresentation by pro-AGW science; another good one is the recent paper on thermal wind shear by Allen and Sherwood;

    http://www.nature.com/ngeo/journal/v1/n6/abs/ngeo208.html

    In this paper the boys acknowledge that the predicted troposphere heating has not been travelling well, so they postulate that radiosonde temp measurement is deficient, but radiosonde wind measure is up to speed; so if an assumption is made that measured wind shear is indicative of temperature, then if model predicted wind shear is confirmed by radiosonde wind measurements then it must follow that the postulated temperature must also be as the model predicts; now this is, ipso facto, nuts; it's like saying if the sun shines tomorrow then people will die; and then when actual deaths occur concluding therefore that the sun kills people; IMO this is probably more egregious than the Ammann nonsense, which is just dishonest; the Sherwood effort raises issues of reality; perhaps that's what it is, reality by scientific edict; I can't recall a more bizarre effort from the AGW crowd, but I'm willing to be persuaded. I'm also interested in SJT's response to the implicit intellectual barrenness manifest by the Sherwood paper.

  7. "The 9% swing against them in the NT elections yesterday suggests times might be a-changing."

    I notice that the Messiah of Change isn't having everything his own way in the US either:
    http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/election_20082/2008_presidential_election/general_election_match_up_history

    See also: us-elections.suite101.com/article.cfm/mccain_leads_obama
    "McCain now leads only by one point in the general poll, but looking underneath we see an extremely close race. Fifty-five percent of the nation sees John McCain in a positive light, while only 51% approve of Barack Obama. This would seem to go against the conventional wisdom that Obama will be carried into office easily come November."

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *