• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • William Kininmonth on the Radiation of Energy and Global Warming
Uncategorized

William Kininmonth on the Radiation of Energy and Global Warming

By jennifer
August 17, 2008

Could ‘the greenhouse effect’ be one of those things that everybody claims to understand because it is apparently so important, but in reality it is not supported by a credible scientific literature?

That's the view of Bill Kininmonth, meteorologist and head of Australia's National Climate Centre from 1986 to 1998.

Furthermore, Mr Kininmonth is of the view that, "the role of greenhouse gases is to cool the atmosphere and this, with the surface warming from solar radiation, generates convective instability. It is the temperature lapse rate required for deep convection that leads to the ‘greenhouse effect’"

Confused?

Well in the following note, Mr Kininmonth explains in more detail:

The closest you will come to an explanation of carbon dioxide and the green house effect is in the 'Frequently Asked Questions' of the on-line IPCC Fourth Assessment Report.

My critique on them follows.

“The IPCC’s most recent assessment attempts to be helpful to the casual enquirer by having a series of explanations for ‘frequently asked questions’, or FAQs. The first FAQ is ‘What factors determine earth’s climate’? We are informed that, on average, the earth emits 240 w m-2 of radiation to space and that this equates to an emission temperature of -19oC. The earth’s temperature, however, is about 14oC and the -19oC temperature is found at a height of about 5 km above the surface. To quote the IPCC: “The reason the earth’s surface is this warm is the presence of greenhouse gases, which act as a partial blanket for the longwave radiation coming from the earth’s surface. This blanketing is known as the natural greenhouse effect”.

This explanation by the IPCC is clearly misleading, if not wrong. The inference that the greenhouse gases are acting like a blanket suggests that they are increasing the insulating properties of the atmosphere. However, the main gases of the atmosphere are oxygen and nitrogen, non-greenhouse gases, and they are also excellent insulators against the conduction of heat (like a blanket); adding additional trace amounts of carbon dioxide will have no appreciable impact on the insulating properties of the atmosphere.

In its third FAQ, ‘What is the greenhouse effect?’ the IPCC comes to the nub of the issue but provides a different and equally misleading explanation. “Much of the thermal radiation emitted by the land and the ocean is absorbed by the atmosphere, including clouds, and reradiated back to earth. This is called the greenhouse effect”. According to the IPCC’s global energy budget, the surface emits 390 W m-2 of radiation and the energy radiated back to the surface is 324 W m-2. It is difficult to see how an ongoing net loss of longwave radiation energy from the surface of 66 W m-2 can lead to warming! Indeed, we are all aware that between dusk and dawn the earth’s surface cools.

The IPCC has not explained in a scientifically sound and coherent way, how the ‘greenhouse effect’ is maintained. The greenhouse gases do not increase the insulating properties of the atmosphere and the back radiation does not warm the surface. The IPCC explanation of the greenhouse effect is obfuscation and, even to the mildly scientific literate, reflects ignorance of basic processes of the climate system.”

I am of the view that ‘the greenhouse effect’ is one of those things that is accepted because it is there, everybody claims to understand it because it is so important, but in reality few know how it comes about. My explanation follows (and you will not find this in IPCC publications):

“A credible explanation has no need for smoke and mirrors. The energy flow through the climate system is predominantly by way of four stages: 1) absorption of solar radiation at the surface; 2) conduction of heat and evaporation of latent energy from the surface to the atmospheric boundary layer; 3) convective overturning that distributes heat and latent energy through the troposphere; and 4) radiation of energy from the atmosphere to space. We will see that it is the characteristics of convective overturning that keep the surface warmer than it would otherwise be.

The Kiehl and Trenberth (1997) global average energy budget of the earth (see figure, where the units are W m-2) is used by the IPCC and is a useful starting point for explanation of the establishment and maintenance of the greenhouse effect.

Radiation BalanceIPCC.jpg

Of the 340 units of solar radiation entering the earth’s atmosphere, 67 are absorbed by the atmosphere and 168 are absorbed at the surface. There is thus an ongoing source of solar energy available to the atmosphere and the surface.

At the surface there is a net accumulation of radiation energy because the incoming solar radiation (168 units) exceeds the net loss of longwave radiation (66 units).

In the atmospheric layer there is absorption of 417 units (390 of emission from the surface, less 40 that go directly to space, plus absorption of 67 of solar radiation) and an emission of 519 units (324 back to the surface and 195 direct emission to space). The net effect of the interaction between the greenhouse gases and radiation is a tendency to cool the atmosphere because it is continually losing energy.

Overall there is a dichotomy, with radiation processes firstly tending to warm the earth’s surface and secondly tending to cool the atmosphere. Air is an excellent insulator against conduction of heat and will not transfer heat through the atmosphere, as is necessary for energy balance. Also, the thermodynamic properties of air (potential temperature increases with height) ensure that turbulent motions of the atmosphere will mix energy downward, not upward as required.

The process for transferring energy from the surface to the atmosphere, necessary to achieve overall energy balance of the climate system, was explained by Herbert Riehl and Joanne Malkus (the latter better known as Joanne Simpson) in a 1958 paper, On the heat balance of the equatorial trough zone (Geophysica). Riehl and Malkus noted that boundary layer air, rising buoyantly in the protected updraughts of deep tropical convection clouds, converts heat and latent energy to potential energy. Away from the convection, compensating subsidence converts potential energy to heat.

What is implied in the Riehl and Malkus model is that deep tropical convection, and the transfer of energy from the surface to the atmosphere, will not take place without buoyant updraughts within deep convection clouds. That is, there is a need for the temperature of the atmosphere to decrease with altitude and that the rate of decrease of temperature must be sufficient to allow buoyancy of the air ascending in the updraughts. From well-known thermodynamic laws, the rate of decrease of temperature must be at least 6.5oC/km to allow the buoyancy forces of convection to overcome the natural stratification of the atmosphere.

The climate system will come into energy equilibrium when temperatures are such that the net solar radiation absorbed is balanced by the longwave radiation to space. At equilibrium, the greenhouse effect (ie, that the average surface temperature of 14oC is greater than the -19oC blackbody emission temperature of earth) is an outcome from the need for convective overturning of the atmosphere.”

Essentially, the role of greenhouse gases is to cool the atmosphere and this, with the surface warming from solar radiation, generates convective instability. It is the temperature lapse rate required for deep convection that leads to the ‘greenhouse effect’. But this takes the wind from the sails of the AGW folk.

William Kininmonth
Melbourne

Mr Kininmonth is the author of Climate Change: A Natural Hazard available from Amazons.

---------------
AEF_Conference advert Tower.png

Good Causes

Comments

  1. It now becomes clear how Ender's physics has become so warped.

    Ender, you really listen to stuff from Berzerkeley???

  2. Bill is definitively correct re: Back Radiation, it cannot meaningfully occur for two reasons.

    1. The emissivity of non-reflective solids is 3 orders of magnitude larger than low pressure, low temperature GHGs H2O & CO2. Even if the atmosphere is hotter by tens of degrees C, the surface OLR will render insignificant any returning radiation of GHGs in their direction.

    2. The fact that the air is heated by OLR is definitive proof that this region of the atmosphere is not in thermal equilibrium. Incoming flux exceeds outgoing flux, if minutely, and the result is increased kinetic energy of the entire molecular complement of the region, increased temp. This means the GHGs lose the absorbed energy to its neighbors by conduction and do not emit in direct relation to their rate of absorption.

    All of this is Thermodynamics, which is not introductory physics and is manifestly not required of Climate Science grads at any level, even those with physics concentrations.

  3. O.K. Graeme I certainly follow your logic and it is very reasonable but if all this warming is being transported up into the troposphere by water vapour why have we not seen the increase in troposphere temperatures in either the UAH or RSS data as predicted by the IPCC in their 4th report. My embedded point here is that both water vapour and CO2 level off in their forcing effect at a relatively low ppm level < 100 ppm this is proven in John Nicol’s paper ( and many others) this does not include water as and aerosol only as a gas. Thus the lack of any change in forcing effect with a large variation in concentration is in conformance with the laws of physics and observations.
    I do agree with you about WPSM , IPCC waffles on about them ad nausium page after page and it is all just smoke and mirrors.

  4. No water vapour won't cause enourmous problems if it increases. This is the curse of the watts per square metre business again.

    Water vapour magnifies the variation of the sun on the troposphere. But it is the method by which the oceans cool down. This is something that you miss if you attempt to process the data all the way to watts per square metre.

    Looking at the more meaningful measure of imbedded oceanic energy, it is the water vapour which is cooling the oceans down. Transporting heat into space.

    It is an EFFECT of excessive warming, seen from the oceans point of view and not a cause. Seen from the troposphere's point of view it is THE cause of warming but when it overheats it is bringing the problem to an end. Since it is cooling the oceans.

    From the stratosphere's point of view it is an immediate cooler.

    I'm telling you be quits with WPSM. It robs all perspective. It makes people stupid. You could start off with a great understanding of earth systems and weather. And the WPSM model would whittle it away over time.

  5. Barry, I think you misunderstand the point that I was making. My point was that we cannot attribute recent changes in global temperature to water vapor, because historically (over several hundred years) there is no evidence to indicate that it has increased. Yes, there are big differences between water vapor at the poles and water vapor at the equator -- that's why the poles are warming faster than the equator.

    "how come if CO2 doubles from 300 to 600 we will have a runaway disaster but water can change from 34 to 25 000 without any adverse effect."

    Indeed, if water vapor concentrations increase, they will cause enormous problems. In fact, this is another one of those nasty positive feedback factors. All by itself, a doubling of CO2 concentrations will increase global temperatures by only a few degrees C. But a small increase in global temperatures will ALSO put more water vapor into the air, which in turn will lead to larger increases in temperature. I'm not at all dismissing the effect of water vapor -- it's one of the factors that magnifies the danger of CO2 emissions.

    "how can you possibly put this into a computer model when the dew point is all over the map on a daily basis which is totally unpredictable."

    This is the difference between weather and climate. Yes, weather variables change rapidly. But for purposes of predicting climate (not weather), you don't need to track these variables with that much resolution. You can rely on data averaged over a period of time and apply standard diurnal and annual variations.

  6. Chris I don’t know if you are still following this blog I have been elsewhere for a couple of days. Your question re the absorption of CO2 at 400 ppm is explained best in the paper by John Nicol – Climate Change, if you can not find it his e mail is jonicol@netspace.net.au it is the best paper dealing with this subject using the fundamental laws of physics. The law you need is Beer’s law to calculate the mean path of the CO2 resonant frequencies.
    Again I think you missed the implication of “At -50 deg C the saturated water vapour content of the atmosphere is 34 ppm at 25 deg C it is 25 000 ppm so from the south pole to the equator we have quite a large variation in concentration. Now if the world warms up there will be a considerable change in this concentration thus water vapour is not constant irrespective of temperature, far from it. With respect to this massive change in concentration the same laws of physics apply to water as to CO2 so how come if CO2 doubles from 300 to 600 we will have a runaway disaster but water can change from 34 to 25 000 without any adverse effect. “ It really does not matter whether the cause is anthropogenic or not, first study the effect of the change then figure out where it comes from. If the atmosphere is as sensitive to concentration changes as that ridiculous empirical formula published by the IPCC then this must apply to water vapour as well as CO2 and the water vapour content of the atmosphere is changing regionally by massive amounts how can you possibly put this into a computer model when the dew point is all over the map on a daily basis which is totally unpredictable.

  7. No mate you are barking up the wrong tree. You are a fraud. You are an idiot. Skeptics understand the global warming idiocy enough to know its a lie.

    Now lets have that evidence.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *