• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Polar Bears Move When Climate Changes: A Note from Nichole Hoskin
Opinion

Polar Bears Move When Climate Changes: A Note from Nichole Hoskin

By jennifer
September 6, 2008

THIRTY years ago polar bear experts were discussing 'climatic fluctuations' rather than climate change, and the effect this can have on polar bear distribution in the Arctic.  In fact, Christian Vibe, the Greenland representative on the Polar Bear Specialist Group, was more focused on how climatic fluctuations affected distribution, than abundance.  His observations back then, for example polar bears drowning in scattered drift ice, are similar to what is being observed now.  But back then such incidences were not considered unusual or causing long term decline in polar bear numbers.

At the 2nd Working Meeting of the Polar Bear Specialist Group, in 1970, Dr Vibe said:

“The ecological conditions of the Arctic have changed as a result of this alteration of the climate. Some high Arctic regions get colder winters and less open water in summer. The productivity of the sea decreases in the Arctic and in regions nearer the Atlantic. The ringed seal moves to the areas of higher productivity, and the polar bear follows the seal.

This is the situation today in Northwest as well as in Northeast and Southeast Greenland. All other animals in Greenland, in the sea as well as on land, are affected by the same climatical fluctuations, which are reflected in a regular shift between Arctic and Atlantic conditions (or Continental and Atlantic) over a period of 56 to 66 years; they are more marked every second time the period culminates. The climatic situation of today, with intense movements in the drift ice in summer, is very similar to that 110-120 years ago. For the polar bear, especially in East Greenland, that means unstable living conditions, more roaming, and probably greater loss of animals by drowning in scattered drift ice off South Greenland.

Under the Atlantic conditions of forty years ago [1930], the drift ice from the Polar Basin kept moving throughout the winter and melted at high latitudes in summer. The situation for the polar bear was quite the opposite to that today [1970]. It then had to go ashore early in summer at high latitudes –and fewer got lost.

Alternatively, we could say that the polar bear probably was more numerous 30-40 years ago - as all Arctic animals were - but the Arctic-Continental climate of today has forced it south to regions with unstable drift ice conditions and within the range of man.” (pgs 20-21)

In this extract from Dr Vibe, written in 1970, he notes the negative effects of colder Arctic winters and less open water in summer. He explains that polar bears in the late 1960s were moving southwards to unstable sea conditions, with the possibility that more polar bears were dying.  However, Dr Vibe also noted that polar bears adapt to climatic fluctuations in the Arctic by moving to the areas with more of their primary prey, ringed seals, as ringed seals move to more suitable habitats. 

This note was sent to me by Nichole Hoskin from the Blue Moutains in Australia.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Nice try at a side-step, Ann. The issue is how far the unmonitored male half of the population wander and what proportion of these unmonitored animals return to their previous territory. The monitoring has concentrated on the females who return to particular denning sites, but they are only half of the story.

    Lets look at the supposedly worst case population decline in WHudson Bay. Over a 20 year interval some 5.88% of a total population of 4,500 have been found to be "not present" in a sub-territory defined by the movements of females.

    This has been assumed to be a result of either an increase in adult mortality, a decline in birth rate, or a failure of cub survival. But according to Vibe, this could also be a consequence of migration within the larger population groupings.

    If we divide the 5.88% by 20 years we find that it would only take a consistent annual migration of only 0.294 of 1% of this population to produce the same result.

    And given that the Hudson Bay ice sheet will tend to contract to the north with each summer thaw, the likelihood that the most distant animals will follow that retraction north into a new sub-territory is quite high.

    But please do keep up the petty sneers, Ann, they signpost your total lack of substantive response. Lets face it. The IUCN has been caught out flogging Polar Bear $hit. It looks like bull$hit, smells like bull$hit and burns a hole in the fresh snow of truth, just like bull$hit.

  2. Libby,

    I have the Stirling et al paper and the original Dyck et al paper. I am eagerly awaiting the Dyck et al response to the Stirling et al paper.

    Thanks for the offer. It is much appreciated

  3. Nichole,

    The response I was referring to is "Reply to response to Dyck et al. (2007) on polar bears and climate change in western Hudson Bay by Stirling et al. (2008)". It is listed as an article in press. It is available on line.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *