I’M often confronted, via my Facebook News Feed, with grotesque images of butchered animals and an expectation that I participate in the emotionally satisfying activity of clicking ‘like’ and thus demonstrating that I’m against animal cruelty and for conservation. I’ve never once seen something in my Facebook News Feed that promotes the sustainable use of wildlife. Yet this is more likely to contribute to the long term survive of species like the Rhinoceros. 
The last few years has seen a dramatic rise in the incidence of rhino poaching. Previously secure populations are now being targeted by aggressive poaching operations, backed by international crime syndicates. Part of the problem is that the legal trade has been banned following campaigning by the ignorant self-righteous.
The illegal trade is driven by the high price for rhino horn because a worldwide trade ban has made rhino horn artificially scarce.
As Michael ‘t Sas-Rolfes explains:
“Establishing an appropriately structured legal trading regime for rhino horn may provide a more effective and lasting solution to the rhino poaching problem for three reasons:
First [a legal trade] would bring trade out into the open. Market prices would be visible, thereby allowing for continued and accurate monitoring of ongoing consumer demand relative to supply. This would enable governments, conservationists and rhino owners to be far more immediately responsive to changing market conditions. It would also enable them to identify and engage directly with consumers.
Second, by providing a significantly increased and potentially ongoing source of supply, the incentives for speculative stockpiling by criminals would be greatly reduced, if not altogether removed. Furthermore, by meeting the demand at the highly inelastic and persistent ‘top end’ of the market, the price of horn would almost certainly drop, perhaps quite drastically, thereby reducing the profitability of the illegal market and concomitant incentives for poaching and illegal trade.
Third, by becoming active market participants, legal suppliers of rhino horn gain a new source of income, which they are able to re-invest in improved protection and breeding. Legal owners and custodians also have a significant competitive advantage over poachers and illegal suppliers: defendable legal rights and, in most cases, privileged physical access to and control of their stocks. If necessary, they can even dehorn their animals.”
You can read more, including why and how the re-education of people who desire rhino horn production hasn’t worked here...
http://www.rhino-economics.com/
An understanding of appropriate mechanisms for the sustainable use of not only rhino, but also elephants and crocodiles, seems to be generally in retreat. The world seems to be spinning away from practical wildlife conservation. Is it inevitable that social media will contribute to a rise in the banning of activities that could contribute to long-term sustainable management and conservation of wildlife, while inadvertently assisting the development of poaching and illegal trade?
***
Further reading ...
1. ‘The Rhino Poaching Crisis: A Market Analysis’ by Michael ‘t Sas-Rolfes can be downloaded at
http://www.rhino-economics.com/
2. For publications on sustainable use, but with an Australian focus visit
http://www.wmi.com.au/wmi-abst.html
The picture is from http://www.rhino-economics.com/the-illegal-rhino-horn-trade-is-driven-by-greed-and-evil-people/ . And republished here with Michael’s permission. Thank you.
Luke
"Mortality from dehorning is?"
It happens, I actually saw a doco that mentioned it but it had to do with the health of the individual animal not the dehorning. It reacted badly to the tranquilizer.
Since they mentioned this rare occurrence I'd say the % of death is so small as to never mind.
-----------------------------------------------
Ian Thomson
Europe and Japan, as you said, will never ever let themselves become totally dependent
on foreign food supplies. Simple as that, one had to live through the wars they did to understand that.
Oh sure, they pay lip service to "free" trade as long as it benefits them, same as the Americans.
Hi sd,
I know I am wobbling o/t, but I think that BK knows what most movers and shakers in Cantberra will not admit.
The EC countries are NEVER going to throw their rural producers to the wolves.
The Japanese are NEVER going to kill off their rice farmers, ( apparently the big problem is finding young ones).
The reason ? They have starved and they know the supermarket will not save them.
The motor industry in China and Malaysia is almost a branch of the Govt.
And today's breaking news is that the NZ Labour Party and the Greens are proposing to give the peoples electricity assets back to them . Big business is not amused, of course.
We in MRCC service area had the cheapest domestic power in Oz and Murrumbidgee CC had the cheapest industrial . The the pollies fixed it, they "denationalized" it.
It now costs $50 a month to run a small fluoro security light.
This is modern economic reality. Somebody needs to acknowledge the facts.
PS What the evidence does suggest, is that banning trade in rhino horns and elephant tusks is counter productive.
Luke, you make some valid points, but it is also clear from your comments that you have not read the article on which this post is based... ‘The Rhino Poaching Crisis: A Market Analysis’ by Michael ‘t Sas-Rolfes can be downloaded at
http://www.rhino-economics.com/
The idea of this blog post was to introduce the concept and provide a link to a detailed proposition.
I did live in Africa for 7 years and got some exposure to the issues there then, but it is true I'm not up to date and would like to see some verification of Michaels story.
I'm not against dehorning if it works. But you need to know this cycle of dehorning is needed repetitively - no evidence on at what levels will poachers kill. Mortality from dehorning is? Will poachers kill to make the price go even higher. Why bother tracking animals and getting close when you can just shoot them.
As usual wild assertions galore here and no serious evidence. If it were organic farming you'd be advocating people be educated and the wasteful process shut down. Why be selectively indulgent?
Well you're advocating Jen - is your capacity for editorialising slipping on this "evidence based blog". You should be briefing us on rhino population dynamics and ability for herd increase.
Don't just bluff.
The Rhino has evolved from the Paraceratherium; wouldn't it be great if a few of those could be genetically engineered. Viagra would be completely superseded.
Yes Ian, subsidies are a worry but even subsidised "free" market would be of value in the case where there is currently just the sounds of silence.
Which ever way rhinos were anaesthetised and their horns removed, powdered and sold, would lead to their better survival rates even if the authorities fully socialised the cost and privatised the profit.
Even if Luke revolted at the thought.
But I think you'll find Bob K's policies on ethanol, nationalising assets, motor vehicle manufacturing etc., are also riddled with the S word.
sd,
Free market is a sorry traitorous illusion, or why is a little bottle of flavoured milk from Belgium 95c in Deniliquin ? Heart of a dairy area. Not subsidised?
Why are tomatoes from Italy 90 ? Yeah right !
Why are SPC peaches TWICE the price in Shepparton, ( the place of manufacture)
of South African ones ? Come on, LOOK
All lies
But in advance of anything he says, Bob Katter is now " The Maverick " Cause he says it is wrong.
I just noticed that he is the only one who does care about this free trade lie
Jen, the free market IS the solution.
The rhino are similar to many struggling wildlife in the world today. They are being wiped out by feral pressure and there is no legal, commercial, economic pressure to assist them.
By legalising the sale of rhino horn it would become a small, harmless, niche market. I nearly said it might even shrink and shrivel to almost nothing but then I realised that is the problem it 's supposed to prevent.
Campbell Newman is aware of this problem in Qld and is introducing eco-tourism in NPs to put commercial value on wildlife.
Wild animals viewed in the wild have enormous commercial, economic value in this over-urbanised world.
It is the same principle.
People are doing PhD theses on this because the world is beginning to realise that this is how it works.