• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Dumping the Carbon Tax without Dumping Anything
Information Opinion

Dumping the Carbon Tax without Dumping Anything

By jennifer
July 16, 2013
Dumping the Carbon Tax without Dumping Anything

THE Coalition's attacks on the carbon tax have been more about broken promises than policy, allowing Kevin Rudd to 'dump the tax' without actually dumping anything, writes Chris Berg...

"WHEN Julia Gillard promised in 2010 that there would be no carbon tax under a government she led - but that her government would pursue an emissions trading scheme - she probably thought it would defuse a toxic debate and help secure victory.

Like so many of Labor's ploys in that election, it was far too clever by half. Tony Abbott dined off Gillard's no-tax promise for three years.

Now it's Kevin Rudd's time to dine. On Sunday we learned that he wants to transition from a fixed-price carbon tax to a full-blown floating-price emissions trading scheme one year ahead of schedule. Kevin Rudd laughs

Here's the riddle: why?

It seems strange to bring this up now. Over the last year or so, anger about the carbon tax has dissipated. Australians like the status quo. The GST swung elections back in its day. It destroyed leaders. John Hewson was one victim. The Howard government almost lost in 1998 because of its proposed great big new tax on everything. But now the GST is completely settled.

Furthermore, Rudd's fiddling with the carbon scheme isn't costless. It creates a $4 billion hole in next year's budget. It exposes the government to charges of policy disarray. The way it was announced (a bare leak to the Sunday papers) recalls one of the worst habits of Rudd's first outing as prime minister - the obsession with impressive sounding but light on detail 'announceables'.

But we forget how Gillard's 2010 bungle completely realigned the debate over Australian climate change mitigation policy. Three years later, her broken promise allows Labor to market Rudd's minor scheduling change as "dumping the carbon tax". Even better, they don't have to actually dump anything.

The distinction between 'tax' and 'trading scheme' has always been a triumph of semantics over clarity. An emissions trading scheme is a tax. It just happens to be a very complicated one. Just like a simple carbon tax, it prices an externality - pollution. The trick is that firms are allowed to trade their tax liabilities with each other. But that doesn't make it any less a tax.

(Here's the Oxford dictionary definition of 'tax' if you're sceptical: 'a compulsory contribution to state revenue ... added to the cost of some goods, services, and transactions'. Under a floating scheme, the added compulsory cost would be the European price of around $6 a tonne. The current fixed Australian price is about $25 a tonne.)

Gillard's broken carbon tax promise has ruled the debate over climate change policy in these last three years. Before the promise, Tony Abbott was calling Kevin Rudd's emissions trading scheme 'a great big new tax on everything'. Afterwards he targeted Julia Gillard's 'bad tax based on a lie'.

There is a subtle but important difference in these talking points. The focus on the lie eases political pressure off the policy itself.

Thanks to the Coalition's rhetorical realignment, it is the carbon tax that is remembered as Gillard's folly, not the entirety of the climate change program.

Long forgotten is the protracted and contentious debate about mechanisms and international agreements and subsidies and targets and the assumptions of Treasury modelling and the Garnaut Report.

We haven't heard much about all this in recent years. Australia's climate mitigation programs include everything from industry subsidies to renewable energy targets to efficiency regulations. Thanks to the broken promise, the whole debate was anthropomorphised. Climate policy was given human form by Julia Gillard and her tax.

Now Gillard is gone and it has all become a bit confused.

Kevin Rudd plans to recoup the $4 billion in lost revenue by cutting climate-related industry assistance, tightening tax concessions for salary-sacrificed cars, and imposing a further efficiency dividend on the public service.

Take the efficiency dividend with a grain of salt - it's the magic beans of public finance.

But cutting industry assistance is a great idea. Rudd should have taken the opportunity to go further. The Productivity Commission counted $5.1 billion in direct budget support for private industry in 2011-12. If you want to reduces expenditure, surely that's the first place to look.

Unfortunately, the Opposition is lumbered with an absurdly expensive, ludicrously inefficient and gimmicky hodgepodge of climate change policies clumped under the banner of Direct Action.

The Coalition's shadow climate minister, Greg Hunt, insists his plan is the true 'market solution' to climate change, but has not been able to convince anybody of that.

We shouldn't place too much faith in market mechanisms. Tony Abbott was mocked for his comments about invisibility yesterday but his basic point was right. An emissions trading scheme is not a real market. It is a highly regulated approximation of a market, where supply and demand are artificially created by the government to meet a political goal. (I detailed this argument in the Drum in 2011.) Of course, Abbott's attack on artificially created markets should apply double to his Direct Action program.

In retrospect, it seems obvious the Coalition's plan has been propped up by the unpopularity of Gillard's no carbon tax promise.

As has the whole climate change policy debate. Not for the better."

*****

This article, written by Chris Berg, was first published at The Drum and is republished here with permission. Chris Berg is a Research Fellow with the Institute of Public Affairs. His most recent book is In Defence of Freedom of Speech: from Ancient Greece to Andrew Bolt. Follow him on Twitter @chrisberg.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. I'm with John. Deal with real pollution but de-carbonise nothing. Of course, you might call me a de-carboniser in the sense that I believe in thrift. We should never waste a lump of coal by burning the stuff in aging plants any more than we should have a Commonwealth fleet of Ford Falcons made in 1970. Carbonise for fun and profit, but don't fritter our lovely coal. As I've said before, it's chocolate sunshine.

  2. John Sayers,

    Woops! My apologies to you and anyone else that actually clicked on the link to the Quadrant article. The correct link for the article: "No gain and lost of pain with the ETS" is:
    http://www.quadrant.org.au/blogs/doomed-planet/2013/07/no-gain-and-lots-of-pain-with-the-ets.

    This article I referred you adresses your question in the first sentence:
    Decarbonising the global economy requires an economically rational approach:
    http://judithcurry.com/2013/04/19/open-thread-weekend-14/#comment-313509

    I am suggesting a policy approach that should satisfy all rational people.

    If you want to argue no policies for GHG mitigation are needed or should even be debated, that might be your approach, but it is not mine. I view such an approach as futile. Those who take that approach are dismissed as politically naive. The indisputable fact is there is a head of steam in the developed countries where a significant proportion of electors "just want their government to fix the climate problem". That is a political reality. The political reality has to be dealt with.

    My suggestion is we should try to steer policies towards economically rational solutions. That is what the links I've provided advocate, IMO they offer a pragmatic solution.

    However, this is not something Australia can do much about. It is really up to the USA to lead the way. The US President could make it happen. There is no need for UN intervention and no need for any legally binding international agreements. No carbon pricing and no targets and timetables for emission reductions are needed. Decarbonisation of the global economy would just happen as a result of normal market forces if we removed the blocks that are preventing it from happening. It would happen much faster if the enviro NGO's lead the way and converted their supporters to become enthusiastic advocates instead of persistently intransigent sabateurs.

  3. Well Peter your first link to Quadrant gave me the Quadrant styles page, the other two were discussing methods of decarbonising. They all assume decarbonising is necessary.

    I asked a simple question - why do we need to decarbonise?

  4. John Sayers, can I urge you to please read the links I provided first, and then ask me questions. I can't write all the arguments again here in comments, and address all the possible questions. So, people really do need to read the links and get the background first. Then we can have a more constructive discussion.

  5. According to Treasury figures the ETS would cost about $1,35 trillion (undiscounted) or $400 billion (dicsounted) to 2050: https://climatelab.com.au/2012/06/what-the-carbon-tax-and-ets-will-really-cost-peter-lang/

    If there is no global carbon pricing scheme there will be no benefits for this expenditure. It is most unlikely there will be a global carbon carbon pricing scheme as renowned world expert on carbon pricing, Professor Richard Tol, explains here: http://www.voxeu.org/article/global-climate-talks-if-17th-you-don-t-succeed.

    Therefore, the $1.35 trillion ($400 billion discounted) is wasted money. It would be much better spent on the adaptation policies advocated by Bob Carter and supported by Jennifer Marohasy.

    To put the $400 billion in perspective it is about $13,000 for every man woman and child or about $26,000 per working person. That is what the ETS will cost us, according to Treasury figures, if it is not repealed.

  6. Why do we need to decarbonise our economy Peter?

    What's wrong with burning good old coal in modern supercritical coal fired power stations fitted with scrubbers that remove 99% of particulate matter, SO2 and emits only CO2?

  7. Carbon pricing, either carbon tax or ETS, will not survive. It will not survive in Australia or anywhere. It cannot succeed unless there is a global pricing system and that is highly unlikely. This explains why: http://www.quadrant.org.au/pages/style-guide

    Carbon pricing, despite being theoretically attractive, is the wrong solution. The solution that will succeed is technological, not carbon pricing. I explain how here:

    Decarbonising the global economy requires an economically rational approach:
    http://judithcurry.com/2013/04/19/open-thread-weekend-14/#comment-313509

    and here:

    Alternative to carbon pricing – Reduce existing market distortions
    http://judithcurry.com/2013/04/19/open-thread-weekend-14/#comment-313514

  8. cohenite, you seem to forget that Abbott f**ked Rudd the first time, he did the same to Julia, he'll do the same to Rudd in round two.
    Don't underestimate his wacky persona - he's no fool and acting desperately now could blow it. He's fully aware of the games from Rudd that's he's up against.

    Please, give the man some credit.

    Your suggestion

    "Abbott needs to say AGW is crap. And offer Salby the main job at csiro and Carter at BOM; Jo and Jennifer can run the science department at the abc."

    is just idiotic.

    No one knows who the hell Salby or Carter are!! let alone Jo and Jen. Nor do they care.

    I thought you were smarter than that!

  9. The other idiocy luke has been gloating about is da boats; Pickering has good advice:

    "The glib one-liners are wearing thin. The exaggerating, fabricating, terminating, excruciating, fornicating Rudd can be better attacked using plain logic. Abbott will never be known as a cool communicator but he is capable of a lot better than this.
    His TV ads so far are a waste of money and appear to be designed by an apolitical creative director desperately in need of direction.
    The quality of Abbott’s advice is approaching that of Gillard’s in that the likable side of their personalities has never surfaced.
    John McTernan killed Julia Gillard stone dead simply because he did not understand what Australians respond to. Even Bogans don’t respond to repetitious one-line platitudes.
    Gillard’s class and gender wars were atrocious but it was McTernan’s job to sell her and whatever she had in her suitcase. He predictably failed miserably.
    McTernan was born into those hideous British class divisions that still thrive there but were discarded here 50 years ago. Egalitarianism is our go and class differentiation of any kind is cause for ridicule.
    Kevin Rudd is the most able-to-be-attacked politician in years and, correctly advised, Tony Abbott should tear him limb from limb but there is no structure to his attack. He is stuck in response mode.
    Bruce Hawker, Rudd’s political strategist, is a wily old boy who already has Abbott on the back foot reacting negatively to puerile debate offers. That’s exactly what Hawker wanted; to paint Abbott as a chickenshit, negative wimp.
    Abbott must take the high ground, he is dealing with political experts who will do anything to divert the debate from Rudd’s Achilles heel... illegal boat arrivals.
    I suggested months ago that boats would be the over-riding election issue. The pre-Abbott rush to our shores is well underway but, as yet, Abbott hasn’t laid a glove on Rudd who stands naked and exposed with blood dripping from each of his fleshy female hands.
    Incredibly, Rudd has grasped the initiative with the claim that Indonesia is refusing to allow Abbott to defend our borders.
    What Abbott assumed would be the biggest shot in his locker, the Carbon Tax, has already been dishonestly, yet cleverly, blunted by Hawker.
    I mentioned last week that unfortunately it's the Bogans who will decide this election and Rudd knows where each of them lives. He has them on twitter and email and is able to make them feel important... and they are very important.
    Conservatives are not adept at handling Bogans but they better learn how to, and quickly. It’s not hard, they’re just people who normally vote Labor but this time they want the boats stopped and there lies a cavernous opening for Abbott... and he hasn’t seen it yet.
    His innocuous response to the latest drownings is to demand Rudd recall Parliament. Well, that ain’t going to happen. Rudd won’t risk being mauled by the Greens in a hung Parliament where Independents and a volatile backbench want his blood.
    Regardless, legislation is not needed to stop the boats and even if it was needed it wouldn’t pass the Senate anyway. What’s needed is a leader who will publicly challenge Indonesia’s disregard for our borders.
    Rudd knows he must clear the boats from his election platform. He will do anything to avoid risking a Gillard type annihilation. And he can do it while his Party's partners in crime, the Greens, are in recess.
    If Abbott blinks again and allows Rudd a forerunning role he will again find himself on the back foot.
    This time with boats... and that’s bloody unthinkable.
    At least 14 seats are there for the taking. Whoever has the balls to publicly confront Indonesia (and Indonesia will undoubtedly back down) will win those seats and Government.
    Now there’s an opportunity for a bright young lad to repair shattered Aussie pride lost to the broken borders policy of a culpable Rudd.
    So, Tony Abbott, where are you?"

    What a calamity for this country; on the one hand we have the labour and green parties who know no restraint or barriers but are devoid of purpose; on the other we have the coalition who at least recognise the problems but are constrained by, what, etiquette, good manners, lack of ticker, fear of the msm.

    In that respect I tend to agree with Jennifer; Abbott needs to say AGW is crap. And offer Salby the main job at csiro and Carter at BOM; Jo and Jennifer can run the science department at the abc.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *