• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Bushfires Rage Because Whitefellas Don’t Know How to Manage The Australian Landscape
Information

Bushfires Rage Because Whitefellas Don’t Know How to Manage The Australian Landscape

By jennifer
January 18, 2014
Bushfires Rage Because Whitefellas Don’t Know How to Manage The Australian Landscape

SO much of Australia is needlessly and brutally incinerated every summer. News reports focus on homes and lives and the brave fire crews. But, what about the native fauna and flora? It wasn’t always this way, and it shouldn't be so. As West Australian David Ward explains...

“BEFORE Europeans arrived, Noongar people managed our south-west dry forests and woodlands very well without fire trucks, water bombers, helicopters, television journalists, concerned politicians, the Conservation Council, hundreds of firefighters, or the Salvation Army to give them all breakfast. They did this by burning frequently, in most places as often as it would carry a mild, creeping fire.

Even where there were no Noongars, most of the bush would have burnt frequently by unimpeded lightning fires, trickling on for months. Such large lightning fires continued up to the 1920s, before there were any Bushfire Brigades. They could travel a hundred kilometres before autumn rain doused them. Most of the landscape would have burnt as often as it could carry a fire. Fire suppression and exclusion are unnatural, new fangled notions.

Frequent fire made the bush safe, and promoted grass for yonka (kangaroo), and a host of bush tucker plants. It produced byoo, the red fruit of the djiridji, or zamia. Frequent light smoke germinated seeds, and provoked flowering of kangaroo paws and balga grass trees.

Kangaroo paws and byoo are increasingly rare, under a muddle headed advocacy which claims that we should exclude fire from large bush areas for long periods. This phoney idea makes the bush very dangerous, as we have recently seen. Fire cannot be excluded indefinitely, and the longer it has been absent, the fiercer, and more damaging it will be.Zamia

Ecomythologists claim that, left alone, the litter will all rot down to enrich the soil. The truth, as any Perth Hills resident will testify, is that there is some decay in winter, but the summer blizzard of dead leaves, bark, and capsules is far greater, so litter builds up. After twenty years or so, there is a mulching effect, and build up ceases. However, by then most wildflowers are smothered and straggly, and most of the nutrient is locked up in dead matter. Frequent, mild fire releases the nutrients, sweetens the soil, and prunes the plants. Gardeners will appreciate that.

In the 1840s, the early West Australian botanist James Drummond wrote, “When I was a sojourner in England, I never remember to have seen Australian plants in a good state after the second or third years and that, I think, is in a great degree owing to their not being cut down close to the ground when they begin to get ragged; how for the pruning knife and a mixture of wood ashes in the soil would answer as a substitute to the triennial or quaternal burnings they undergo in their native land, I am unable to say, some of our plants never flower in perfection but the season after the ground is burned over…”

There are many historical references to frequent, widespread burning by south-west Noongars. In 1837 Lt. Henry Bunbury mentioned “…the periodical extensive bush fires which, by destroying every two to three years the dead leaves, plants, sticks, fallen timber etc. prevent most effectually the accumulation of any decayed vegetable deposit… being the last month of summer… the Natives have burnt with fire much of the country… ”

In 1975 Mr. Frank Thompson was interviewed about his memories of fire near the south coast, before the First World War. He said “You see, the Natives …they used to burn the country every three or four years… when it was burnt the grass grew and it was nice and fresh and the possums had something to live on and the kangaroos had something to live on and the wallabies and the tamars and boodie rat …It didn’t burn very fast because it was only grass and a few leaves here and there and it would burn ahead and… sometimes there'd be a little isolated patch of other stuff that wasn’t good enough to burn the time before, but as it burnt along perhaps there might be some wallabies or tamers. Those animals didn’t run away from fire, they’d run up to it and you’d see them hopping along the edge of the fire until they saw a place where the fire wasn’t burning very fierce...”

It is hard to imagine wallabies hopping along the flame front of the recent Karagullen fire, looking for a way through. Long fire exclusion is causing fires of unprecedented ferocity, and many avoidable wildlife deaths. The longer fire has been excluded, the longer the bush takes to recover when it is eventually, and inevitably, burnt.

Over the last decade, research in south-western Australia by the Department of Conservation & Land Management (CALM) and Curtin University into fire marks on hundreds of balga grasstrees has confirmed traditional two to four year fire in dry eucalypt areas. Ridges with pure jarrah burnt every three to four years, slopes with some marri every two to three years, and clay valleys with wandoo every two years. There would have been thousands of small refuges, in rocks or near creeks, which would have burnt less often, perhaps never. Recent fierce fires destroy these, and the fire sensitive plants they protect. The ecomythology of long fire exclusion over large areas, is destroying the very plants and animals it claims to care for. Equally guilty are those ‘talking heads’ in politics, and the news media, who unthinkingly promote ecomythology.

The oldest balga records go back to 1750, and show traditional frequent, mild fire until measles epidemics killed many Noongars in 1860, and 1883. In some places two to four year burning continued until the First World War. In others, it continued up to the 1930s, and even the 1950s. Some old Perth Hills families remember when any fire could be put out with wet bags or green branches. This is only possible when fires are in litter no more than four years old, with flames less than a metre high.

Far from destroying diversity, this frequent burning enhanced it, by creating a rich mosaic of different aged patches. Animals had both food and shelter, and wildflowers flourished. Today’s muddle headed blanket fire exclusion leads to an eventual single, blanket, fierce fire, which simplifies the ecosystem down to a single age.

By insisting, through our political representatives, that CALM burn the bush more often, and more patchily, we will make it safer, see more wildflowers, avoid most animal deaths, and avoid dense, choking smoke from fierce wildfires. We will have to live with occasional light smoke from prescribed burns. If most litter were less than five years old, smoke would be minimal, and arson would be futile. All it could cause would be a mild, creeping fire, which would benefit the bush.

Think of the savings and benefits by working with nature, instead of fighting it. No more squadrons of aircraft, anxious home owners, and choking smoke for a week or more. The police could get on with catching burglars. More young Noongar people should be employed by CALM to help manage the bush with fire, restoring their culture and healing their self esteem.”[1]

Since David Ward shared that article with us in April 2005, historian Bill Gammage has published his book ‘The Biggest Estate on Earth’ in which he explains in more detail how the South West of WA was managed intensively and systematically through fire-stick farming and that a similar philosophy once extended to the management of the entire Australian continent.

According to Mr Gammage the aboriginal religious philosophy of totems basically meant that all things were responsible for others of its totem and their habitat. So, emu people must care for emus and emu habitat, and emus must care for them. The entire continent was managed under the same aboriginal law for similar biodiversity purposes; hence the idea of Australia being essentially managed as one big estate.

Indeed for indigenous Australians wilderness offered no cause for fond nostalgia, it represented a tract of land without custodians.

****
1. Noongars Knew Best by David Ward was first published at https://climatelab.com.au/2005/06/noongars-knew-best/

The image is of a Zamia palm with ripe fruit.

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Hello Jaycee,
    I must admit I find your views a bit puzzling. If you are interested in bushfire education, you may care to Google (curtin+library+ward+wungong). Let's try to work together to find a solution to the bushfire problem, regardless of political orientation.

  2. It seems obvious to me that while I am trying to give the readers here information, certain parties seem only keen to disparage such. In their keeness to slight my humble attempts to educate, they trip-up and confuse and contradict even their own information.
    I would humbly suggest those of you who are too keen to find fault, get your "act" together before you write, as it is becoming somewhat difficult to follow your arguements!

  3. But Debbie..what Stewie and Mr. Ward hve written of is mainly second or third hand or even further back anecdotal evidence..ie..;someone said about someone saying...

  4. Jaycee, Jaycee, Jaycee...Pleeeeease. . .just go right ahead and say it (whatever IT is). . .no one expects you to NOT say what you think about current bushfire management.
    BTW. . .was your lifted quote from David Ward's article supposed to be an answer to my questions about who is advocating firestick management, slash and burn, stressing the environment or vacant woodlands?
    I notice that Ward advocates in that particular quoted section that we would:
    " avoid most animal deaths, and avoid dense, choking smoke from fierce wildfires."
    You appear to be conflating the difference between uncontrolled, fierce wildfires (which are indeed devastating) and controlled/ managed/prescribed burns that create: "a mild, creeping fire, which would benefit the bush. ”
    Cohenite has also pointed out that your reference to CC bringing about record breaking extreme weather events is not supported re the occurrence of Australian bushfires.
    And seriously?
    What do you think this is proving?
    "gamble with your grandchildren’s future just to satisfy your own theories?"
    Most of what David Ward and Stewie have commented on are not just 'theories'. . .they are examples of what has worked successfully in practice with suggested nuancing to cater for extra practical knowledge and understanding.

  5. JC

    '1939 was a long time ago'.

    Was it? You serious? As mentioned in previous posts, evolutionary ecology is a very important consideration in understanding the biology of modern natural settings, cycles, processes, etc.

    What was the systematic burning by Aboriginals you refer to? I think you mean intentional. Calling it systematic makes it sound like they controlled all their fires. Maybe at times they could and did but clearly they couldn't have alot of the time. If you think that is the case, then you are unaware of the volatility and ease in which fire spreads through many plant communities. Aboriginals were on foot not firetrucks and the landscape is just as rugged as today. The scrub can make it a real hassle to get through. Slows you down big time. They burnt it out the way. Do you think you could have stopped them doing this by citing your belief in AGW. They would have thrown you in. Some may have then eaten you.

    I am no expert on these matters but your ignorance is obviously breathtaking. Have you been out in the mountains much? Are you doing a TAFE course? Do you know alot of scientific names? I guess you read alot, surf the net.

    More fuel, more fire, more heat, more microbiology dead. Don't you get that? Gambling has nothing to with it. Gambling with wildfire will burn your butt.

  6. cohenite....: " Complete and utter garbage. "

    You wish!...trouble is coh'...you're as tad like old Admiral Nelson, looking through his blind eye and seeing nothing...You can Google all you like and live your life vicarioulsy through a PC. monitor...but I am seeing things "on the ground"...as I said a while ago...you're hoping, I'm seeing!
    Go in peace bro'.

  7. Stewie...1939 was along time ago...1980's were a fair while ago and while the indigenous people operated a sytematic "burn" in "the good ol' days"..they weren't to know what burning was doing to the microbiology and they operated on natural selection operatives and chance.
    I don't think we moderns have the depth of bushland, nor the breath of time to play such chancey games...are you a gambling man, Stewie?.....I mean : to gamble with your grandchildren's future just to satisfy your own theories?

  8. Some detail about the pygmy possum you mention.

    A friend of mine, now deceased, new Mt Hotham well (a population of possums are there). He was the road builder (parts of) and snow clearerer way back. A good bushman, loved the mountains, an expert prospector and an advocate for fuel reduction burning. He took the first skiers into Hotham and new your little possum well. In fact, he got a call from some uni student in the 1980's?, hearing about Fred's knowledge of the area and of the flora and fauna. Fred was more than happy to show her where the possums were and did. She returned to Melbourne, wrote a paper on the possums, which was the beginning of the management plans to protect this species. Fred never received any acknowledgement for his efforts. Is that stealing intellectual property?? Do you know her JC?

    So the possums are living in the basalt screes. These basalt screes got hammered in the 1939 fires. As a reminder, as you know all (ALL) the snow gums up there are multi-trunked. They have suckered after the 39 fires. Before the fires, as Fred explained, all the trees were big thick single trunk trees. Old, old trees. Fred explained the fire travelled from Noojee to Hotham in 2 hours. The possum population was seriously affected. There were other populations of possums in many of the basalt screes that lay scattered around Hotham and Feathertop and Dargo High Plains. Many of the screes are off the plateaus a bit, over the edge. They were obliterated in 39. The ones on top survived.

    Fires, or lack of them is one predominant problem (Maybe that's what you mean by 'destroyed food-chain'?). Numbers of Aboriginal tribes made annual excursions to Hotham to feast on the Bogong moths. They would have burnt as they went. And that plateau country would would have constricted them to similar routes chosen. They burnt regularily. That's why the snowgums were so big. Aboriginals virtually fire-proofed the high country up there. For some bizzare reason the dept. virtually excludes fire from the alps. Says its to fragile or unique or something. Maybe its the possum. That could be ironic.

    Fuel JC. It can make a fire very, very angry. I stood on top of the very summit of Hotham with Fred and 2 dept fire managers. You could see in some directions for hundreds of miles. I asked Fred what it looked like from here after 39 fires. He waved his arm across the horizon and said it was all gone and nearly all incinerated. He said nothing was left down there and it nearly had all crowned. Absolutely no greenery.

    Brushed tailed Rock Wallaby populations were also desimated, never to return. They live in steep country too, where this inferno raced up and baked them.

    Next predominant problem dogs, foxes and cats, and skiers. The first three not only eat them (probably think they're tasty), I would imagine they would seriously affect population despersal. You know what that countries like JC. They'd get picked off easy, don't you reckon.

    You been up there JC? You sound like you get around. Hows the fact that those plains up there, including Hotham sit on 600, 800 feet of basalt. They were once giant lava flows and now they're alps. Amazing.

  9. jc says:

    "Climate Change has already brought about extreme weather conditions measured by the number of extreme weather records broken in all parts of the globe. "

    Complete and utter garbage.

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *