THE Luddites, including Greenpeace, Scott Kinnear and Margaret Fulton, have campaigned relentlessly against the introduction of genetically modified canola. Their misleading propaganda successfully saw moratoriums introduced in many states. More recently Mr Kinnear has raised $750,000 to help Steve Marsh sue his neighbour, Michael Baxter, for planting GM canola.
In what is considered a landmark decision Justice Kenneth James Martin today ruled in favour of the GM canola grower, Michael Baxter.
The following reasons were given for the decision:
1. For private nuisance it had not been shown that there had been any unreasonable interference by Mr Baxter in the Marshes’ use and enjoyment of their property.
2. Mr Baxter was not to be held responsible as a broadacre farmer merely for growing a lawful GM crop and choosing to adopt a harvest methodology which was entirely orthodox in its implementation.
3. Nor could Mr Baxter be held responsible, in law, for the reactions to the incursion of Marshes’ organic certification body, NASAA, which in the circumstances presented to be an unjustifiable reaction to what occurred.
4. His Honour also rejected the Marshes’ cause of action in common law negligence. The Marshes’ action for exclusively a financial loss, was without precedent. No basis in legal principle was presented to the Court to extend the law to the events in this case.
5. Mr Baxter had not been shown to have acted negligently, either by growing or then by swathing the lawfully grown GM canola in 2010.
For more information on this story read The Land at http://www.theland.com.au/news/agriculture/cropping/general-news/baxter-wins-gm-case/2700017.aspx?storypage=1
For more information about coexistence and GMOs visit http://www.abca.com.au/coexistence/
What ever your opinion of "Roundup ready" is. Here is a challenge for you. Watch at least the first of these videos and see if your opinion changes.
Some claimed facts to notice. Canola yield improves with managed bee pollination or nurtured wild pollination. About 1 in three of the foods we eat require bee pollination. A there has been a worldwide increase in crops that require bee pollination. Over the winter of 12/13 U.S. bee keepers reported a 40 to 50 percent loss of hives. It appears to have been worse again this time around due to the harsh winters that adjusted data is hiding (warmist propaganda as usual is part of the problem not the solution, "making a difference"). Albert Einstein once prophetically remarked, “Mankind will not survive the honeybees’ disappearance for more than five years.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dY7iATJVCso
Why is 3 feet in distance a problem for bees?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3DEVnYrCIg
Who has the Roundup resistant bees?
http://www.pacc-news.com/5-2-12/heart_ingram5_2_12.html
Graham,
Monsanto is in fact feeding the planet.
Health is improving.
There are some licensing and ownership/patent issues that are questionable, but much less so than the pernicious dishonest accusations about GMO crops by GMO kooks.
Climate kooks, like GMO kooks, are anti-science fanatics that dress up their arguments with sciencey sounding words and phrases. Australia seems poised to be a leading nation in sweeping away anti-science kooks of all stripes. Congratulations!
Redress says:
"Simply stating that something is “unjustifiable” does not mean it is not legal.
I truly wish that were a sound defense under law, because then I could argue that any organisation [that I disagreed with], by enforcing of their rules, [try it with a bank] was reacting unjustifiably, and therefor I had not responsibility for, well, anything."
It is when a Judge says it. That is the difference; when you say it Redress it is just bush-lawyer talk.
@Graeme
Just a BTW
You keep saying you're not a warmist and not a greeny. Maybe, but you do a good imitation.
I learned a bit more about this case and apparently seed was blown over to the other property.
I could see a good case for complaint and compensation if the neighboring farmer was also growing the same crop but the organic variety.
Otherwise the problem lies in the unreasonable rules for organic registration.
As to producing the same or more using 'organic' methods?
Poppycock. One reason capitalism works is that if there is a demand for something someone will fill it.
If 'organic' methods worked the same way and produced just as much, Monsanto or any other company would waste their time and money uselessly, why would anybody pay for it?
Why do the CSIRO and other institutions constantly research to try to improve varieties?
We never used our own seed for next years crop, yes we kept some for emergency but always bought certified seed.
Graeme at 10:50
"As for crop production volumes, organic produces as much if not more crops when grown properly. This is not about being Green, this is just about volume and common sense."
No offence to you personally. . .but I think you are missing the point here and perhaps you don't understand the logistics of producing cereal and oilseed crops? ???
In broad acre agriculture, such as canola production, I think you will find that : 'organic techniques do (NOT!!!) produce as much if not more crops'.
If 'organic techniques did produce as much if not more crops' . . .then most Australian broad acre farmers would already be using those techniques.
If we're talking about our own little vege patches in our back yards, or specific organic market gardens on the urban fringes, then that is a different matter to the issue being discussed here.
Light side dark-side, Luddites and who would've expected Kay, Hargreaves,
and you're into The Industrial Revolution and one century on, the end of famine
in the western world and life expectancy statistics doubling and oh what might
Mozart have done had he lived in a later age instead of dying in his thirties.
beth - the -serf. Take a look at me Serf Under-ground journal Second Edishun. )
Graham, i agree with your fear about biodiversity and Monsanto dominance, it is a potential problem and one that should be monitored.
There are genuine problems with seed stocks in poor countries and the inability to store your own seed to grow again next season.
However it seems to me that the benefits outweigh the costs overall.
Good old Malthus felt we would hit a population peak because we would run out of land and hence food production (corn in those days) would be limited.
Like most modern greens he forgot about human ingenuity and innovation. GM is just another step in this direction.
Humans have been modifying plants and animals since we became the dominant species.
Very Little around us has not been influenced from the grasses that grow to the food we eat.
If you get a chance watch "animal pharm" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tYeu2fG87T4 { a link to part 1}( It was on the ABC a few years ago)it is a splendid look into the pro's and cons of humans playing with evolution. It seems very balanced. They start with a biologist ( pro change) and a food critic who is anti GM change etc and believes in the "old ways". By the end he is pretty much converted.
"Some of the environmental lobbyists of the Western nations are the salt of the earth, but many of them are elitists. They've never experienced the physical sensation of hunger. They do their lobbying from comfortable office suites in Washington or Brussels. If they lived just one month amid the misery of the developing world, as I have for fifty years, they'd be crying out for tractors and fertilizer and irrigation canals and be outraged that fashionable elitists back home were trying to deny them these things".
- Norman Borlaug
My mother, who is also wise, calls the current behaviour and emotional hullabaloo about organic farming. . . "orgasmic farming".
🙂 🙂
As well as being wise, my Mum has an excellent sense of humour.