HEADS need to start rolling at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology. The senior management have tried to cover-up serious tampering that has occurred with the temperatures at an experimental farm near Rutherglen in Victoria. Retired scientist Dr Bill Johnston used to run experiments there. He, and many others, can vouch for the fact that the weather station at Rutherglen, providing data to the Bureau of Meteorology since November 1912, has never been moved.
Senior management at the Bureau are claiming the weather station could have been moved in 1966 and/or 1974 and that this could be a justification for artificially dropping the temperatures by 1.8 degree Celsius back in 1913.
Surely its time for heads to roll!

The temperature record at Rutherglen has been corrupted by managers at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology.
Some background: Near Rutherglen, a small town in a wine-growing region of NE Victoria, temperatures have been measured at a research station since November 1912. There are no documented site moves. An automatic weather station was installed on 29th January 1998.
Temperatures measured at the weather station form part of the ACORN-SAT network, so the information from this station is checked for discontinuities before inclusion into the official record that is used to calculate temperature trends for Victoria, Australia, and also the United Nation's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
The unhomogenized/raw mean annual minimum temperature trend for Rutherglen for the 100-year period from January 1913 through to December 2013 shows a slight cooling trend of 0.35 degree C per 100 years. After homogenization there is a warming trend of 1.73 degree C per 100 years. This warming trend is essentially achieved by progressively dropping down the temperatures from 1973 back through to 1913. For the year of 1913 the difference between the raw temperature and the ACORN-SAT temperature is a massive 1.8 degree C.
There is absolutely no justification for doing this.
This cooling of past temperatures is a new trick* that the mainstream climate science community has endorsed over recent years to ensure next year is always hotter than last year - at least for Australia.
There is an extensive literature that provides reasons why homogenization is sometimes necessary, for example, to create continuous records when weather stations move locations within the same general area i.e. from a post office to an airport. But the way the method has been implemented at Rutherglen is not consistent with the original principle which is that changes should only be made to correct for non-climatic factors.
In the case of Rutherglen the Bureau has just let the algorithms keep jumping down the temperatures from 1973. To repeat the biggest change between the raw and the new values is in 1913 when the temperature has been jumped down a massive 1.8 degree C.
In doing this homogenization a warming trend is created when none previously existed.
The Bureau has tried to justify all of this to Graham Lloyd at The Australian newspaper by stating that there must have been a site move, its flagging the years 1966 and 1974. But the biggest adjustment was made in 1913! In fact as Bill Johnston explains in today’s newspaper, the site never has moved.
Surely someone should be sacked for this blatant corruption of what was a perfectly good temperature record.
----------
Climate records contradict Bureau of Meteorology by Graham Lloyd, 27th August
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/climate/climate-records-contradict-bureau-of-meteorology/story-e6frg6xf-1227037936046
The story is behind a paywall. But if you don't already have a subscription perhaps its time… this could just be the biggest story of the year.
** There are a lot of tricks that climate science managers have implemented over the years to fix the temperature record; that is fix it so it shows global warming. “Trick” was the word Phil Jones, a leading United Nation’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) scientist, used to explain to his peers that, when constructing very long global temperature series using proxy data based on tree ring measurements that can extend back thousands of years, it was best to substitute thermometer data for this proxy data from about 1960 because the proxy data started to show cooling from about then. Indeed from about 1960 until 2002 the thermometer data mostly did show warming. But now even this instrumental record is starting to show cooling. Enter the relatively new trick of homogenization.
[…] https://climatelab.com.au/2014/08/whos-going-to-be-sacked-for-making-up-global-warming-at-ruthergl… […]
There are several things going on here. According to the US methodology which is almost certainly what the Australian government is doing there are several aspects to this "adjustment" business.
1) when a station reports results inconsistent with that they think it should report it is cutoff and its data homogenized.
2) when a station is different than its peers it is cutoff and data homogenized.
3) if a station is reporting temperatures not at midnight in the past then it is told to start reporting midnight temps. Then all data in the past is "TOD" adjusted so the temperature was as if it had reported temps at midnight. This adjustment is frequently very large dominating the whole of the entire global warming for the century yet they make these adjustments as if they were 100% certain they were exact.
Also, Interestingly these adjustments 95% of the time result in an enhancement of the greenhouse response. Fully more than 50% of the entire US rise in temperatures are the result of adjustments. Without those adjustments the temperatures would have barely gone up last century across the US. They don't seem to have a problem with the idea their adjustments are of the same magnitude as the entire warming they are saying has occurred. If nothing else the error bars because of introducing these adjustments must be magnified tremendously.
Each of these techniques results in massive changes and disregarding of data. Before any systematic adjustment is made to a station they should verify that there is actually good cause for the adjustment. Somebody should go out and verify that these adjustments actually make sense since the entire amount of global warming in the last century is being adjusted in there should be solid proof that these adjustments are justified. Of course this is just my opinion.
I have a keen interest in the weather and have pondered for many years the information we have been 'fed', as most of the data is for such a small time in the history of the earth, which we know has warmed and cooled many times. If the 'powers that be' were genuine, surely they would not allow concrete jungle blocks of flats/units without any trees or shrubs to be built, or not jetting across the world to talk fests.
Thank you Jennifer for your dedication to try and expose the manipulation of these figures. I feel for the people that spent their time and dedication recording the figures for the BOM for many years for it to then be manipulated years down the track, unfortunately this will happen more nowadays as Government Departments do not want paper records anymore, so things will be open to more manipulation.
Moderator Ray August 29, 2014 at 2:39 pm #
"In Australia, nothing short of a Royal Commission is likely to get to the truth of how the homogenisation process has been stuffed up, and only after such an examination of the facts would prosecutors even consider if a crime has been committed."
In this respect, Australia must be very different from the USA. On my side of the Pacific Pond, 'blue ribbon' commissions are white-washes 90% of the time.
The goobermint investigates itself. Surprise, surprise! It finds that there is some room for improvement, but that there was no wrongdoing. (Example: the Warren Commission, in the wake of the JFK assassination.) That would be the foregone conclusion if the Rutherglen fiasco had happened in the USA, and were investigated by an American 'blue ribbon' commission.
[…] wants heads to roll [rolls eyes] because she claims that the Rutherglen site was never moved and so there was no need […]
This issue of temperature series goes right to the heart of what is wrong with the AGW theory, but lets not call it a FRAUD.
In Australia, nothing short of a Royal Commission is likely to get to the truth of how the homogenisation process has been stuffed up, and only after such an examination of the facts would prosecutors even consider if a crime has been committed.
It is entirely possible that the algorithms used to create the series from raw data were written by people who did not realise the effects generated when processing perfectly good data. Were the programmers also statisticians? - probably not. Did they do enough testing to eliminate errors in their logic? - obviously not. Did they simply copy the work of others who they assumed knew what they were doing? - most likely. Was their work vetted by suitably qualified statisticians? - I doubt it. Never forget we are talking about bureaucrats whose whole career is invested in this work, and they are unlikely to admit to be wrong.
So, we can vent our spleen as much as we like in private conversation, but when you come on this blog you are in a public space, and if you wish your comments to help sway public opinion, then you will avoid inflammatory statements and name-calling. This is not a parliamentary bear-pit where anything goes, it is a platform for discussion of important issues in the sphere of science and public policy.
Please think carefully about what you have typed before clicking on the big blue button!!
Glenn August 29, 2014 at 10:57 am #
Oh, just in case you're really interested, Jennifer did provide a list of her peer-reviwed scientific publications. This answers one of Mimi's questions, at least.
FWIW, I have an M.S. in Analytical Chemistry, and a publication in the top journal in my field. (No, the article is not about climate; it's about compression of tabular data.) Does that make me "anti-science?" BTW in my experience, people who use that expression are usually mindless trolls, who do not understand what real science is.
Your turn! What is your academic background? Let me guess. It's either Critical Theory or Underwater Basketweaving.
About your deficient reading comprehension skills . . . The key phrase in the title is, "making up global warming at Rutherglen." Do you have any idea what that means? If so, how do your fortune-cookie inputs contribute to our understanding of the topic at hand? Can you pass a Turing Test?
What we have here is an open-and-shut case of scientific f***d, which may or may not be actionable under Australian law. The official 'adjusted' results from the first 5 or 6 decades of the Rutherglen station are a classic dry-lab. The opinions of empty suit 'experts' are not relevant. It's a common sense matter, on which a jury of lay persons is competent to pass judgment. As Debbie has pointed out, we're not talking rocket science here.
Are your histrionics an indication that you'll be picking up your marbles, going home, and getting back on your meds? Sorry Bubba, we're way out of your league.
Glenn, I merely took the trouble to inform you that inviting skeptics to publish in alarmist flagships like Nature smacks of a GetUp-style stunt. The kind "suggester", initially polite and concerned, knows perfectly well that the skeptic he is "helping' is being guided to a certain dead-end with brick walls on all sides.
You'll note that I was merely alerting you to the existence of such GetUp-style stunts. At no point did I accuse you of being part of one of those stunts.
I was just making helpful suggestions, showing you a logical next step etc. I hope you don't think I was being coy because I thought you were being coy!
This has been an interesting experience to say the least.
I came here with what I thought were legitimate questions (which remain unanswered) and all I've received is accusations of being a mindless troll, being part of a Get-Up stunt, being short on rationality, a gatekeeper (apparently being skeptical and asking questions is now a sign of gate-keeping)! What was it that Orwell said, Ignorance is Strength, that would apply to a few commentators on here.
This behavior from the other posters is indicative of the kind of group think and conformity that I presumed this site was against (at least I assumed Jennifer was against it, obviously the other posters not so much).
Top if off with a whole slathering of unproven conspiracy insinuations about the peer review method and disdain for the scientific method (I wonder if the other posters are so against the scientific method when it comes to medicine or evolution?) and it has become fairly obvious that most posters are nothing more than trolls, using the old psychological projection trick to comfort themselves and divert attention onto other posters.
It is clear to me that this is an obvious case of experimenter bias. We saw it in medical studies for years which is why we have double blind studies now. The researchers CANNOT know who is in the study and who is being given a placebo. It is well known that if you want a result scientists will find a way consciously and even subconsciously to get the result they wish. A simple example of this is the constant errors made in simple transcription of temperatures in the record. A few years ago the entire country of Russia had its data from september copied into october. NOAA reported that world temperatures were highest ever breaking new records in October 2008. Nobody in the "scientific community" of accepted climate scientists seemed to notice the entire country of Russia had this incredible anomaly. They don't notice things when they are HOTTER than they expected. Nobody goes to look for any error if it is warmer. They only look when it is colder. Then they think hard, really hard and amazingly come up with "reasonable sounding" rationale for why things must be adjusted. Then they argue that since it would be difficult to adjust each "temperatures" they will come up with an algorithm to correct all the temperatures which makes someplace look 1.8C colder! when there is no possible way that could be. Everybody nods their head, doesn't question the results. They won't even look into their data to see these problems because possibly subconsciously they know that the result will be a problem. That is the generous way to say it. One could imagine some purposely do this but to see the reason for this bias doesn't require that the scientists be evil. It's simply a matter that they don't look into things that confirm what they think. When a common unaffiliated person looks at the data and sees that Russia was amazingly the same exact temperate in October as September and sends a note they then embarrassedly fix it and pull the story that October was the hottest ever. Russia is such a big country and the error so egregious that it moved the entire world temperature down significantly. They didn't see it. They didn't see that Russia was inexplicably 10 degrees warmer than it should have been in october. How amazing is that? It proves experimenter bias is rampant. There have been dozens of cases like this but they never look at themselves and say: "I wonder if we are biased?" Instead they see all kinds of reasons to lower high temperatures in the past and explain why they need to do that but they never find a reason to raise temperatures in the past because they never look for any such reason. This is how experimenter bias allows scientists to frequently come up with data, answers that look exactly like they expected. It happens in every scientific discipline. It's the reason double-blind studies are done. The problem is that if the entire community of "allowed" peers to review something are all aligned in a belief then there is not much peer review at least on things that might question the unified belief system. The russian incident should have been enough to alert scientists they had a problem. This should similarly alert real scientists that there is a systematic bias in their thinking process which could be corrupting their theories and the data.