THE Australian Bureau of Meteorology issued a media release last night (19thFebruary) with the headline “Tropical Cyclone Marcia to reach Category 5 system at landfall”. This morning there was extensive media reporting of Marcia having reached landfall as a Category 5.
But where is the evidence? And who is asking for it? Like the Bureau, the Australian media seem intent on hyping the event, rather than providing any critical or dispassionate assessment.
The first technical bulletin for Marcia, issued at 4pm today states that, “surface observations have not captured the highest winds,” and acknowledges that the minimum pressure so far recorded has been 975 hPa inside the eye wall at 1.30 pm at Rockhampton.
In fact, this central pressure only qualifies Marcia as a Category 2. As one would expect of a category 2, both Rockhampton and Yeppoon have sustained relatively minor house damage and significant damage to trees.
Just before the cyclone made landfall it passed over Middle Percy Island, to the north of Rockhampton, and the lowest central pressure recorded for the system then was 971.6 hPa at 3.39 am this morning. A wind gust of 208 km/hr was recorded at 4.30 am, which suggests Marcia was almost a Category 3 at this time, even though its central pressure was never recorded as below 970 hPa. The central pressure of a cyclone needs to be somewhere in the 970 to 955 hPa range to be a Category 3.
This would suggest that even as Marcia approached the Queensland coastline it was never more than a Category 2.
Indeed the raw observational data available at the Bureau’s website would suggest that Cyclone Marcia made landfall just south of Middle Percy Island as a Category 2 approaching a Category 3, but had already weakened to a very ordinary Category 2 approaching Category 1 by the time it reached the city of Rockhampton.
This evidence, however, contradicts the track map at the Bureau’s website, and also the extensive media suggesting that Cyclone Marcia made landfall as a Category 5, and was still a Category 3 system when it reached Rockhampton.
The Australian Bureau of Meteorology has been hyping the possibility of a devastating cyclone hitting the Queensland coastline all year. It forecast that Marcia would hit as a Category 5 cyclone, but where is the evidence?
*******
Thanks to everyone who has emailed me today with best wishes, assuming I was in Yeppoon when Marcia hit. Our house there is still standing, with some trees down in the front yard. I was in Brisbane last night, and am now in Noosa.
Elleen , You need to understand it really doens't take a lot of wind to knock a lot of trees over. we now this because of the wind speeds recorded around Yeppoon, and yes Yeppoon sat through 4 hours of it as well, so don't Byfield were the only ones.
Now what it missing from all this is Samuel HIll observations, all of 15-20km north of Byfield they were recorded, they have now been removed, oh where could they have gone and why? And with these then people could make a better balanced judgement other than calling people drongos.
Just remember this and if you have lived at Byfield for quite some time then you will relaize it doesn't take a lot of wind to flatten pine trees (actually less than gum trees) which has occured several times in recent memory. The main issue with Byfield is there are a lot more trees and these days there are many more people living within this tree environment than 30-40 years ago so please no more about Byfield having coped something different, it has happened before you know.
So did anybody get a copy of the Sam hill obs when they were still available, they might just throw a whole new light on the thinking?
What is it about this simple statement from NASA JPL that you don't understand, John?
“Tropical cyclones (the generic term for hurricanes and typhoons), however, are difficult to measure. To relate the radar energy return to actual wind speed, scientists compare measurements taken from buoys and other ground stations to data the satellite acquired at the same time and place. Because the high wind speeds generated by cyclones are rare, scientists do not have corresponding ground information to know how to translate data from the satellite for wind speeds above 50 knots (about 93 km/hr or 58 mph). Also, the unusually heavy rain found in a cyclone distorts the microwave pulses in a number of ways, making a conversion to accurate wind speed difficult."
It plainly over-rides any claimed ability to estimate and speculate on wind speeds whatever method is used.
Now, if you have any concrete evidence that Marcia was a Cat 5 [like photographs of coastlines stripped bare] please produce them or apologise and admit you don't know what you are talking about.
spangled drongo -- "John, in spite of your childish, gratuitous insults, I was trying to be polite and spare you obvious embarrassment"
Then what do you call your your earlier comment "To think you can calibrate wind speeds from pictures of clouds is delusion. But then you’re probably no stranger to that slight problem."? Maybe you should practise what you preach. Look in your own backyard before you launch on others.
"Now, go back and read it several more times and then come back and tell us what you still don’t understand." -- how about YOU stop being such a condescending twat and read back on all the points I have made, the vast majorify of which you still haven't addressed. I said the remotely sensed satellite data is compared to conventional observations. Such data has high uncertainty with cyclones on average but that is on average. Some cyclones whose winds are able to be compared to conventional observations at the time have lower uncertainties if the satellite detected closely match those of conventional observations. Other cyclones over remote oceans where conventional observations are sparse or lacking have much higher uncertainties. Of course context like this is totally lost on a simpleton like you.
You never addressed the corrections I made to all your misconceptions from earlier on so maybe it's YOU who needs to go back and re-read what I said several times then come back and tell us what you don't understand. Hypocrite. How many more misconceptions do you want to raise before you become less narrow minded?
John, in spite of your childish, gratuitous insults, I was trying to be polite and spare you obvious embarrassment when I produced NASA JPL's own assessment of satellites' inability to measure cyclonic wind speed above 50 knots with any accuracy.
Not only were you not able to discover that for yourself and save yourself that embarrassment, but also after I produce it for you, you apparently can't even understand what it says.
Now, go back and read it several more times and then come back and tell us what you still don't understand.
Here is the comparison between the intensity scale used in Australia and the one that is used in the Atlantic and eastern Pacific which is also the one that JTWC uses which I mentioned in my last comment.
http://www.bom.gov.au/cyclone/images/faq/category-comparison.png
spangled drongo, you're not the sharpest tool in the shed are you. "To think you can calibrate wind speeds from pictures of clouds is delusion." -- you don't calibrate wind speeds just by glancing at a satellite photo and saying "she looks around a cat 5". A number of techniques are used, ONE of which is the Dvorak technique which involves analysing various signatures of cyclones such as cloud top temperatures in infrared satellite imagery and other structures which have a known correlation with observed intensities from past cyclones.
This really illustrates just how infuriatingly dumb people like you are and how totally oblivious you are to how complex and technical analysing cyclones is in real life. And whenever it comes to anything technical or complex I can bet a million dollars that there will always be ignorant people like you who make wrong assumptions based on your ridiculously simplistic view of the way things work in the real world. This event is no exception.
Matt -- "JTWC had it at 3 so someone did get it wrong." -- Wrong. The JTWC had it as a Cat 4, NOT cat 3. Even more importantly they use the Saffir-Simpson scale used for hurricanes in the eastern Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. It uses 1-minute wind speeds, not 10-minute wind speeds used to rate Australian cyclones. This means the corresponding wind speeds needed to reach each category is higher compared to our scale. In other words many cyclones in our region will have a lower rating on their scale. For a low end cat 5 cyclone in our area this corresponds to a cat 4 on their scale.
"BOM ignored everything except their model." -- Wrong. Computer models were NOT used to rate it. This was especially the case with Marcia because they underestimated the intensity of Marcia rather than the other way around. So no BOM didn't "ignore everything except their model".
And yes really Bob in Castlemiane. It's so amazingly predictable to the extreme that people like you would paste a notorious sceptic website link such as that one while conveniently ignoring and/or attacking anything that happens to not fit in with your your anti global warming agenda and mantra.
One thing is almost certain though. There will be more posts after this one containing (a) some sort of conspiracy theme (b) more misconceptions based on incorrect info and (c) more attacking of anyone who happens to actually agree with the BOM or anything remotely scientific. And you can be assured of that.
All debate and views aside maybe some people should read what others have written who were actually on the ground in the area (for example Ellen's post above) before shooting their "mouth" off again.
Thank you Ellen! Good to hear from someone who has actually witnessed the devastation.
The people of CQ aren't claiming the cyclone was a cat 5 as part of a conspiracy to prove the existence of global warming. We know it was more than a cat 2 or 3 because we have actually witnessed the damage it caused. The people of Byfield especially, will not be complacent in future cyclones- even those that may be measured as a cat 1. The devastation that Marcia caused in this area will not be forgotten anytime soon. I'm sure these people will take all future cyclones seriously no matter what the category. So those who think they are saving the world by downplaying Cyclone Marcia and obsessing over conspiracy theories are really wasting their time.
The media did get a few of the measurements wrong. For example I read in one Brisbane newspaper that Yeppoon had wind gusts of over 300kph- which wasn't true. The media, particularly the CQ local media, played a major role in keeping everyone indoors and safe. I am not aware that there were any deaths attributed to the Cyclone. We can partly thank the media for that.
I invite all the doubters to visit Byfield/ Shoalwater area it see the damage. Talk to the locals who sat through this cyclone for 4 intense hours, speak to the local heroes who pushes through tree covered roads to make it to their mates. I have spoken to army personal who attended both clean ups at cyclone larry and yasi, and they all say the devastation here is worse. What saved the houses in Byfield is the trees, all our house used to be tucked into beautiful tree filled blocks, which are no more. You can all sit in your offices and speculate all you want, but I have seen it with my own eyes. It may not of been a cat 5 but it was much much stronger than a cat 2 you drongos!
The "Dunning–Kruger effect" - really John. Sounds like something one might find in the Lew Papers?
"These papers [the Lewandowsky papers] warn of cognitive bias effects, all of which occur in the CAGW Consensus, confirming it is heavily biased. Can’t admit this? Skeptics exposing the dilemma? So… push skeptics beyond the pale, minimizing cognitive dissonance."
http://wattsupwiththat.com/2014/11/09/wrapped-in-lew-papers-the-psychology-of-climate-psychologization-part3/
Some idea of the limits of satellite measurement of cyclonic winds above 50 knots from NASA JPL:
"Tropical cyclones (the generic term for hurricanes and typhoons), however, are difficult to measure. To relate the radar energy return to actual wind speed, scientists compare measurements taken from buoys and other ground stations to data the satellite acquired at the same time and place. Because the high wind speeds generated by cyclones are rare, scientists do not have corresponding ground information to know how to translate data from the satellite for wind speeds above 50 knots (about 93 km/hr or 58 mph). Also, the unusually heavy rain found in a cyclone distorts the microwave pulses in a number of ways, making a conversion to accurate wind speed difficult. Instead, the scatterometer provides a nice picture of the relative wind speeds within the storm and shows wind direction."