It is not disputed that Blair Trewin under the supervision of David Jones (both working at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology) remodel all the historical temperature data generating trends and statistics that look quite different from the actual measurements.
The remodelled series are then passed on to university and CSIRO climate scientists who base much of their climate research on these ‘second-hand’ statistics.
So, when Michael Mann and David Karoly tell you it’s getting hotter and hotter, this is their interpretation of Blair Trewin’s statistics, not their interpretation of the actual data.
When I say there needs to be more scrutiny of what Blair does to the actual measurements, I’m simply making a request.
As Andrew Bolt explains in his column yesterday harshly entitled ‘On the deceit of Paul Barry’:
Marohasy does not say the Bureau is “part of a huge conspiracy”. What she does say is undeniably true: the Bureau has repeatedly adjusted its data, with the result that the past looks cooler and therefore the warming greater.
The only dispute is over whether the Bureau has done this correctly, to make the data more accurate. It says yes, Marohasy says no.
What evidence does Barry offer that she’s wrong? None. No interest. All he has is mockery and an appeal to his mob.
Thanks Andrew, for explaining the situation so succinctly.
It is the case that none of the adjusting is denied by Blair at the Bureau.
To help Paul Barry and others explore what Blair has actually done, my colleague Jaco Vlok has created a table with an interactive drop-down menu for each of the 112 weather stations with remodelled data.
The adjusting is laid-out, and explained here:
https://climatelab.com.au/acorn-sat-v1-vs-v2/
Go and have a play!
For example, if you click on the link, and scroll down (the 112 stations are listed alphabetically) all the way to Wagga, and then across to TMax you will find a chart that shows the raw data, and then the Blair Trewin reconstructions for this weather station that is used to calculate national averages and global warming.

One of the charts from the drop-down table created for Paul Barry by my friend and colleague Jaco Vlok.
First Blair created ACORN V1, that was back in 2011.
ACORN V2 is the data reworked to further increase the rate of warming.
Thanks Jaco. Thanks Andrew.
Now, Paul ... go and have a look, and play. It is not a conspiracy, nor is it rocket science. But understanding can take time, especially when it is not what you might expect Bureau employees to be doing to the historical temperature data.
****
The feature image shows Jaco Vlok (far left) backing me up in a dispute about the value of remodelling historical temperature data.
John Brookes, your credulity and world-class rationalizations are much more impressive.
It is not at all clear why wholesale downward adjustments of past temperature records are undertaken.
And the rationalizations you offer are at best circular and post hoc.
Jeff Ollerton,
I have a comment about the Tamino defence of BoM temps fiddling (more a basic question really) -
how come the instrumental records by thermometers prior to 1910 in Australia (and 1950 in Canada) are not regarded as reliable enough by "the authorities" to determine the state of climate(s) in those relatively recent times, but the tree-ring proxy temps that formed the basis of the MBH "hockey stick" are held as gospel for the state of climate(s) back in the days of yore?
Hi Jen, thank you for taking the time to generate this invaluable site, Ihave been an avid reader and have passed on your articles to countless numbers of friends and colleagues, who have now become your readers as well. I would request, as has Bill Hankin, that a simplified explanation of the data sets be given, as Bill states - "This post is not simple & direct..It is complex for 112 BOM stations, and even I had trouble following what you were explaining what you were stating and asking me to do." - I do hope you will take time to somehow get the info to me in a more 'readable' form. Yours Tony
I am surprised by the loyalty of your followers.
Dr. Jennifer: You are commended for your commitment and effort in reconstructing temperatures more accurately so as to reflect a trend which if I understand correctly shows that Australia is not experiencing exothermic conditions but rather the antithesis?
As a novice Climate Researcher what puzzles me the most are the inferences by so many from within and from outside the "science" community that the planet is experiencing AGW. How can this be categorically deemed to be science when (and again my understanding) that science requires "scientific method" under extreme laboratory accuracy to prove an observed hypothesis. Where and when were such laboratory experiments conducted to determine the earths climate over the past few centuries?
Haphazard world-wide temperature and precipitation readings with casual repeatibility might only show trends and didn't Dr. Raymond Wheeler do this over a century ago?
Right now, I am reading all the "climate gate" documents as well as the testimony given by Dr. Michael Mann to the House Science Committee in the US Congress!
In summary, even if I wanted to believe AGW, it would be extremely difficult given the dubious information delivered by the East Anglia CRU (who coalesced with Mann to deny appropriate scientific "peer review") to the IPCC.
Your comments are appreciated.
Thank you
Perhaps you'd care to comment on this? If you have the courage to allow it through moderation that is:
https://tamino.wordpress.com/2020/02/12/cult-of-stupidity-naming-names/
We are watching how history is twisted into Holy Scripture to serve the goal of putting those who did the twisting into power. Fight on.
Don't try to merge data in a non professional way. Separate stations are separate stations..
If we look at the Wagga Wagga AMO station alone, it is obvious that raw untampered data has the highest trend from 1942 til now (adjustments are warming the past).
Hence, I believe that Big Coal has infiltrated BoM, and deceivingly tries to downplay the consequences of global Warming..
The sites get moved I have looked into Alice Springs (use to live there) one site which goes back to 1878 to 1953 was moved at least once during this period from the telegraph station to the post office in town. Then relocated to the airport but at least they have over lap in the data but not from the initial relocation.
There is also the issue of using electronic thermometers vs mercury thermometers the electronic ones have almost no thermal inertia where as the mercury have quite a lot. What this would mean is the electronic ones will show a higher temp spike depending on how much time they allow for averaging in there recording. I don't think the long term temp data is good enough to tell whether there is a warming trend or not.
Thank you so much for your efforts.
This is in response to Frank Mulcahy and his interest in Tasmania's Cape Bruny, as I looked at the site's data about a year ago.
Blair Trewin writes in the ACORN 2 technical report re the influence of AWS response times …
"Figure 8 shows two examples of this. Alice Springs is the most extreme example; the November 2011 probe replacement there resulted in an increase in mean one-minute temperature fluctuations of approximately 0.16 °C at 1500 and 0.03 °C at 0600. Assuming that the increased variation is distributed symmetrically about the one-minute mean and that the change of probe did not introduce any inhomogeneities into the one-minute mean, this equates to an upward shift of about 0.08 °C for maximum temperature and a downward shift of 0.01-0.02 °C in minimum temperature. In less arid climates the effect is smaller (e.g., for Sydney, around +0.03 °C for maxima and –0.01 °C for minima)."
ACORN catalogue re Cape Bruny : "The site appears to have been close to its current location before a move in April 1939. It also moved on 13 November 1961, and 45 m east in March 1969. An automatic weather station (094198) has been operating since 1997 at Cape Bruny. This is expected eventually to supersede the current site. It is about 50 m west of the current site, close to the 1961–1969 location of the manual site, but is in a more exposed location on top of the ridge. This exposure has clearly reduced rainfall readings but impacts on temperature are less clear."
i.e. Cape Bruny provides a fairly unique comparison of AWS vs manual Stevenson screens just 50 metres apart over 20 years of observation.
94010 1998-2017 average max 15.57C
94198 AWS 1998-2017 (50 metres west) average max 16.02C
94010 1998-2017 average min 9.47C
94198 AWS 1998-2017 (50 metres west) average min 9.28C
94010 has an elevation of 55 metres and 94198 has an elevation of 60 metres, so there’s a five metre upward slope west of 94010 over 50 metres. With the sun setting to the west, the higher slope should only start to cast shadow on the lower screen very late in the afternoon, a few hours after the daily maximum has been recorded.
94010 has had an average rainfall of 879.0mm since 1998 and 94198 has had an average annual rainfall of 763.5mm since 1998.
Trewin explains the marked difference in rainfall just 50 metres apart (http://media.bom.gov.au/social/blog/1047/to-bourke-and-beyond-one-scientists-epic-journey-to-112-weather-stations/)…
"One example is at Cape Bruny in Tasmania, where we have two sites 50 m apart, one on the top of a hill and one just off to the side in a more sheltered location. Visiting there on a windy, showery, day made me appreciate how much more exposed the hilltop site is, and it turns out the hilltop site measures 17 per cent less rain than the more sheltered one, because some of the rain blows over the top of the gauge."
The 94198 AWS averages 0.45C warmer max per annum.
94010 is cooler than the AWS each month by …
Jan -0.8C
Feb -0.7C
Mar -0.6C
Apr -0.5C
May -0.1C
Jun -0.1C
July -0.2C
Aug -0.3C
Sep -0.4C
Oct -0.5C
Nov -0.7C
Dec -0.5C
Either the AWS response time is more of an influence during warmer weather, as effectively acknowledged by the bureau, or something else about the stations' environment is reducing the difference as the months get cooler (and the days get shorter).
Note from the ACORN catalogue re the position of 94198 … it is about 50 m west of the current site, close to the 1961–1969 location of the manual site …
In the eight available annual observations during 1961-1969, the Cape Bruny 94010 manual site average maximum was 14.88C. When shifted east to its current site, the eight years of 1970-1977 had an annual average maximum of 15.30C (even though average annual rainfall was 950.6mm in 1961-69 and 1,098.2mm in 1970-77).
So the manual screen was 0.42C cooler when in the western location where the current AWS is now recording 0.45C warmer.
The higher 94198 location should also be more exposed to cooler westerly, easterly and southerly winds off the ocean - powerful enough to blow 17% of rainfall over the gauges, according to Trewin. This suggests the 94198 AWS location isn’t a warmer environment and the warmer readings are more likely to be due to instrumental influences. (However, there may be some temp rounding influence as x.0F/C rounding averaged 84.13% in 1961-69 and 46.60% in 1970-77.)
Also and oddly, the 94198 annual mean 3pm wind speed is 25.7kmh and the 94010 annual mean 3pm wind speed is 27.8kmh - meaning the manual site has slightly stronger afternoon winds than does the AWS on a higher elevation. Most Cape Bruny winds are westerlies and southerlies (http://www.bom.gov.au/clim_data/cdio/tables/pdf/windrose/IDCJCM0021.094010.3pm.pdf).
Cape Bruny is the most southerly of all ACORN stations and, as a result, one of the coldest near sea level. The rainfall shows it’s not arid. 94010 is surrounded by grass and 94198 by what looks like low scrub (heath to 0.5m, as described above), but presumably well exposed to avoid vegetation shade.
Maximum temperatures are normally recorded mid afternoon when shading isn’t an issue. Stevensons are not supposed to be located on watered grass but it’s unlikely the grass changes colour due to seasonal drying as there is very little difference in Cape Bruny’s rainfall between the 12 months, and all months are rainy enough to maintain the green (driest Feb with average 56.12mm, wettest July with average 95.1mm, meaning in the driest month the location still gets an average 2mm of rainfall every day. This should also maintain the greenery and albedo of the surrounding heath and 3m shrubs just east of the AWS.)
Trewin’s A2 report explanation of AWS response times reads like an effort to minimise this artificial warming by confining it only to a small number of hot, arid locations and thus not sufficiently influential to adjust the national dataset.
Plenty of individual stations show sharp maximum temperature increases post AWS installation with some levelling thereafter, and the rapid warming consistently looks more pronounced than Trewin’s insignificant description.
Ken Stewart considers Cape Bruny non-compliant with site standards ...https://kenskingdom.wordpress.com/2019/12/05/the-wacky-world-of-weather-stations-no-283-cape-bruny-tas/
Cape Bruny poses questions not only about the AWS response time warming at the site itself but the response warming at all Australian sites, hot, cold, arid or wet, and is an example that can be used to highlight the AWS influence.