• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Concerned About Prof Peter Ridd
News

Concerned About Prof Peter Ridd

By jennifer
August 25, 2017
Concerned About Prof Peter Ridd

I have been chatting off-and-on with Peter Ridd, now Professor of Physics at James Cook University, for nearly two decades. We both resent the lack of honesty in the reporting of many environmental issues.

Peter Ridd, Professor of Physics, James Cook University, Townsville

Earlier this week, Prof Ridd was concerned that his recent comments to Sid Maher at The Australian newspaper [1], and then his appearance on Sky News TV with Alan Jones and Peta Credlin [2], had not been received at all well by the University.

In particular, he has written and said:

“Policy science concerning the Great Barrier Reef is almost never checked. Over the next few years, Australian governments will spend more than a billion dollars on the Great Barrier Reef; the costs to industry could far exceed this. Yet the keystone research papers have not been subject to proper scrutiny. Instead there is a total reliance on the demonstrably inadequate peer-review process.”[3]

There is a website Retraction Watch [4], reporting on both the circumstances of papers being retracted, and more widely on the issue of fraud in science. It shows that there is a widespread problem: that Prof Ridd is correct to be concerned about what he often refers to as the general lack of ‘quality control’.

Rather than James Cook University sacking Peter Ridd for having the courage to speak out, it would be good if they would get behind him, and his calls for urgent reform.

*****

1. Maher, S. 2017. ‘No proper scrutiny’ of $1bn reef rescue funding', http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/climate/no-proper-scrutiny-of-1bn-reef-rescue-funding/news-story/3a317e01f01c2ec61b102718be2feff1

2. Jones & Co. 2017. Sky News TV, https://twitter.com/SkyNewsAust/status/892337964851712000

3. Ridd, P. 2017. The Extraordinary Resilience of Great Barrier Reef Corals, and Problems with Policy Science. In Climate Change: The Facts, Institute of Public Affairs, Melbourne, Editor J. Marohasy, Pages 282-296.

4. Retraction Watch, http://retractionwatch.com/

Good Causes

Comments

  1. Craig us upset that someone questioning the consensus actually got to speak publicly, in the same manner as consensus promoters.
    Even while he is still suffering from the effects of his own petard.
    He seems quite unwilling to consider information that does not fit his consensus echo chamber...

  2. Dear Craig,

    You can look this up very easily in Web of Science or Scopus.

    Also, while you are there, check out Tim Flannery's scientific publications.

    Kind regards,
    Neville

  3. So which of those publications specifically supports Ridd's recent statements to the tabloid media?

  4. Oddly, Peter Ridd's "expert advice" on the GBR appear only in the mass media, and his opinions remain therefore immune from ever having to appear on Retraction Watch.

    If Ridd has something to add tot he published science on this topic, why is he not doing so?

    ***** Craig Thomas, you are in error.

    Ridd has a long publication record: more than 100 papers in international science journals.

    On the specific topics on which he has been making public comment recently, you may like to read him in:
    Ecological Applications (volume 22), Marine Pollution Bulletin (volume 65), Marine Geology (volume 346) and Energy & Environment (volume 18).

  5. One method of contacting JCU is via their website "Feedback" section.
    Whether that has any effect or not remains to be seen.

  6. We should all be very concerned that our tertiary institutions have been hijacked by the far left.
    Thanks very much Gough Whitlam - for nothing.

Write a Comment