THE hubris of the Australian Bureau of Meteorology is on full display with its most recent remodelling of the historic temperature record for Darwin. The Bureau has further dramatically increased the rate of global warming at Darwin by further artificially lowering historic temperatures.
This begins by shortening the historical temperature record so that it begins just after the very hot years of the Federation drought. Then by changing the daily values: that is changing the observed measured temperatures to something else.
For example, on 1st January 1910 the maximum temperature recorded at the Darwin post office was 34.2 degrees Celsius.
A few years ago, the Bureau changed this to 33.8 degrees Celsius, cooling the recorded temperature by 0.4 degrees. In its most recent re-revision of Darwin’s climate history the temperature on this day has been further reduced, and is now just 32.8.

The daily maximum temperatures for early 1910 as shown in the three different datasets for Darwin
Environmental reporter for the Australian newspaper, Graham Lloyd, asked the Bureau why it had made such changes earlier in the week. A spokesperson is quoted in The Weekend Australian as follows:
“For the case of Darwin, a downward adjustment to older records is applied to account for differences between the older sites and the current site, and difference¬s between older thermometers and the current automated sensor.
“In other words, the adjustments estimate what historical temperatures would look like if they were recorded with today’s equipment at the current site.”
Yet this is a version of exactly the same reason given by the Bureau just six years ago for reducing the temperature on 1 January 1910 by ‘only’ 0.4 degrees.
Neither the equipment, nor the site has changed since ACORN-SAT Version 1 was published in 2012.
Yet another 1 degree has been shaven from the historical temperature record!
To be clear, the weather station has been at the airport since February 1941, and an automatic weather station was installed on 1 October 1990. A Stevenson screen was first installed at the post office site in 1894, and has always been used at the airport site.
So, why was the temperature dropped down by a further one degree for 1 January 1910 in the most recent revision – undertaken just a few months ago? There is no logical or reasonable explanation.
Apparently, at the Bureau, the future is certain and the past can be continually changed - history can be continually revised.
When the daily values are added-up, and compared between versions as annual mean maximum temperatures we see the magnitude of the change - and its effect on temperature trends.
The warming trend of 1.3 degrees C per 100 years in ACORN V1 has been changed to 1.8 degrees C per 100 years in Version 2. The annual average maximum temperature for 1942, as one example, has been reduced by 0.5 degrees.

The extent of global warming increases from 1.3 degrees Celsius per 100 years to 1.8 degrees Celsius in the latest revisions by the Bureau to Australia's temperature history.
In the maximum temperature record as actually measured at Darwin from 1895 to the present -- and taking into consideration the move from the airport to the post office –- there is no warming trend in the Darwin temperature record. This is consistent with other locations in northern Australia with long high-quality records, for example Richmond in north western Queensland.

Annual mean maximum temperatures as measured at Richmond, Qld, charted with a minimally homogenized series for Darwin that combines the post office and airport series into one continuous temperature series making adjustments only for the move to the airport.

Mean maximum annual temperatures as measured at the Darwin Post Office and airport shown with the new remodeled ACORN-SAT Version 2, which is the new official record for Australia.
What the Bureau has done to the historical temperature record for Darwin is indefensible. The Bureau has artificially shortened and cooled Darwin's climate history to make it consistent with the theory of human-caused global warming.
Ends.
[…] https://climatelab.com.au/2019/02/changes-to-darwins-climate-history-are-not-logical/ […]
Dr. Andrew Johnson’s letter in The Australian on 20/2/19 claimed that the new version of Australia’s historical temperature record (ACORN V2) does not constitute a “rewriting the climate record”. How would we know? At the moment, the BOM’s adjustment “machine” seems more like a Black Box… all we get to see is the input and the output. We have very little idea of what goes on inside the Box.
If I, as a Software Designer of Accounting Systems, were in charge of the Software Design section of the BOM, I would rigorously enforce the creation of a comprehensive Audit Trail of all homogenization adjustments performed during the creation of a new version of ACORN.
Such an Audit Trail would show the original-as-read temperature; each adjustment made; the date and time of the adjustment; the ACORN version number, the reason for the adjustment (e.g. site move, time of observation, UHI etc); and all the variable data that went into the calculation of the adjustment. If there were multiple reasons to adjust a particular temperature reading, then each reason and the resulting adjustment would be recorded separately in the Audit Trail. You can think of it in Accounting terms as being the Opening Balance (original temp) + or – All Transactions (individual V1 and V2 Adjustments), giving the Closing Balance (V2 temp).
Then, in the interests of transparency and peer-review, I would publish on-line, with suitable search and analysis tools, the complete Audit Trail for the adjustments done in creating each Version of the ACORN dataset. This Audit Trail would also be a boon to the Testing and Peer Review Teams who presumably have to sign-off on the adjustments. The analysis tools would provide endless slicing-and-dicing possibilities that would readily highlight any anomalous adjustments.
How about it, Dr. Johnson? This isn’t Rocket Science, and yet he seems to be obfuscating for some reason. Taxpayers have paid for the BOM’s temperature data, and taxpayers pay his salary. We deserve so much more than a Black Box, especially in this critical area.
Jen: I really think that pushing for a detailed Audit Trail of each individual adjustment might be the best way of achieving an audit of the BOM, than pushing for an actual audit of the organisation, or chasing up anomalies at one or two stations. The detailed Audit Trail would open up the Black Box to more scrutiny.
Jennifer, thanks for your effort in bringing this folly to light, and I wish to note:
1. Changes in vegetation at Darwin post office up to 1940, Darwin had very intense cyclones in 1897 and 1937
2. In the 1960 the US were bombing Vietnam from Darwin (there were 2000 tons of bombs stored within view of the city) and Defence carried out major upgrades to the airport infrastructure (a Defence facility):
(a) the main runway was lengthed by some 50% and the width of the runway increased from the wingspan of a WWII bomber to that of a B52. The afternoon sea breeze traverses a proportion of this radiating surface ( if not most of its length my recollection about 4km) on its way to the BOM site
(b) a Bomber replenishment area some 100m x 50m x0.6 m thick concrete, and a smaller Fighter area some 0.4 m thickness were placed upwind of the BOM site, and would be heat sinks re radiating large quantities of heat for long periods
To minimise statements crying" Global warming", drain the cash trough. It worked with the hole in the ozone layer, dry trough, the problem went away and it is no longer a problem
The sensitivity of today's thermometers should be investigated. Apparently the BoM did some comparative testing but results have not been made public,
I have seen a 1C degree change within the same minute.
The classic example was Sydney's record temp of 45.8C in Jan 2013.
Just before it was 44.9C, just after it was 44.8C. Even the screen temp graph does not show the temp going above 45.0C.
So if the BoM claim the SS back then were showing a higher temp then they believe, it would be no higher than the new thermometers. Therefore, those temps should not be changed.
BTW, all readings of manual sites were done at 3:00pm. Did the earlier mercury/liquid thermometers have something in the tube to mark a temp increase after 3:00pm?
The treatment of the historical record is transparently self serving to the interests of the alarmist community.
The story of this vandalism of our history is vital and I greatly appreciate that you are playing a vital part in this.
Rational ethical behavior is precious and we desperately need more of it.
Keep up the good work.
On 22 February on Watts up with That , I wrote:
"What is odd about the Bureau’s claim regarding equipment is that the modified temperatures always go down. Why not up? After all, the greater sensitivity of today’s technology makes for higher temperatures; mercury simply did not, for it could not, react to a hot puff of air. It is all very confusing and leaves one with a nasty taste. And all this atop the strange dependence upon average temperatures; why not median?"
Setting median aside, it is perhaps noteworthy that this afternoon the observations for Mount Gambier (the airport) have two readings for three pm. The one labelled "high temp" says 35.5 °C. The other, the page devoted to Mount Gambier, has the same time at 35 °C. Must things become ever more confusing and leave one with an ever nastier taste?
I'm just filing this here, a snippet from my Sunday night interview with Chris Kenny ...
https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1187746904740255
And here is more on the 'scratched' Bourke record hot day ...
https://climatelab.com.au/2017/02/australias-hottest-day-record-ever-deleted/
Oh Jenny, here you go yet again - sweating the small stuff, devoting so much energy and intellect on 'proving' how the BOM has hoodwinked and lied to us all. If only you could devote even 10% of this energy towards some real stuff - like helping to rid the planet of plastic pollutants, reverse the disruption to Earth's fragile biodiversity and extinction of species, making the air over Beijing breathable again. Gawd, I could go on and on. This crusade is pointless and sucking up to idiots like Craig Kelly won't help your cause either.
[…] Reblogged from JenniferMarohasy.com […]
oh such a tangled web they weave