• Home
  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • Monitoring to Avoid Cyclone Damage – Denial. Part 3.
Events Information

Monitoring to Avoid Cyclone Damage – Denial. Part 3.

By jennifer
June 27, 2024
Monitoring to Avoid Cyclone Damage – Denial. Part 3.

It is purportedly the intension of The Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS), specifically their Long Term Monitoring program, to detect changes in reef communities at a number of different scales including at the scale of the individual reef, sub-region and between the northern, central and southern Great Barrier Reef.

But.  If this monitoring is not even able to detect the extraordinary damage inflicted by Tropical Cyclone Kirrily on John Brewer Reef  it cannot be considered fit for purpose.

To reiterate, John Brewer reef as an ecosystem was approaching climax, in all its beauty, when it was smashed by TC Kirrily early this year, on 25th January 2024.

This severe category three cyclone sat for two long hours over the top of this spectacular mid-shelf reef unleashing such destruction and yet the AIMS's monitoring program has no record of it.   According to their monitoring program there is nothing to see, they are in denial of this cyclone.

This reef, John Brewer reef, was surveyed in March 2022 and then again in June 2024 – and yet percentage coral cover change is little change: just 23 percent before TC Kirrily to now officially 17 percent in the latest June 2024 survey – and yet so much healthy, hard coral was destroyed in between!

I explained the extent of the damage to John Brewer reef, and included photographs, in a post entitled, Cyclone Kirrily Smashed my Favourite Coral Reef.

The coloured line shows where the AIMS survey looked for coral, and how much they found in June 2024.

The ‘core survey reef sample’, as explained by AIMS comprises ‘Manta tow surveys, which collect information in a standard reef slope habitat around the perimeter of each reef’.   The technique involves towing a snorkel diver at a constant speed behind a boat around the perimeter of each reef.   Every two minutes the observer records their visual assessment of hard coral cover onto a data sheet into one of five categories that correspond to very low (0-10%), low (10-30%), medium (30-50%), high (50-75%), and very high (75-100%) hard coral cover.

In the AIMS reports, and at the AIMS website that explains this, it is emphasised that ‘the methodology is consistent’, the tow is always ‘clockwise’ around the perimeter of each reef.

But what is the objective?  If it is to be able to report on changes in hard coral cover between reefs and across regions, then the observer needs to be ‘towed’ or otherwise given access to representative reef habitats.  It is pointless if the observer is towed away from the habitat where the fish tend to congregate, which is where there is more coral that is at the reef crest.

TC Kirrily did most damage at John Brewer reef in the shallower sections, including at the reef crest.   Yet the manta tow surveys around the reef perimeter are typically at a depth of 8-9 metres.   By their very design these surveys, that are at the core of the AIMS Long Term Monitoring program, they cannot capture disturbance from the major natural source of catastrophes that regularly befall coral reefs at the Great Barrier Reef – tropical cyclones.

Fish congregate at the reef crest where all the coral is, it is a bit of a way down to the reef slope that is the perimeter that is surveyed by AIMS. I visited that section of John Brewer Reef on July 10th, 2022, and made it down to the perimeter where there was not much coral.  I was on snorkel, holding my breath.

It doesn’t matter that the observer is always towed around the perimeter, and it doesn’t matter that this is always done in a clockwise direction if this is not where all the coral is, particularly the coral at a reef like John Brewer Reef before TC Kirrily – a coral reef approaching climax.

If the objective is to monitor change in coral cover, then habitats where coral is concentrated will need to be monitored as part of any program committed to understanding change.

According to Dr Mike Emslie, the leader of this project:

Information from LTMP has been instrumental in apprising the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA), government and stakeholders on the status of the GBR and uses web-based reporting products to ensure timely dissemination of information upon completion of each survey cruise. Upon completion of each field season, an online annual update on the status of the GBR is produced, along with substantial media exposure.

LTMP data also feeds directly into the five yearly GBR Outlook Report produced by the GBRMPA under the auspices of the Australian Governments Reef 2050 Sustainability Plan.

The monitoring program at John Brewer reef began in 1985, nearly forty years ago, yet as far as I can tell, never in all this time has any relevant data been consistently gathered about hard coral cover at the reef crest, where the coral and fish are concentrated.

If there is no relevant data, then we can’t know what the cumulative effects of more or fewer cyclones or bleaching events is on coral cover, not in any meaningful way.  Yet this is one of the key tax-payer funded programs, relied upon not just by my colleague Peter Ridd, but also government and the media to know the state of the Great Barrier Reef.

The little fish at the crest back on July 10 2022, they could look down to the perimeter where the AIMS's observers are towed about, apparently unaware that most of the coral was above them.   If the AIMS's surveys are to give an accurate indication of changes in coral cover, they need to consider coral cover in key habitats including at the reef crest.  This and the feature photograph, and the photographs above were taken at John Brewer Reef on July 10, 2022 with my Olympus TG6.

And, while there might be 3,000 coral reefs, John Brewer Reef is something of the jewel in the crown considering the central region of the Great Barrier Reef – something of greater value amongst other valuable things?   This coral reef to the north-east of Townsville was once home to a floating hotel, that was back in the 1980s.   More recently, and somewhat more modestly, John Brewer has been given its own Museum of Underwater Art.   It does matter that we know how hard coral cover at John Brewer reef changes, and what the key drivers are, of this change.

I have found it difficult that the response of most of my colleagues to this damage, not just the scientists at AIMS, but my colleagues at the IPA and also at Sky News has been to turn away; their response has mostly also been denial.   But.  It does matter that we acknowledge such destruction.  It does matter that we acknowledge what is happening at coral reefs like John Brewer reef, this is important for our collective conscious for the myths that emerge about who we are, and what we value.

The destruction after TC Kirrily. There may have been little change in the amount of coral around the perimeter because while much of it may have been washed away by the cyclone it was perhaps replaced by so much coral from the reef crest that had been picked-up, turned-over, and dropped-down to the perimeter of John Brewer reef.  Photograph by Stuart Ireland, of me (Jennifer Marohasy) and Paul Crocombe inspecting damage on February 15, 2024.

****

I've cross posted some of this text at my official Facebook page, that is where there is now most public discussion about what I write.  At the same time, I get little notes from Facebook warning me that I must respect 'community standards' and so I am never sure if I'm going to have my account there suspended.  This has happened before.  Of course, there is also the possibility that I could lose my Facebook account altogether; I have a habit of offending gatekeeper.   Anyway, I thought it worth crossposting this comment from Facebook:

Boydington Scott III

I have witnessed the damage to coral reefs by cyclones off the Cassowary Coast and offshore from the Daintree over the past 35 years and more, the reef crest is most affected by the waves /swell whipped up by cyclonic winds and the accompanying heavy rain also bleaches the shallower water corals on those reefs. In the deeper sections over 7m, I’ve witnessed large coral structures split in two and other such damage from the incredible turbidity of the sea during these events. It looks dreadful for a year or so but the damage is never permanent and I saw local reefs recover twice after being hit hard by Cyclone Larry (2006) and Yasi (2011). This damage needs to be acknowledged as it is further evidence of the resilience of our Great Barrier Reef.
Good Causes

Comments

  1. […] As mad as this may sound, there is now opportunity for this famous coral to be part of the AIMS survey and it presumably was included in June, because the coral has been lost from the reef proper and is now at the perimeter of this coral reef, and AIMS are reporting an increase in coral cover at John Brewer Reef while denying the cyclone.  I’ve written in detail about this just recently, CLICK HERE. […]

  2. Thanks Karen,
    That is the easy stuff: correct filter and camera settings. Stabilisation is never an issue with a DJI drone. Yep. Tick.
    But. Then there is the issue of how far below the water surface the corals are, visibility in-water, the extent of the surface current and swell, and on it goes.
    And how is it, that in March 2020 the AIMS in-water survey reported no bleaching and yet the aerial survey reported severe bleaching ...at John Brewer Reef?

  3. Are you using a good quality digital SLR camera fitted with either a 24-70mm or a 70 – 300mm zoom lens. A circular polarising filter is essential for reducing glare and improving the clarity of underwater features and corals beneath the surface. Since the images “move” fast, use the fastest shutter speed your camera will allow in the light conditions. Shutter speeds of <1/1000th second are recommended. To achieve this, it may be necessary to reduce the F-stop (open the aperture, e.g. F1.8 - F5.6) and use a moderately high ISO number for increased light sensitivity (e.g. 800-1800 depending on the light conditions, modern full frame mirrorless cameras can use even higher ISO settings without losing pixel clarity up to 4000 or higher, but by rule use the lowest ISO settings to give less “grainy” images). Turn the automatic image stabilization feature on your camera to “ON” and try not to support the camera (or arm, shoulder, elbow) on the side of the plane to minimize image blurring due to vibration.

  4. Thanks Karen,

    I have a DJI Mavic drone with a zoom lense. Put that up over a body of water and see how much you can see into the water from 120 metres. It does vary with the time of day and the amount of wind and how sunny the day is, but basically you can't see far into the water even when conditions are near perfect, and then there is the issue of the coral growing down the walls/the drop offs.

    The other thing I have done is visited reefs that according to aerial surveys are stuffed, and I've found no bleaching from an in water survey.

    And while the AIMS aerial surveys were calling John Brewer reef 'severely bleached' in March 2022, the in water manta surveys reported no bleaching. Same organisation different method, and completely different result.

    There is some discussion of this in a film I made some time ago that you can watch here: https://vimeo.com/775205373

    Cheers,

  5. I notice that you again claim that your use of drones refutes the validity of AIMS aerial photography. What type of camera is your drone fitted with. Are you following the same detailed guidelines for this type of survey laid out by AIMS?

Write a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *